Consignment Service Overview

How to consign - if you already know you want to consign, click here to get started. Otherwise keep reading for an overview of what our consignment service can do for you and how it works.

What can be consigned?

• Any comic graded by CGC, CBCS, or PSA. Any grade, any value.
• Comic book original art
• Any "raw" (not slabbed) comic book with an estimated retail value of about $50 or more is eligible for consignment. You can look up any issue in our online buying database and it will tell you the minimum grade that would be eligible for consignment based on our estimated retail values for that issue. If you are not a comic collector and are unfamiliar with comic prices, please be aware that most comics published 1980 or later, and many lower grade comics from the 1960s and 1970s, will not be valuable enough to be eligible for consignment.

What is consignment?

Consignment is the easiest way to sell your higher value comics and comic art for the best price with the least effort.

We are happy to buy your comics outright, and many sellers choose that option. We buy everything from $2 comics to high value Golden Age books over $100,000, and everything in between. However, as a retailer we cannot pay the full market value of an item when buying it, we still have to make money. If you have expensive comics and want to get the highest possible price for them, consignment is the way to go since our consignment commission is only 8-10% of the item's sale price.

When you consign a comic with us, all you do is ship the comic to us. We grade the comic for you (if not already slabbed and graded). We provide high quality images of the cover. When it's ready, you choose how you want to sell: either Buy It Now or Auction.

Buy It Now items will be posted for sale to the two largest comic book marketplaces on the internet: MyComicShop and eBay. We post your item to eBay for you at no additional charge to you, and if an item sells on eBay you'll get paid your asking price minus our commission just as you would if it had sold on MyComicShop.

Auction items will be assigned to the next available auction. Our Prime Auctions take place four times a year, in January, April, July, and October, and showcase higher value comics with a particular focus on more valuable Golden Age, Silver Age, and high grade Bronze Age and Modern. In between the Prime Auctions we run weekly auctions that start and end each Monday evening. View our auctions

Make an offer is an optional feature for your Buy It Now listings. If you allow offers, buyers who make an offer will begin a negotiation in which you can accept, decline, or counteroffer each offer received. Buyers on both MyComicShop and eBay are able to make offers on your items.

Commission

You pay nothing out of pocket, only a commission when your item sells:

Note regarding especially technical and labor-intensive raw grading: some comics are especially difficult to handle, requiring careful handling and examination by senior graders. Examples include complex extensive restoration involving reconstruction or married/replaced pages, coverless books that have not been properly identified, and comics that are especially brittle, fragile, or damaged. Very few comics will meet this criteria, usually coming to us from consignors who specialize in collecting these types of books. Any comic that we determine meets these criteria requiring considerably more grading effort than usual will be charged at a higher commission rate: 20% of the sale price, with a minimum of $20 per item.

Lowest Price Guarantee

Low price guarantee: if you are offered a lower consignment rate from any major venue, let us know and we'll match or beat it. Any comparison should be inclusive of all fees charged by the auction house including buyer's premium. Watch out for services that tell you they're willing to waive the seller's premium for you but charge a high buyer's premium. They may even offer to pay you part of the buyer's premium to make you feel like you're getting a great deal. Don't be fooled by math tricks: all that matters is the total percentage of the purchase price that is kept by the auction house.

What is currently consigned with MyComicShop?

We currently have over 90,000 comics, pulps, and comic art pieces consigned with us, and sold more than 105,000 consigned items last year.

View recently listed consignment items

Payments

Two things have to happen before we pay you: the buyer of your item has to submit an order to us, and we have to receive payment from the buyer for that order. Items sold via auction or best offer may have some additional time before the buyer turns in their order: up to 15 days for an auction item and up to 10 days for a best offer item. Many buyers pay faster than that, but that's the maximum time they're allowed to get their orders in.

Once the order is received, if the buyer is paying by credit card or PayPal, we receive the payment immediately. If the buyer is paying by check or bank transfer, it will take additional time: one to two weeks is typical, but at maximum might be up to 3-4 weeks. As soon as we receive that payment, we're ready to issue payment to the conisngor. We issue payments to consignors once a week--payments are usually issued every Wednesday, and if you choose to be paid by check checks go into the mail Wednesday to Friday. Depending on the type of sale and method of payment used, most consignors should receive their payments within 1-2 weeks of the item selling, with some items taking 3-4 weeks and very few taking longer than that.

You choose your payment method: check, PayPal, or credit to your MyComicShop account. Payment made in account credit is same as cash and can be spent on anything we sell. Payment made by PayPal is classified as a "Goods and Services" payment and subject to their 3% fee, which they deduct from the balance of our payment to you.

A 3% buyer's premium is charged to buyers purchasing consignment items who pay by credit card or PayPal. The Buyer's Premium is not charged to buyers paying with check, bank transfer, or MyComicShop account credit. Most buyers making larger purchases will not pay with credit card or PayPal, so the buyer's premium is not a factor in their purchase. The buyer's premium has no effect on the consignor: you as the seller get paid the same regardless of whether the buyer paid a buyer's premium.

Requirements for Buy It Now listings

In order to provide a dynamic marketplace that is attractive to both sellers and buyers, AND to ensure that we do not run out of storage space in our warehouses, MyComicShop places some reasonable limits on Buy It Now listings, as follows.

Items not assigned after 30 days
30 days after MyComicShop notifies a consignor that an item is ready to be priced, if the consignor has not yet assigned a price or put the item in auction, the item will be managed by MyComicShop. That means that MyComicShop will decide what price to assign or whether to auction the item. (We'll send you a reminder if that's coming up.)

Reasonable limits on Buy It Now pricing
At MyComicShop's discretion, we may enforce limits on how high an item may be priced. For example, if the market value of a CGC 9.8 is around $100, and other copies are available for sale at prices from $100 to $150, we do not consider an identical copy priced at $300 to be realistically priced. We reserve the right to restrict pricing to ranges near current market price averages.

We seek consignors who are motivated to sell at whatever prices and conditions are currently prevailing in the market. We are unable to accommodate consignors who feel compelled to price significantly higher than current market conditions because they paid more in the past and are unwilling to adjust down, or because they are speculating that prices will rise at some point in the future. If you're not willing to price in line with where the market is currently, your item is better off remaining in your personal collection.

Use of automatic price reductions to prevent stale, overpriced listings
When items are assigned a Buy It Now price, MyComicShop allows the consignor to choose an automatic price reduction schedule. These price reduction options will automatically reduce an item's price by 5% at regular intervals until it sells.

Maximum listing duration
Any items that have opted out of periodic price reductions will instead be subject to a maximum Buy It Now listing duration after which they will automatically be auctioned. For most comics, magazines, books, pulps, and other periodicals, the maximum listing duration is one year. At our discretion we may allow longer durations for items that are especially high value or rare and priced realistically. For most original comic art, the maximum listing duration is three years. For lower value prints and posters the maximum listing duration is one year.

Multiple copies of the same issue

If a consignor has five or more copies of the same issue (slabbed or unslabbed), all copies of that issue will be managed by MyComicShop. The consignor authorizes MCS to assign prices and/or sell those items via auction. If a consignor is not willing to grant MCS pricing authority for that issue, then those copies will not be accepted for consignment. If you have five or more copies of the same issue and are concerned with how we would handle them, please discuss it with us prior to shipping them to us.

Submitting consignments to CGC, CBCS, or PSA for grading

Upon request, we can submit any of your comics to be graded and encapsulated. We can also advise you on which comics we would recommend submitting for slabbing. We do very well selling unslabbed comics because buyers trust and respect our grading, so unless your comics are $500-1000+, or are very high grade, you can often avoid the expense and wait times of third party grading.

In some cases, we may require that high value comics ($5K to $10K+) be slabbed before we list them on our platform. We can handle the submission for you for any comics where that is the case, you don't have to submit them yourself first prior to sending them to us.

Requesting return of your consignments

It is rare that a consignor requests that an item be returned, but there is no minimum time commitment required. Unsold consignments that are not part of auctions already in progress may be returned to you upon request. Your account will be charged return shipping cost plus $2 per item for slabbed comics and $4 per item for raw comics and non-comic items.

International Returns

We do not offer return shipping of consigned items to addresses outside the US, with one exception: we will do so only if you send us an email informing us in writing that A) you will not hold us liable for any lost or damaged shipment, and B) that you accept the possibility that your shipment might be delayed at customs or be charged import duties. If those conditions are not acceptable, you may want to create an account with a US-based reshipping service. We will ship your item to that reshipping service, which can then forward it on to you. In that case we are responsible only for getting your return to its destination in the US.

Ready to consign?

If you're ready to consign, How to consign will help you get started.

Consignor Behavior

SHILL BIDDING: A consignor may not bid on his own items that he or she has put in auction, also known as shill bidding. This policy also applies to others residing at the same address as the consignor, including family members and friends. All bids placed in an auction should represent genuine intention to purchase the item if the entered bid ends as the winning bid.