| Issue | #5 |
| Published | April-May 1953 |
| Cover Price | 0.10 USD |
| Pages | 36 |
| Editing | Whitney Ellsworth |
| Genre | occult |
| Pencils | Murphy Anderson |
| Inks | Bernard Sachs |
| Characters | Phantom Stranger |
| Genre | occult |
| Script | John Broome |
| Pencils | Carmine Infantino |
| Inks | Bernard Sachs |
| Reprinted | in House of Mystery (DC, 1951 series) #226 (August-September 1974); in Showcase Presents: The House of Mystery (DC, 2006 series) #3 |
| Script | Morris Waldinger |
| Pencils | Morris Waldinger |
| Inks | Morris Waldinger |
| Genre | occult |
| Script | John Broome |
| Pencils | Murphy Anderson |
| Inks | Joe Giella |
| Genre | superhero |
| Script | Jack Schiff |
| Pencils | Win Mortimer |
| Inks | Win Mortimer |
| Letters | Ira Schnapp |
| Script | Jack Miller |
| Pencils | John Giunta |
| Inks | John Giunta |
| Script | Jack Miller |
| Pencils | Raymond Perry |
| Inks | Raymond Perry |
| Letters | typeset |
| Notes | text w/illo |
| Characters | Villain: Vasti the Fortune Teller |
| Genre | occult |
| Script | John Broome |
| Pencils | Frank Giacoia |
| Inks | Joe Giella |
| Reprinted | in Phantom Stranger, The (DC, 1969 series) #3 [incorporated into: "How Do You Know My Name?"]; in Showcase Presents Phantom Stranger (DC, 2006 series) #1 |
| Script | Morris Waldinger |
| Pencils | Morris Waldinger |
| Inks | Morris Waldinger |
| Script | Morris Waldinger |
| Pencils | Morris Waldinger |
| Inks | Morris Waldinger |