| Issue | #1 |
| Published | September 1965 |
| Frequency | Bi-Monthly |
| Cover Price | 0.35 USD |
| Pages | 24 |
| Editing | James Warren |
| Genre | Horror |
| Letters | Ben Oda (logo) |
| Characters | Monica Cerulean; Brian Cerulean; Bluebeard; Fatima (Death); Uncle Creepy (Host) |
| Synopsis | Monica’s new life married to Brian is very lonely and soon she begins to suspect that he spends time away from her because he is in reality Bluebeard! |
| Genre | Horror |
| Script | Bill Pearson |
| Pencils | Joe Orlando (signed) |
| Inks | Joe Orlando (signed) |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Notes | The Script and Letters credit comes from the index to Creepy #7. |
| Reprinted | in Creepy (Warren, 1964 series) #7 (February 1966); in Creepy The Classic Years (Harris Comics, 1991 series) #[nn] (1991) |
| Characters | Uncle Creepy (Host) |
| Synopsis | A mysterious plane shoots down both Germans and Americans during World War I. One unlucky pilot sent to shoot down the plane manages to see the face of the one piloting this plane, although he wishes he hadn’t. |
| Genre | Horror |
| Script | Larry Ivie |
| Pencils | George Evans (signed) |
| Inks | George Evans (signed) |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Notes | The Script and Letters credit comes from the index to Creepy #8. |
| Reprinted | in Creepy (Warren, 1964 series) #8 (April 1966) |
| Characters | Dr. John Cabore; Baron Von Renfield; Eva; Boris Hedra (Death, returned as vampire); Dr. Kovac (Death, returned as vampire); Hugo (Death, returned as vampire) |
| Synopsis | Vampires find it easy to get victims by inviting them to their home. |
| Genre | Horror |
| Script | Larry Engleheart; Russ Jones?; Maurice Whitman? |
| Pencils | Manny Stallman |
| Inks | Manny Stallman |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Notes | Uncle Creepy is not in this story but he is in the reprint in Creepy #8. The Script and Letters credit comes from the index to Creepy #8. |
| Reprinted | in Creepy (Warren, 1964 series) #8 (April 1966) |
| Characters | Cousin Eerie (host); Countess Ersze Bathory; John George Haigh |
| Synopsis | The lore of vampirism and the history of vampires Countess Ersze Bathory and John George Haigh. |
| Genre | Horror |
| Script | Archie Goodwin |
| Pencils | Bob Lubbers (signed) |
| Inks | Bob Lubbers (signed) |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Editing | Russ Jones (Original Editor); Archie Goodwin (Original Story Editor) |
| Notes | Letters credit from the index of Creepy #2, Uncle Creepy has been replaced by a very crude Cousin Eerie. Inside back cover. |
| Reprinted | from Creepy (Warren, 1964 series) #2 (1965) |