| Issue | #5 |
| Published | April 1974 |
| Cover Price | 0.75 USD |
| Pages | 68 |
| Editing | Al Hewetson |
| Genre | horror |
| Pencils | Fernando |
| Inks | Fernando |
| Genre | horror |
| Script | Al Hewetson |
| Pencils | Ricardo Villamonte |
| Inks | Ricardo Villamonte |
| Notes | Continued from Nightmare #17. Next in Nightmare #19. |
| Script | Augustine Funnell |
| Letters | Typeset |
| Genre | horror |
| Script | Al Hewetson [as Howie Anderson] |
| Pencils | Alphonso Font |
| Inks | Alphonso Font |
| Genre | horror |
| Script | Edgar Allan Poe (short story); Al Hewetson (adaptation) |
| Pencils | Maro Nava |
| Inks | Maro Nava |
| Notes | Adaptation of the short story "The Cask of Amontillado" by Edgar Allan Poe. |
| Reprinted | in Edgar Allan Poe: The Murders in the Rue Morgue (Eternity, 1989 series) #1. |
| Genre | horror |
| Script | Al Hewetson [as Stuart Williams] |
| Pencils | Jose Cardona |
| Inks | Jose Cardona |
| Genre | horror |
| Script | Edgar Allan Poe (poems); Al Hewetson (adaptation) |
| Pencils | Domingo Gomez |
| Inks | Domingo Gomez |
| Notes | Adaptation of some of the poems by Edgar Allan Poe. |
| Reprinted | in Edgar Allan Poe: The Black Cat and Other Stories (Malibu, 1989 series) #1 |
| Genre | horror |
| Script | Al Hewetson |
| Pencils | Ricardo Villamonte |
| Inks | Ricardo Villamonte |
| Notes | Pages 4 and 5 are out of order. |
| Genre | horror |
| Script | Augustine Funnell |
| Pencils | Emilo Bernardo |
| Inks | Emilo Bernardo |
| Genre | horror |
| Script | Oscar Wilde (novel); Al Hewetson (adaptation) |
| Pencils | Zesar Lopez |
| Inks | Zesar Lopez |
| Notes | Adaptation of the novel "The Picture of Dorian Gray" by Oscar Wilde. |
| Genre | horror |
| Pencils | Fernando |
| Inks | Fernando |
| Letters | typeset |
| Notes | Pen-and-ink version of the cover, used as an ad for the proposed Tomb Of Horror title. |