| Issue | #5 |
| Published | July 1972 |
| Frequency | monthly |
| Cover Price | 0.50 USD |
| Pages | 164 |
| Editing | ? |
| Notes | 92051-207 |
| Genre | occult |
| Pencils | ? (painting) |
| Inks | ? (painting) |
| Colors | ? (painting) |
| Pencils | Al McWilliams |
| Inks | Al McWilliams |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Tales of Mystery (Gold Key, 1963 series) #11 (September 1965) |
| Genre | occult |
| Script | Don Glut |
| Pencils | Dan Spiegle |
| Inks | Dan Spiegle |
| Letters | Bill Spicer |
| Script | Dick Wood |
| Pencils | Fred Fredericks |
| Inks | Fred Fredericks |
| Colors | Fred Fredericks |
| Letters | Fred Fredericks |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Tales of Mystery (Gold Key, 1963 series) #10 (June 1965) |
| Pencils | Joe Orlando |
| Inks | Joe Orlando |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Tales of Mystery (Gold Key, 1963 series) #12 (December 1965) |
| Genre | horror |
| Pencils | Tom Gill |
| Inks | Tom Gill |
| Letters | Tom Gill ? |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Thriller (Gold Key, 1962 series) #1 (October 1962) |
| Pencils | Luis Dominguez |
| Inks | Luis Dominguez |
| Letters | typeset |
| Genre | occult |
| Script | Don Glut |
| Pencils | Dan Spiegle |
| Inks | Dan Spiegle |
| Letters | Bill Spicer |
| Characters | Cecil Matthews (death); Fred; Mr. Johnson; Charlie |
| Synopsis | Cecil Matthews is a bank employee who is sick of his job. He steals $30,000 and flys to Hawaii where he plans to charter a plane to Papinee, an island he found in an old "Islands of Paradise" book. The bank notices the theft before he can get to Papinee so he hijacks a mail plane to fly him there. Once there he kills the pilot and settles in at the deserted village. What Cecil doesn't know is that the reason the village is deserted is that the Island of Papinee was chosen by the Government to use in a missile test. The next day he is destroyed when the bomb is detonated on the island. |
| Pencils | Dan Spiegle |
| Inks | Dan Spiegle |
| Letters | WCL (Gold Key/Dell West Coast Letterer) |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Thriller (Gold Key, 1962 series) #2 (January 1963) |
| Script | Dick Wood |
| Pencils | Mel Crawford |
| Inks | Mel Crawford |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Tales of Mystery (Gold Key, 1963 series) #7 (September 1964) |
| Pencils | Joe Certa |
| Inks | Joe Certa |
| Letters | typeset |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Tales of Mystery (Gold Key, 1963 series) #15 (September 1966) |
| Pencils | Win Mortimer |
| Inks | Win Mortimer |
| Letters | John D'Agostino |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Tales of Mystery (Gold Key, 1963 series) #17 (March 1967) |
| Script | Dick Wood |
| Pencils | Alex Toth |
| Inks | Alex Toth |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Tales of Mystery (Gold Key, 1963 series) #5 [October 1963] (October 1963) |
| Genre | occult |
| Script | Don Glut |
| Pencils | Dan Spiegle |
| Inks | Dan Spiegle |
| Letters | Bill Spicer |
| Notes | 1st appearance of Dr Spektor, he is simply a narrator here. |
| Pencils | Mel Crawford |
| Inks | Mel Crawford |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Tales of Mystery (Gold Key, 1963 series) #15 (September 1966) |
| Pencils | Frank Thorne |
| Inks | Frank Thorne |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Reprinted | from Boris Karloff Tales of Mystery (Gold Key, 1963 series) #8 (December 1964) |