| Issue | #4 |
| Published | January 1998 |
| Cover Price | $2.50 |
| Pages | 28 |
| Editing | Jason Asala |
| Characters | Poe |
| Pencils | Jason Asala |
| Inks | Jason Asala |
| Colors | Deborah Marett (credited for Gray-O-Vision) |
| Letters | Jason Asala |
| Characters | Poe; Roderick Usher; Mehlia |
| Script | Jason Asala |
| Pencils | Jason Asala |
| Inks | Jason Asala |
| Colors | Deborah Marett (credited for Gray-O-Vision) |
| Letters | Jason Asala |
| Notes | Continues from Poe #3. |
| Synopsis | Jason Asala appears in convention photos. |
| Script | Jason Asala |
| Script | Jason Asala |
| Pencils | Jason Asala |
| Inks | Jason Asala |
| Colors | Deborah Marett |
| Notes | Kay Rosenblum of Atlanta, Georgia, won Edgar's Puzzle Page #3. |
| Synopsis | Recommendation of other comic books: Levi's World and The Borden Tragedy. |
| Script | Jason Asala |
| Pencils | Levi Krause; Rick Geary. |
| Characters | Levi; Poe; Pluto. |
| Synopsis | Poe dreams of Levi's World. |
| Script | Edgar Allan Poe; Levi Krause |
| Pencils | Levi Krause |
| Inks | Levi Krause |
| Letters | Levi Krause |
| Notes | Text is E.A. Poe's "Eulalie," modified by Levi Krause. |
| Characters | Poe |
| Script | Jason Asala |
| Pencils | Jason Asala |
| Inks | Jason Asala |
| Colors | Jason Asala |
| Letters | Jason Asala |
| Notes | Colorized panel from this issue |