Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

I am eager to sell you this lot of books and I would like to be able to take perhaps 1/2 trade and 1/2 cash instead of the full amount in cash. The reason is that I have a few books that I'd like to send off to you to have slabbed and graded. I will accept whatever grading/value you determine as you've always been very fair, and I enjoy working with you because of that.
— Josh F., North Las Vegas, NV

This is my first time selling to you guys, but I've bought from you many times, originally while I was living in Canada, and several times since I moved to Georgia. Looking forward to seeing how the trading process goes! Over almost 20 years of collecting, I've accrued lots of issues I don't now need/want, so this will hopefully be a way for me to offload some of the two long boxes that are currently labeled "to sell."
— Tim L., Atlanta, GA

I've been using your consignment service for my older books and I've had fantastic results. I'm trying out your direct purchase option for the first time and if all goes well I'll be selling more modern books through mycomicshop.
— Lee E., Pfafftown, NC

Wonderful website! Very excited about trading comics with you! Thank you for all of your time and effort!
— Aaroon S., Montgomery Village, MD

I thoroughly enjoy trading comics with you! By trading, I have been able to find a lot of back issues I need to complete my collections.
— Jeff D., Belcamp, MD

I have enjoyed using your website to make several purchases. Your want-list feature is very helpful at conventions! I use your pricing to see if something is truly a good deal, and frequently I save money buying from you. Selling to you was recommended by a friend of mine who has done so in the past, so I thought it was time to submit some comics to you for trade and get some store credit!
— James P., Mechanicsburg, PA

Thank you for making selling my comics such an easy process! It was fun going back through all of these old comics and remembering the stories. Ah, childhood!
— Justin R., Minneapolis, MN

I got my first check today from your business, I believe there are about a dozen more closely behind it. I must have sent in between 2,000 and 3,000 books so far. Autumn in your buying department has been very helpful on the phone and this has encouraged me to make a business of supplying you. She's been extremely helpful. She's representing you well.
— Philip S., Fall River, MA

You would think that after over 100 orders made and over 100 trades sent in to you that I would run out of compliments for you after a while, but you'd be wrong! I want to take a minute to praise your want list feature. Just last Saturday morning early, I got an email that three of my want list items were in stock. I quickly nabbed them! I got three (rare-ish) books that I have been after for a long time. And I got them at a great price! Not an artificially inflated mark up, but a great deal! (As always!) I spend a fair amount of time just "window shopping" Mycomicshop.com as there is SO much to discover, but the automatic email on requested items is phenomenal and extra helpful! Thank you so much! And I forgot the best part - getting those books without having to pay cash, because of the credit from past trades already in my account! Excellent! I TRY to keep credit in my account, but it never lasts for long. You just have too much inflow of books that I want!!! Thanks for everything! It, as always, is appreciated!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Hello! My name is Ruth. My husband John and I are selling our comics to start a little nest egg for the future. Thank you so much for being available. We have a lot more and hope to do more business with you in the future.
— Ruth M., Germantown, MD

Looking forward to seeing what other comics are on your want list and trading some of my favorites for something new to add to my collection.
— Ryan E., Abbotsford BC, Canada

I have been a very happy customer with you guys for over a decade and have always been satisfied with your buying and selling options. You are the first retailer I go with! Thanks so much guys, you rock!
— Matthew P., Logan, UT

Love dealing with you guys.
— James G., Linden, TX

Thank you for the excellent service!
— Christian R., Schenectady, NY

I'm looking forward to another smooth transaction. :-) Thanks!
— Boris S., Minden, NY

I was just closing up for the day when I saw some Spideys went off my "Wait List" and onto your "Want List!" Here they are!
— Chuck W., Lake Buena Vista, FL

As always I appreciate the opportunity to sell my comics with you. It is always a good experience.
— Neill U., Galesburg, IL

You guys are the best. I love selling and buying with you!
— Travis T., Seattle, WA

Your online want-list buy/trade system has made this transaction quick, easy, and simple. I thank you for that.
— Kirk B., Jonesborough, TN

You guys do a great job!
— Jeff R., Bangor, ME

My wife and I just had our third child. I am unemployed now, which was unknown at the time of conception, but life throws us curve balls for a reason. My wife is on maternity leave with no pay and I am just looking to make money any way that I can. I have had these comics forever. Not sure of the grades, but I am hoping for good things. Any money will help. I am also consigning some other items with you. I still have some of my collection left, including Batman, which is my number one collection and longest run of mostly Silver Age. I'm not giving up everything, but still losing some memories. Some of these were from my mother. I have a lot of Archie because of her. Thank you for your help. Your process is very easy and informative. Have a great day!
— John S., Grayling, MI

Thank you so much for consistently awesome service!
— Christian E., Schenectady, NY

I just bought 39 comics from you. They were in great shape and had great prices. I knew if you were this fair with my purchase, you would also be awesome to work with in trading. Thanks for the pleasant experience; I look forward to many further purchases. You brought me back into the comics fold after a 30 year hiatus. :)
— Dave S., Largo, FL

My wife has told me it is time to lighten the load, so I have sent you about 20% of my comics to see how it goes. There may be more coming.
— James H., Bow, WA

I've ordered from you many times. This is my first selling transaction. Looking forward to it.
— Bret B., Colorado Springs, CO

Well, it has been almost 4 hours since I mailed a package of trade-ins to you, so it's time to start another consolidated transaction! Simply amazing! Your constant demand for such a wide variety of comics means that as soon as I mail you a box of books, you're ready for yet another, which in turn provides me with a never ending stream of credit for even more books, which I can then read and trade in for more credit which I can use for....well you get the idea!......to infinity! Your comic trade system could not be more perfect for a reader like me. Thanks as always!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

I'm so glad I found your website! My comics had been sitting on my shelf for so long that I felt bad. I'm happy to sell them to you so that someone else can enjoy them.
— Douglas D., Corte Madera, CA

I really enjoy and appreciate your website. Very awesome and SPEEDY SERVICE! Thank you for the opportunity to conduct business.
— Dennis W., White Sulphur Springs, WV

Again, I just get back from lunch and already more of my books go from MCS "wait" list to MCS "Buy" list!
— Chuck W., Lake Buena Vista, FL

First time on your site. You have a great idea and process. I'm selling off some of my issues now, but hope to send in more back issues in the future.
— Nathan R., Cary, NC

Enjoy doing business with you. Will be looking to buy some collected editions soon.
— Steven R., Pacifica, CA

I have done business with you previously and it was a great experience.
— Charlie F., Gainesville, FL

My first transaction went well, so I thought I would try another.
— Tracy O., Richland, MO

My wife and I love your site and we are very excited to get some credit for the comics we are trading to you.
— Kevin C., Venice, FL

Been selling comics online for 17 years now! Found this site from a friend and I just love it.
— Brian G., Murrieta, CA

Thank you. You have a great site that helps the comic book community thrive.
— Dan W., Cedar Rapids, IA

Hey, Lone Star Comics. I found a hidden stash of comics that I thought I'd already submitted. Guess not! I guess we both win, though. Looking forward to using this credit toward some nice want-list items!
— Michael T., Fort Worth, TX

I have been an avid comic book reader for almost forty years. They have helped me through some pretty miserable times as well as some pretty great times. I have a substantial collection but am always finding holes that need to be filled. I also want to thin the flock a bit.
— Tim H., Monroe, GA

I recently started collecting comic books again after years of not buying anything. I like the '80's era the most. Anyway, I have bought several comics from you and you guys seem to grade fairly so I would like to try trading a few comics to you.
— Tony S., Athens, TN

Hello, This is a collection I received from my great uncle's estate. I have zero experience with comic books. Your site is incredible with being able to search the books and get some sort of value. I trust you guys will grade fairly and find each one a happy home with someone who will truly appreciate them. Thank you.
— Rich P., Bangor, PA

Thank you so much! This entire process of selling and buying comics from you guys has been super smooth! I really appreciate your thoroughness and speed. Have a nice day!
— Peter L., Oakland, California

I was interested in finding out what my comic book collection was worth. Your site saved me from having to drive to more comic book shops. After visiting some, I found your offer prices are more fair. I've enjoyed comic books for years, and now I'm enjoying using your site to sell. I look forward to coming back to your site soon.
— Dianne P., Mira Loma, CA

Hi! I am a comics buff from childhood. I'm currently cleaning out my collection of certain items that have accumulated over the years. It is very helpful to be able to sell these comics through your website. God bless.
— Paul F., Hasbrouck Heights, NJ

I was really happy to find your service. I've been wanting to sell my comics for a while, but I didn't know how to go about it and get a fair deal. I was impressed by your website. :-)
— Jeff B., Dallas, TX

I have done business with you before and was happy with the service.
— Steven R., Pacifica, CA

I have never sold comics before so I mostly stuck to your green line typical grade defaults on the grading.
— Valerie H., Washington, DC

Thanks for all your help. I will only sell to you guys.
— John C., Mentor on the Lake, OH

Looking forward to our second deal together. My first sale to you was as smooth and as wonderful as possible.
— John C., Merrit Island, FL

Great format for shopping and buying. Informative website and it's easy to navigate. All the best for your business in the future. Thanks again.
— Stephen D., Bethesda, MD

More comics on the way soon in my newest trade. Thanks!
— Fred M., Holland, OH