| Issue | #2 |
| Published | 1989 |
| Cover Price | 2.95 USD; 3.65 CAD; 1.20 GBP |
| Pages | 68 |
| Editing | Mark Waid |
| Characters | Santa Claus; Superman; Wonder Woman [Diana Prince]; Green Lantern [Hal Jordan]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Nightwing [Dick Grayson]; Aquaman [Arthur Curry]; Flash [Barry Allen]; Plastic Man; Hawkman [Katar Hol]; Atom [Ray Palmer] |
| Genre | Superhero |
| Pencils | Stephen DeStefano (signed) |
| Inks | Larry Mahlstedt (signed) |
| Characters | Superman |
| Synopsis | Superman helps a stranded motorist. |
| Genre | superhero |
| Script | Paul Chadwick |
| Pencils | Paul Chadwick |
| Inks | John Nyberg |
| Colors | Tom McCraw |
| Letters | John Costanza |
| Characters | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Alfred; Robin [Dick Grayson] |
| Synopsis | Alfred considers the contrast of light and dark in the Batman's life and the winter holidays. |
| Genre | superhero |
| Script | Dave Gibbons |
| Pencils | Gray Morrow |
| Inks | Gray Morrow |
| Colors | Gray Morrow |
| Letters | John Costanza |
| Characters | Wonder Woman [Diana]; Hippolyta; Myndi Mayer; Hermes; Zeus; Julia Kapatelis; Sharon Jackson; Vanessa Kapatelis |
| Synopsis | When a pastor friend of Julia's comes for the holidays, Diana helps her recover her faith in God as she helps Diana recover her faith in her gods. |
| Genre | superhero |
| Script | Eric Shanower |
| Pencils | Eric Shanower |
| Inks | Eric Shanower |
| Colors | Tom McCraw |
| Letters | Eric Shanower |
| Characters | Enemy Ace [Hans von Hammer] |
| Synopsis | Enemy Ace delivers supplies to an allied hospital on Christmas Day. |
| Genre | war |
| Script | John Byrne |
| Pencils | John Byrne |
| Inks | Andy Kubert (finished art) |
| Colors | Glenn Whitmore |
| Notes | Story is told without dialogue. |
| Characters | Flash [Barry Allen]; Green Lantern [Hal Jordan]; C.B. Fenster |
| Synopsis | Flash and Green Lantern prove to a depressed wealthy man that Santa Claus does exist. |
| Genre | Superhero |
| Script | Bill Loebs |
| Pencils | Colleen Doran |
| Inks | Ty Templeton |
| Colors | Glenn Whitmore |
| Letters | Albert De Guzman |
| Characters | Deadman; Kara |
| Synopsis | Another spirit reminds Deadman what it is to be a real hero. |
| Genre | Superhero; Occult |
| Script | Alan Brennert |
| Pencils | Dick Giordano |
| Inks | Dick Giordano |
| Colors | Tom McCraw |
| Letters | Steve Haynie |
| Notes | Kara is the ghost of the pre-Crisis Supergirl. |