| Issue | #23 |
| Published | September 1969 |
| Frequency | Bi-Monthly |
| Cover Price | 0.50 USD |
| Pages | 68 |
| Editing | Bill Parente |
| Notes | cover art is the Frank Frazetta painting "Egyptian Queen" |
| Genre | period; good girl |
| Pencils | Frank Frazetta (painting) |
| Inks | Frank Frazetta (painting) |
| Colors | Frank Frazetta (painting) |
| Notes | cover art is the Frank Frazetta painting "Egyptian Queen" |
| Reprinted | in Eerie Annual (Warren, 1971 series) #1971 (1971) [1/16 page] |
| Notes | B&W house ads for Blazing Combat, Eerie, Famous Monsters, Screen Thrills Illustrated, and Creepy back issues; 0.5 page B&W house ad for Creepy Fan Club |
| Characters | Cousin Eerie |
| Script | Bill Parente? |
| Pencils | Ernie Colon; Tony Tallarico [as Tony Williamsune]; Bob Jenney; Tom Sutton; Neal Adams; Mike Royer |
| Inks | Ernie Colon; Tony Tallarico [as Tony Williamsune]; Bob Jenney; Tom Sutton; Neal Adams; Mike Royer |
| Letters | typeset |
| Notes | illustrated with art from pages 6, 13, 17, 22, 24, 31, 45, and 46 of issue |
| Characters | Cousin Eerie |
| Letters | typeset |
| Synopsis | Egyptian sorceress tries to become immortal. |
| Genre | period; occult; horror |
| Script | Bill Parente |
| Pencils | Ernie Colon |
| Inks | Ernie Colon |
| Notes | story inspired by Frank Frazetta cover painting |
| Synopsis | Evil tyrant hunts dragons. |
| Genre | fantasy |
| Script | Kim Ball |
| Pencils | Tony Williamsune [Tony Tallarico] |
| Inks | Tony Williamsune [Tony Tallarico] |
| Synopsis | American Civil War soldiers try to hang civilian. |
| Genre | period; horror |
| Script | Archie Goodwin |
| Pencils | Bob Jenney |
| Inks | Bob Jenney |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Notes | adaptation of Ambrose Bierce short story |
| Reprinted | from Eerie (Warren, 1966 series) #9 (May 1967) |
| Characters | Cousin Eerie; Edward E. French |
| Genre | occult; horror |
| Script | Timothy Boertlein; Bill Parente? |
| Pencils | Bruce Jones; ? (photo) |
| Letters | typeset |
| Notes | contains two short text stories; an essay about a fan writing contest second place winner; pencilled fan art; B&W photo of writing contest winner |
| Synopsis | Nuclear war survivors find pool with unusual properties. |
| Genre | occult; science fiction; horror |
| Script | Edward E. French |
| Pencils | Tom Sutton |
| Inks | Tom Sutton |
| Notes | adaptation of fan writing contest second place winning story |
| Notes | 8 pages of B&W Captain Co. ads for Venus fly traps, 8mm films and projector, LPs, decals, model kits, Prince Valiant collections, paperback books, and posters; backcover: 0.5 page two colour Captain Co. ad for Dark Shadows books and 0.5 page two colour Howard F. Rogofsky ad for comic back issues & other collectibles |
| Synopsis | Man seeks immortality through surgery. |
| Genre | occult; science fiction; horror |
| Script | Archie Goodwin |
| Pencils | Neal Adams |
| Inks | Neal Adams |
| Reprinted | from Eerie (Warren, 1966 series) #9 (May 1967) |
| Synopsis | Vampire tries time-travelling. |
| Genre | occult; science fiction; horror |
| Script | James Haggenmiller |
| Pencils | Mike Royer |
| Inks | Mike Royer |
| Characters | Uncle Creepy; Cousin Eerie; Vampirella? |
| Genre | horror; humour |
| Script | Bill Parente? |
| Pencils | Tony Tallarico? |
| Inks | Tony Tallarico? |
| Notes | promo pinup for mystery character; art credits not given |
| Genre | sports |
| Script | Frank Frazetta? |
| Pencils | Frank Frazetta |
| Inks | Frank Frazetta |
| Letters | Frank Frazetta? |
| Notes | anti-smoking PSA |
| Reprinted | from Creepy (Warren, 1964 series) #9 (June 1966) |