Coming in June, we're hosting a CBCS 10th Anniversary Auction! Now accepting submissions of CBCS-graded comics for auction.

Auction in progress, bid now! Weekly Auction ends Monday April 29!

Mystery comic books

4 of 8 in stock Sandman Mystery Theatre TPB (1995-2010 DC/Vertigo) #1-8 DC/Vertigo 1995 - 2010
2 of 3 in stock Sandman Mystery Theatre TPB (2016-2017 DC/Vertigo) Deluxe Edition #1-3 DC/Vertigo 2016 - 2017
Out of stock Savage Membrane SC (2002 Cal Mcdonald Mystery) #1 IDW Publishing 2002
Out of stock Scarab Mystery Magazine (1950-1951 Black Horse Press) Pulp #1 Black Horse Press 1950 - 1951
Out of stock Scary Godmother Mystery Date GN (2004) #1 Sirius 2004
Out of stock Scary Godmother Mystery Date HC (2003) #1 Sirius 2003
Out of stock Scooby Doo Mystery Comics (Australian c.1970 K.G. Murray) #7 K.G. Murray 1970
In stock Scooby-Doo and Krypto Mysteries: The Haunted Dog Park Mystery GN (2023 Picture Window Books) #1 Picture Window Books 2023
Out of stock Scooby-Doo Mystery Incorporated Beware the Beast Below SC (2011 Scholastic) #1 Scholastic Press 2011
In stock Scooby-Doo Mystery of the Fun Park Phantom (1999) #0 DC 1999
In stock Scooby-Doo The Mystery Card Caper Mini Comic (2000) #1 DC 2000
Out of stock Sebastian O/Mystery Play HC (2017 DC/Vertigo) #1 DC/Vertigo 2017
Out of stock Second Wednesday SC (2021 Gemstone) A Donovan Bay Mystery #1 Gemstone 2021
15 of 15 in stock Seekers into the Mystery (1996) #1-15 DC 1996 - 1997
In stock Seekers into the Mystery Preview (1996 DC/Vertigo) #0 DC/Vertigo 1996
In stock Seekers into the Mystery TPB (2009 Boom Studios) #1 Boom Studios 2009
Out of stock Seekers into the Mystery TPB (2017 Dover) The Complete Collection #1 Dover Publications 2017
2 of 7 in stock Sensation Mystery (1952) #110-116 National Periodical Publ 1952 - 1953
Out of stock Shadow The History and Mystery of the Radio Program 1930-1954 HC (2018 OTR) #1 OTR Publishing 2018
Out of stock Shadow The History and Mystery of the Radio Program 1930-1954 SC (2012 OTR) #1 OTR Publishing 2012
0 of 3 in stock Shaver Mystery Magazine (1947-1949 Shaver Mystery Club) #1-3 Shaver Mystery Club 1947 - 1949
0 of 2 in stock Shell Scott Mystery Magazine (1966 LeMarg Publishing) Pulp #1-2 LeMarg Publishing 1966
In stock Sherlock Bones and the Natural History Mystery GN (2020 Etch) #1 Etch 2020
In stock Sherlock Bones and the Natural History Mystery HC (2020 Etch) #1 Etch 2020
In stock Sherlock Holmes Chronicles of Crime and Mystery (1992) #1 Northstar 1992
1 of 27 in stock Sherlock Holmes Mystery Magazine SC (2008-2019 Wildside Press) #1-21 Wildside 2008 - 2019
2 of 3 in stock Sherlock Holmes Tales of Mystery and Suspense (1992) #1-3 Arpad 1992 - 1993
1 of 2 in stock Shock Mystery Tales Magazine (1961-1963 Pontiac Publishing) #2-3 Pontiac Publishing 1961 - 1963
4 of 11 in stock Shocking Mystery Cases (1952) #50-60 Star 1952 - 1954
0 of 3 in stock Showcase Presents House of Mystery TPB (2006-2009 DC) #1-3 DC 2006 - 2009
In stock Shroud of Mystery (1982 Whitman) #1 Whitman 1982
Out of stock Sif Journey into Mystery TPB (2017 Marvel) The Complete Collection #1 Marvel 2017
In stock Silver Age Classics: Midnight Mystery HC (2024 PS Artbooks) #1 PS Artbooks 2024
In stock Silver Age Classics: Midnight Mystery HC (2024 PS Artbooks) Limited Slipcase Edition #1 PS Artbooks 2024
Out of stock Sleuth Mystery Magazine (1958 Fosdeck) #1 Fosdeck Publications 1958
Out of stock Snappy Mystery Stories (1934 Trojan / Culture) Pulp #1 Trojan Publishing 1934 - 1935
Out of stock Snow White Mystery of the Missing Magic (1958) 1958 Western 1958
In stock Son of Mystery (1939 Saalfield BLB) 1152 Saalfield Pub. Co. 1939
3 of 4 in stock Speed Mystery (1943-1946 Trojan-Arrow^) Pulp #1-4 Trojan Publishing 1943 - 1946
5 of 13 in stock Spicy Mystery Stories (1934-1942 Culture Publications^) Pulp #1-13 Culture Publishing 1934 - 1942
0 of 6 in stock Spicy Mystery Stories SC (2005 Adventure House) Pulp Replica 1935-1942 Adventure House 2005 - 2019
Out of stock Spicy Mystery Stories TPB (1990 Malibu Graphics Inc.) #1 Malibu 1990
Out of stock Spider Sense Spider-Man: Spider-Man and the Movie Mystery SC (2011 HarperCollins) #1 HarperCollins 2011
In stock Spy Island TPB (2021 Dark Horse) A Bermuda Triangle Mystery #1 Dark Horse 2021
Out of stock Star Wars The Mystery of the Rebellious Robot 1979 Random House 1979
In stock Startling Mystery Magazine (1940 Popular Publications) Pulp #1 Popular Publications 1940
10 of 18 in stock Startling Mystery Stories (1966-1971 Health Knowledge) #1-18 Health Knowledge 1966 - 1971
1 of 3 in stock Strange Tales of Mystery and Terror (1931-1933 Clayton Magazines) Pulp #1-3 Clayton Magazines, Inc. 1931 - 1933
0 of 3 in stock Strange Tales of Mystery and Terror SC (2004 Girasol Collectables) Pulp Replica #1-3 Girasol 2004 - 2006
3 of 3 in stock Strange The Magazine of True Mystery (1952 Quinn Publishing) Digest #1-3 Quinn Publishing Co. 1952
1 of 5 in stock Street and Smith's Mystery Magazine (1939-1943 Street & Smith) Pulp #5-9 Street & Smith 1939 - 1943
Out of stock Street and Smith's Shadow Mystery Magazine (UK 1954-1955 Street & Smith/Atlas) Pulp #2 Atlas 1955
Out of stock Super Friends Mystery in Space TPB (2011) #1 DC 2011
5 of 8 in stock Super Mystery Comics (1940) #1-8 Ace Magazines 1940 - 1949
3 of 3 in stock Supernatural Freak Machine A Cal McDonald Mystery (2005) #1-3 IDW Publishing 2005
In stock Surfside Girls The Mystery at the Old Rancho GN (2019 Top Shelf) #1 Top Shelf Productions 2019
In stock Tailspin Tommy and the Airliner Mystery (1938 Dell BLB) #0 Dell 1938
In stock Tailspin Tommy in the Famous Pay-Roll Mystery (1933) #747 Whitman 1933
In stock Tailspin Tommy in the Great Air Mystery (1936 Whitman BLB) 1184 Whitman 1936
In stock Tailspin Tommy in the Pay-Roll Mystery (1933 Whitman BLB) #0 Whitman 1934
Out of stock Tales of Magic and Mystery (1927-1928 Personal Arts Co.) Pulp #1 Personal Arts Co. 1927 - 1928
Out of stock Tales of Magic and Mystery SC (2004 Pulp Classics) #1 Wildside 2004
Out of stock Tales of Mystery and Imagination HC (1936 Tudor) By Edgar Allan Poe 1st Edition #1 Tudor Publishing 1936
Out of stock Tales of Mystery and Imagination HC (2008 Calla Editions) By Edgar Allan Poe New Edition #1 Calla Editions 2009
Out of stock Tales of Mystery and Imagination SC (2012 HarperCollins) By Edgar Allan Poe #1 HarperCollins 2012
0 of 2 in stock Terrific Comics (1954 Mystery) #14-16 Mystery Publ. 1954 - 1955
Out of stock Terry and the Pirates and the Mystery Ship (1938 Dell BLB) #0 Dell 1938
In stock Terry and the Pirates The Plantation Mystery (1942 Whitman BLB) 1436 Whitman 1942
In stock The Candle (1937 Digest) A Tech Mystery #1 Tech Mystery Inc. 1937
Out of stock The Mystery of the Green Ghost SC (1965 Random House) #1 Random House 1965
In stock The Niagara Falls Mystery (1992 Trent Publications) 1992 Trent Publications 1992
0 of 14 in stock The Saint Mystery Library (1959-1960 Great American Publications) Digest #118-131 Great American Publications 1959 - 1960
419 of 420 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) #83-502 Marvel 1962 - 1996
1 of 6 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) 30 Cent Variant #246-250 Marvel 1976
0 of 7 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) 35 Cent Variant #260-264 Marvel 1977 - 1978
19 of 19 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) Annual #1-19 Marvel 1965 - 1994
8 of 10 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) Australian Price Variant #427-468 Marvel 1991 - 1994
28 of 47 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) Canadian Price Variant #324-370 Marvel 1982 - 1986
1 of 5 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) Canadian Price Variant Annual #1-13 Marvel 1965 - 1985
In stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) Golden Record Reprint #83 Marvel 1966
2 of 2 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) JC Penney Reprint #0-312 Marvel 1993 - 1994
76 of 247 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) Mark Jewelers #187-433 Marvel 1971 - 1991
3 of 3 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) Marvel Legends Reprint #116-351 Marvel 2005 - 2006
0 of 6 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) National Book Store Variants #243-248 National Book Store 1976
0 of 16 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) National Diamond #187-210 Marvel 1971 - 1973
33 of 232 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) UK Edition #83-314 Marvel 1962 - 1981
In stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) UK Edition Annual #1 Marvel 1965
20 of 23 in stock Thor (1962 Marvel 1st Series Journey Into Mystery) Whitman Variants #256-286 Marvel 1977 - 1979
6 of 25 in stock Thrilling Mystery (1935-1947 Standard) Pulp #1-26 Better Publications 1935 - 1947
Out of stock Thrilling Mystery SC (2006 Girasol Collectables) Pulp Replica #1 Girasol 2006
Out of stock Tinkerbell Solves a Mystery SC (1983 A Sharon Coloring Book) #1 Sharon Publications 1983
Out of stock Tom Mix in the Tepee Ranch Mystery (1938 Whitman BLB) #10 Whitman 1938
In stock Treasury of 20th Century Murder: Lover's Lane: The Hall-Mills Mystery HC (2012 NBM) #1 NBM 2012
In stock Treasury of Victorian Murder Mystery of Mary Rogers HC #1 NBM 2001
Out of stock Treasury of Victorian Murder The Mystery of Mary Rogers GN (2004 NBM) #1 NBM 2004
1 of 4 in stock True Complete Mystery (1949) #5-8 Marvel 1949
1 of 5 in stock True Mystery (1953-1958 Skye Publishing) True Crime Magazine #4-8 Skye Publishing Company 1953 - 1958
4 of 4 in stock Ultimate Mystery (2010 Marvel) #1-4 Marvel 2010
5 of 5 in stock Ultraman the Mystery of Ultraseven (2022 Marvel) #1-5 Marvel 2022 - 2023
Out of stock Ultraman The Mystery of Ultraseven TPB (2023 Marvel) #1 Marvel 2023
Out of stock Vampire Cheerleaders Paranormal Mystery Squad GN (2012 Digest) Monster Mash Collection #1 Seven Seas 2012
1 of 8 in stock Vulcan Mystery (1945-1946 Vulcan Publications) Digest #1-8 Vulcan Publications 1944 - 1946
In stock Walt Disney's Annette and the Mystery at Smugglers' Cover HC (1963 Whitman) #1 Whitman 1963
Out of stock Walt Disney's Mickey Mouse Mystery at Dead Man's Cove (1948 Whitman BLB) 5781 Whitman 1980
In stock Walt Disney's Mickey Mouse Mystery at Disneyland (1975 Whitman BLB) 5770 Whitman 1975
5 of 5 in stock War of the Realms Journey Into Mystery (2019 Marvel) #1-5 Marvel 2019
In stock War of the Realms Journey Into Mystery TPB (2019 Marvel) #1 Marvel 2019
22 of 29 in stock Web of Mystery (1951) #1-29 Ace Comics 1951 - 1955
4 of 4 in stock Weird Mystery (1970-1971 Ultimate Publishing) Pulp #1-4 Ultimate Publishing Company 1970 - 1971
11 of 24 in stock Weird Mystery Tales (1972) #1-24 DC 1972 - 1975
1 of 20 in stock Weird Mystery Tales (1972) Mark Jewelers #4-23 DC 1973 - 1975
Out of stock Weird Mystery Tales (1972) National Book store Variants #12 National Book Store 1974
Out of stock Weird Mystery Tales (1996) Preview #0 DC 1996
Out of stock Weird Mystery Tales (Australian 1972-1978 K.G. Murray) #16 K.G. Murray 1975
Out of stock Welcome Back to the House of Mystery (1998) #1 DC 1998
In stock What Would Velma Do? HC (2023 Running Press) Life Lessons from the Brains (and Heart) of Mystery, Inc. #1 Running Press 2023
Out of stock Whisperer Mystery The Astral Adventures of Rocco Vargas GN (1990 Catalan) #2 Catalan 1990
3 of 3 in stock Winchester Mystery House (2021 Source Point) #1-3 Source Point Press 2021
In stock Winchester Mystery House Hundred Year Curse (2022 Source Point Press) FCBD #0 Source Point Press 2022
In stock Winchester Mystery House TPB (2022 Source Point Press) #1 Source Point Press 2022
In stock World of Andong Agimat: The Mystery of the Talisman GN (2023 Tuttle) #1 Tuttle Publishing 2023
4 of 7 in stock World of Mystery (1956) #1-7 Atlas 1956 - 1957
Out of stock World of Sherlock Holmes Mystery Magazine (1977) 1977 Fanzine 1977
In stock X-Men Missing Mutant Mystery Giveaway (1994) #1 Marvel 1994
0 of 2 in stock XIII Mystery GN (2014- Cinebook) #1-2 Cinebook 2014 - 2022
In stock Zane Grey's King of the Royal Mounted and the Great Jewel Mystery (1939 Whitman BLB) 1486 Whitman 1939
Out of stock Zombie Mystery Paintings HC (1986 Blackthorne) #1 Blackthorne 1986
Out of stock Zombie Mystery Paintings SC (1990 Last Gasp) #1 Last Gasp 1990