| Issue | #4 |
| Published | June-July 1974 |
| Frequency | bi-monthly |
| Cover Price | 0.20 USD |
| Pages | 36 |
| Editing | Joe Simon |
| Characters | Sarah; Crane |
| Genre | Occult |
| Pencils | Joe Simon; Jack Kirby |
| Inks | Joe Simon; Jack Kirby |
| Notes | Simon re-used the rejected artwork for Black Magic #1 (Prize series) for this cover. |
| Characters | Mary Higgens; Mary's mother; Old Min |
| Synopsis | Mary Higgens goes to Old Min for help to stop her daughter from partying all night long, and is given a pair of magic scissors. |
| Genre | Occult |
| Pencils | George Roussos |
| Inks | George Roussos |
| Editing | Joe Simon (original editor); Jack Kirby (original editor) |
| Reprinted | from Black Magic (Prize, 1950 series) #v1 #6 [6] (August-September 1951) |
| Characters | Karl Werner; Hilda Werner; Gustave Werner; Frederick; Frau Hoff |
| Synopsis | Gustave tries to prevent his son Karl from joining the tradition of the Werner family, where every man becomes the hangman. |
| Genre | horror |
| Pencils | Mort Meskin |
| Inks | Mort Meskin |
| Editing | Joe Simon (original editor); Jack Kirby (original editor) |
| Reprinted | from Black Magic (Prize, 1950 series) #v1 #1 [1] (October-November 1950) |
| Letters | Typeset |
| Editing | Joe Simon (original editor); Jack Kirby (original editor) |
| Reprinted | from Black Magic (Prize, 1950 series) #v2 #12 [18] |
| Characters | Matthew Crane; George Berger; Dr. Herbert Michaels; Joshua Benton; Fred Saunders; Sarah Russell |
| Synopsis | Matthew Crane discovers the secret of the afterlife from the last words of a dying girl, and it drives him insane. |
| Genre | horror |
| Pencils | Joe Simon; Jack Kirby |
| Inks | Joe Simon; Jack Kirby |
| Editing | Joe Simon (original editor); Jack Kirby (original editor) |
| Reprinted | from Black Magic (Prize, 1950 series) #v1 #1 [1] (October-November 1950) |