Return Policy

If your order was lost or damaged in transit

Please let us know as soon as possible. We will credit your account with us, refund you, or reship all or part of the order, as appropriate.

If the order was damaged, keep the packaging! We may need it to file for insurance on the package; it may be difficult to refund you if we aren't able to process our claim. You must inform us of any damage to your order within seven business days of receipt.

If you believe we have overgraded a comic

Please let us know within seven business days of receipt. We will either credit your account, refund you, or ask you to return the item for inspection.

In the case of an item returned for inspection, if our senior graders agree that we made an error, we will refund you the purchase price and reimburse you for the cost of shipping. If our senior graders determine that the books do meet our Overstreet-based standards, we will refund you the purchase price only.

Comics graded by CGC are not returnable.

If we have sent you the wrong book or failed to send a book

Please let us know, preferably within seven business days of receipt. We will credit your account, refund you, or ship the proper item, as appropriate. If we need you to return the book, we will reimburse you for basic ground shipping.

If you wish to sell a book back to us

If we have sold you a book, it may be returned as above. If you wish to sell us a book back via our buy/trade system, we will consider it a new book and we will buy it as we grade it during check-in. We do not guarantee we will buy it at the same grade we sold it — we guarantee only that once bought, we will sell it as we bought it.