| Issue | #4 |
| Published | November 1963 |
| Cover Price | 0.12 USD |
| Pages | 36 |
| Editing | Richard Goldwater |
| Characters | Josie; Josie's mom; Albert; Alexander Cabot III; un-named boy |
| Genre | humor |
| Pencils | Bob White |
| Notes | No credits, but the drawing style appears to be White's. This is the first Josie cover not drawn by Dan DeCarlo. |
| Characters | Josie; Melody; Pepper; Albert; Mr. Tuttle; un-named kids |
| Synopsis | Melody becomes head of the school Anti-Superstition League and tries to show everyone that it's bad luck to be superstitious. |
| Genre | humor |
| Script | Frank Doyle |
| Pencils | Dan DeCarlo |
| Notes | Writing identifiable as Frank Doyle by his style and DeCarlo's statement that Doyle did "all the writing" for the early Josies. |
| Characters | Josie |
| Synopsis | Josie models a bathing suit design suggested by readers. |
| Genre | fashion |
| Pencils | Dan DeCarlo |
| Characters | Melody |
| Synopsis | Melody models a reader-designed, music-themed outfit. |
| Genre | fashion |
| Pencils | Dan DeCarlo |
| Characters | Josie; Pepper; Alexander Cabot III |
| Synopsis | Josie and Pepper, clad in backpacks and short shorts, are looking for a forest so they can pass their Woodsman test for the Girl Guides. Alex takes them to a specially-built jungle in the back of his estate. |
| Genre | humor |
| Script | Frank Doyle |
| Pencils | Dan DeCarlo |
| Characters | Josie; Pepper; Albert; un-named kids |
| Synopsis | Albert is feeling depressed because Pepper is a better athlete than he is. |
| Genre | humor |
| Script | Frank Doyle |
| Pencils | Dan DeCarlo |
| Genre | fact |
| Letters | Typeset |
| Characters | Li'l Jinx; Hap Holliday |
| Genre | humor; children |
| Script | Joe Edwards |
| Pencils | Joe Edwards |
| Inks | Joe Edwards |
| Letters | Joe Edwards |
| Characters | Josie; Melody; Pepper; Albert; un-named boys |
| Synopsis | Melody's figure is causing all the boys to get distracted and crash into walls. So Josie and Pepper disguise her as an old woman to prevent her from causing damage. |
| Genre | humor |
| Script | Frank Doyle |
| Pencils | Dan DeCarlo |