| Issue | #4 |
| Published | 1971 |
| Cover Price | 0.50 USD |
| Pages | 100 |
| Editing | Joe Orlando |
| Genre | horror |
| Pencils | Bernie Wrightson (signed) |
| Inks | Bernie Wrightson (signed) |
| Notes | Creature reprint spotted by Frank Battaglia (submitted via the error list, December 2006). |
| Reprinted | in House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #229 [creature only] |
| Genre | occult; humor |
| Pencils | Sergio Aragones (signed) |
| Inks | Sergio Aragones (signed) |
| Letters | typeset |
| Notes | Inside front cover. |
| Characters | Berni Wrightson |
| Genre | occult |
| Script | Joe Orlando? |
| Pencils | Berni Wrightson |
| Inks | Berni Wrightson |
| Notes | Introduction page. |
| Genre | fantasy |
| Pencils | Mort Drucker |
| Inks | Mort Drucker |
| Reprinted | from My Greatest Adventure (DC, 1955 series) #8. |
| Genre | fantasy |
| Pencils | Carmine Infantino |
| Inks | Sy Barry |
| Reprinted | from Sensation Mystery (DC, 1952 series) #116. |
| Genre | humor |
| Pencils | Dave Manak ? |
| Inks | Dave Manak ? |
| Genre | fantasy |
| Pencils | Mort Meskin |
| Inks | Mort Meskin |
| Reprinted | from My Greatest Adventure (DC, 1955 series) #14. |
| Genre | humor |
| Script | ?; ?; ? |
| Pencils | ?; ?; ? |
| Inks | ?; ?; ? |
| Notes | Three gag pages. Not sure if they are by the same artist or more than one artist. |
| Genre | occult |
| Pencils | John Prentice |
| Inks | John Prentice |
| Reprinted | from House of Secrets (DC, 1956 series) #2. |
| Genre | humor |
| Pencils | Sergio Aragones |
| Inks | Sergio Aragones |
| Notes | Three gag panels. |
| Characters | Berni Wrightson |
| Genre | occult |
| Pencils | Berni Wrightson |
| Inks | Berni Wrightson |
| Genre | fantasy |
| Pencils | Mort Meskin |
| Inks | Mort Meskin |
| Reprinted | from My Greatest Adventure (DC, 1955 series) #12. |
| Genre | humor |
| Script | ?; ?; ? |
| Pencils | ?; ?; ? |
| Inks | ?; ?; ? |
| Notes | Three gag panels. Not sure how many artists. |
| Characters | Johnny Peril |
| Genre | fantasy |
| Pencils | Frank Giacoia (signed) |
| Inks | Sy Barry (signed) |
| Reprinted | from Sensation Mystery (DC, 1952 series) #110. |
| Characters | Phantom Stranger |
| Genre | occult |
| Script | John Broome |
| Pencils | Carmine Infantino |
| Inks | Sy Barry |
| Reprinted | from Phantom Stranger, The (DC, 1952 series) #1 (August-September 1952) |
| Characters | Berni Wrightson |
| Genre | occult |
| Pencils | Berni Wrightson |
| Inks | Berni Wrightson |
| Genre | science fiction |
| Pencils | Jim Mooney |
| Inks | Jim Mooney |
| Reprinted | from My Greatest Adventure (DC, 1955 series) #20. |
| Genre | fantasy |
| Pencils | Nick Cardy |
| Inks | Nick Cardy |
| Reprinted | from My Greatest Adventure (DC, 1955 series) #15. |
| Characters | Berni Wrightson |
| Genre | science fiction |
| Pencils | Berni Wrightson |
| Inks | Berni Wrightson |
| Genre | humor |
| Pencils | Sergio Aragones |
| Inks | Sergio Aragones |
| Notes | Four one-panel gags. |
| Genre | science fiction |
| Pencils | Mort Meskin |
| Inks | Mort Meskin |
| Reprinted | from Tales of the Unexpected (DC, 1956 series) #15. |
| Genre | science fiction |
| Pencils | Lou Cameron (signed) |
| Inks | Lou Cameron (signed) |
| Reprinted | from Tales of the Unexpected (DC, 1956 series) #24. |
| Genre | occult |
| Pencils | Berni Wrightson (signed) |
| Inks | Berni Wrightson (signed) |
| Letters | typeset |
| Characters | Bart Evans |
| Genre | science fiction |
| Pencils | Leonard Starr |
| Inks | Leonard Starr |
| Reprinted | from House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #49. |
| Genre | humor |
| Script | Lore Shoberg [as Lore] |
| Pencils | Lore Shoberg [as Lore] |
| Inks | Lore Shoberg [as Lore] |
| Notes | Inside back cover. Three gag panels. |
| Genre | horror |
| Pencils | Berni Wrightson (signed) |
| Inks | Berni Wrightson (signed) |
| Notes | Same as front cover, sans title and trade dress. |