Return to Sleepy Hollow (2025 IDW) comic books
-
Issue #1A
Published Oct 2025 by IDW Publishing.$4.99
$4.99
(W) Casey Gilly (A) Savanna Mayer (CA) Savanna Mayer Tim Burtons Sleepy Hollow (1999) continues in Return to Sleepy Hollow! From Eisner Award–winning author Casey Gilly (Buffy the Last Vampire Slayer, A Funeral in Foam) comes a tale of buried truths, decaying bodies, and rotting gods. The Headless Horseman hasnt plagued Sleepy Hollow for 15 years now, but unbeknownst to the residents of the drowsy valley, a deeper evil lurks in the roots of the town, and it will stop at nothing to quench its thirst for blood.Ichabod Crane is a man of science and, despite his indisputable brush with the supernatural, has built a name for himself debunking claims of the occult across the world. However, when he receives a frantic letter urging him to return to Sleepy Hollow, Ichabod must reunite with his now estranged love, Katrina Van Tassel, to investigate a string of strange, unexplainable murders. Together, they will uncover the truth of Sleepy Hollows origins and the roots that connect them all. 36 pages, full color, rated mature. Cover price $4.99.
The listings below are from eBay, and MyComicShop is not responsible for these items in any way. Some listings shown here may no longer be available if they sold or were ended by the seller after we last retrieved the listing details.
Clicking on the links to the eBay listings shown above and then making a purchase may result in MyComicShop earning a commission from the eBay Partner Network.
-
Issue #2A
Published 2025 (est.) by IDW Publishing.$4.99
$4.99
(W) Casey Gilly (A) Savanna Mayer (CA) Savanna Mayer Tim Burtons Sleepy Hollow (1999) continues in Return to Sleepy Hollow!The Van Tassel mortuary is overflowing with bodies–—residents of Sleepy Hollow who died tangled in roots, decorated in flowers, or blanketed in soil. The constables insist that the deaths are accidents, but Ichabod and Katrina suspect that evil has returned to plague the town.As their investigation leads them deeper into the Western Woods, Lotte, Katrinas daughter, begins an investigation of her own by communing with the spirits of the dead. Screaming to be heard, the lingering souls may hold the answers the living are looking for. 32 pages, full color, rated mature. Cover price $4.99.
The listing below is from eBay, and MyComicShop is not responsible for this item in any way. Some listings shown here may no longer be available if they sold or were ended by the seller after we last retrieved the listing details.
$5 Return To Sleepy Hollow # 2 Cover A NM IDW 2025 [VV] Clicking on the links to the eBay listings shown above and then making a purchase may result in MyComicShop earning a commission from the eBay Partner Network.
-
Issue #2B
Published 2025 (est.) by IDW Publishing.$4.99
$4.99
(W) Casey Gilly (A) Savanna Mayer (CA) Audrey Estok Tim Burtons Sleepy Hollow (1999) continues in Return to Sleepy Hollow!The Van Tassel mortuary is overflowing with bodies–—residents of Sleepy Hollow who died tangled in roots, decorated in flowers, or blanketed in soil. The constables insist that the deaths are accidents, but Ichabod and Katrina suspect that evil has returned to plague the town.As their investigation leads them deeper into the Western Woods, Lotte, Katrinas daughter, begins an investigation of her own by communing with the spirits of the dead. Screaming to be heard, the lingering souls may hold the answers the living are looking for. 32 pages, full color, rated mature. Cover price $4.99.
-
Issue #3A
Published Jan 2026 by IDW Publishing.$4.99
$4.99
$3.99
$3.99
(W) Casey Gilly (A) Savanna Mayer (CA) Savanna Mayer Tim Burtons Sleepy Hollow (1999) continues in Return to Sleepy Hollow!Death hangs over Ichabods and Katrinas heads as they race to put a stop to the suspicious fatalities befalling the residents of Sleepy Hollow. Their investigation turns to the townsfolk, and– everyone is a suspect—from the widowers of the deceased to the local apothecary owner. But the pair dig up nothing but dead ends until a possessed gardener leads them to…The Tree of the Dead! The cursed ground where Lady Van Tassel resurrected the malevolent Headless Horseman, and the very same place spirits have been showing Lotte over and over again in her visions. It seems the tree is the root of Sleepy Hollows problems, but it may also hold the answers Ichabod and Katrina seek. 28 pages, rated Mature, full color Cover price $4.99.
The listings below are from eBay, and MyComicShop is not responsible for these items in any way. Some listings shown here may no longer be available if they sold or were ended by the seller after we last retrieved the listing details.
$5 Return to Sleepy Hollow #3 01/28/2026 VF+ Cover A (Mayer) IDW PUBLISHING $6 Return to Sleepy Hollow #3A VF/NM; IDW | 1st Print Sequel to Tim Burton Movie - Clicking on the links to the eBay listings shown above and then making a purchase may result in MyComicShop earning a commission from the eBay Partner Network.
-
Issue #3RI
Published Jan 2026 by IDW Publishing.$9.99
$9.99
Limited 1 for 15 Retailer Incentive Variant Cover.(W) Casey Gilly (A) Savanna Mayer (CA) Joëlle Jones Tim Burtons Sleepy Hollow (1999) continues in Return to Sleepy Hollow!Death hangs over Ichabods and Katrinas heads as they race to put a stop to the suspicious fatalities befalling the residents of Sleepy Hollow. Their investigation turns to the townsfolk, and– everyone is a suspect—from the widowers of the deceased to the local apothecary owner. But the pair dig up nothing but dead ends until a possessed gardener leads them to…The Tree of the Dead! The cursed ground where Lady Van Tassel resurrected the malevolent Headless Horseman, and the very same place spirits have been showing Lotte over and over again in her visions. It seems the tree is the root of Sleepy Hollows problems, but it may also hold the answers Ichabod and Katrina seek. 28 pages, rated Mature, full color Cover price $4.99.
-
Issue #4A
Published Feb 2026 by IDW Publishing.$4.99
$4.99
$2.99
(W) Casey Gilly (A) Savanna Mayer (CA) Savanna Mayer Tim Burtons Sleepy Hollow (1999) continues in Return to Sleepy Hollow!The Tree of the Dead haunts the nightmares of all who reside in Sleepy Hollow, but Ichabod, Katrina, Lotte, and their friends find themselves standing in its shadows once again, gathering the remains of yet another body. They hoped the tree would hold some answers, but instead they have more questions when Masbath stumbles upon a circle of gravestones marked with the names Fortuna, Masbath, Dale, and Van Tassel. Why are these unkempt graves so far outside of town? Who would bury their loved ones so close to such a horrible sight?While Masbath and Maggie investigate, Lotte is struggling to return to herself after being possessed. Shes hearing whispers. Of digging, of the softest dark, of thirst. The whispers are leading her in circles and circles and circles… 28 pages, rated M, full color Cover price $4.99.
The listings below are from eBay, and MyComicShop is not responsible for these items in any way. Some listings shown here may no longer be available if they sold or were ended by the seller after we last retrieved the listing details.
Clicking on the links to the eBay listings shown above and then making a purchase may result in MyComicShop earning a commission from the eBay Partner Network.
-
Issue #5A
Published Mar 2026 by IDW Publishing.$4.99
$4.99
$3.99
$3.99
(W) Casey Gilly (A) Savanna Mayer (CA) Savanna Mayer Tim Burtons Sleepy Hollow (1999) continues in Return to Sleepy Hollow!In the final issue, Ichabod, Katrina, and Lotte unearth the horrible secret entangled in the roots of Sleepy Hollow.After her mother is arrested, Lotte loses control, seemingly possessed by an entity starved for blood. Time has run out. Ichabod must accept the supernatural and put a stop to it before it kills again—before it takes those who are most precious to him. 32 pages, full color, rated mature. Cover price $4.99.
The listings below are from eBay, and MyComicShop is not responsible for these items in any way. Some listings shown here may no longer be available if they sold or were ended by the seller after we last retrieved the listing details.
$5 Return to Sleepy Hollow #5 (Cvr A) (2026) Savanna Mayer $5 Return To Sleepy Hollow # 5 Cover A NM IDW 2026 [KK4] Clicking on the links to the eBay listings shown above and then making a purchase may result in MyComicShop earning a commission from the eBay Partner Network.
-
Issue #5RI
Published Mar 2026 by IDW Publishing.$7.10
Limited 1 for 15 Retailer Incentive Variant Cover. (W) Casey Gilly (A) Savanna Mayer (CA) Joëlle Jones Tim Burtons Sleepy Hollow (1999) continues in Return to Sleepy Hollow!In the final issue, Ichabod, Katrina, and Lotte unearth the horrible secret entangled in the roots of Sleepy Hollow.After her mother is arrested, Lotte loses control, seemingly possessed by an entity starved for blood. Time has run out. Ichabod must accept the supernatural and put a stop to it before it kills again—before it takes those who are most precious to him. 32 pages, full color, rated mature. Cover price $4.99.
The listing below is from eBay, and MyComicShop is not responsible for this item in any way. Some listings shown here may no longer be available if they sold or were ended by the seller after we last retrieved the listing details.
$14 Return to Sleepy Hollow #5C VF/NM; IDW | RI 1:15 Variant - w/Bag+Board Clicking on the links to the eBay listings shown above and then making a purchase may result in MyComicShop earning a commission from the eBay Partner Network.
