| Issue | #4 |
| Published | July - September 1969 |
| Cover Price | 0.25 |
| Pages | 68 |
| Editing | Joe Orlando |
| Notes | First appearance of Abel is in this issue. Abel first appeared in House of Secrets #81 which has a date of August/September of 1969, one month after this issue. |
| Pencils | Neal Adams |
| Inks | Neal Adams |
| Notes | First appearance of Abel is in this issue. Abel first appeared in House of Secrets #81 which has a date of August/September of 1969, one month after this issue. |
| Script | Mark Hannerfeld |
| Pencils | Bill Draut |
| Inks | Bill Draut |
| Notes | framing sequence |
| Pencils | Ed Smalle |
| Inks | Ed Smalle |
| Notes | Reprint information from James Zanotto via the GCD Errors list, January 2010. |
| Reprinted | from House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #9 (December 1952) [with splash panel removed] |
| Pencils | Jack Kirby |
| Inks | Jack Kirby |
| Notes | orig title: "The Magic Stick" |
| Reprinted | from House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #68 (November 1957) |
| Reprinted | from House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #5 (August 1952) |
| Pencils | Jerry Grandenetti |
| Inks | Ray Burnley |
| Reprinted | from House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #15 (December 1952) |
| Pencils | Leonard Starr |
| Inks | Leonard Starr |
| Reprinted | from Tales of the Unexpected (DC, 1956 series) #1 (February-March 1956) |
| Pencils | George Roussos |
| Inks | George Roussos |
| Reprinted | from House of Secrets (DC, 1956 series) #62 (September-October 1963) |
| Pencils | Carmine Infantino |
| Inks | Joe Giella |
| Reprinted | from Sensation Mystery (DC, 1952 series) #114 (March-April 1953) |
| Pencils | Sheldon Moldoff |
| Inks | Sheldon Moldoff |
| Reprinted | from House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #30 (September 1954) |
| Pencils | George Papp |
| Inks | George Papp |
| Reprinted | from House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #26 (May 1954) |
| Pencils | John Prentice |
| Inks | John Prentice |
| Reprinted | from House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #2 (February-March 1952) |
| Pencils | Gene Colan |
| Inks | Gene Colan |
| Reprinted | from House of Secrets (DC, 1956 series) #63 (November-December 1963) |
| Pencils | Bernard Baily |
| Inks | Bernard Baily |
| Reprinted | from Tales of the Unexpected (DC, 1956 series) #17 (September 1957) |
| Pencils | Ruben Moreira |
| Inks | Ruben Moreira |
| Reprinted | from House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #19 (October 1953) |