Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Customers

You have the best selection of any website I have ever used!
— Adam G., Mount laurel, NJ

This is my second time selling to you. Once in a while I've got to force myself to let go of parts of my collection, either for space or financial reasons, and your site is very convenient to use. Searching for issues is always spot on and the tips for identifying issue variants are always available with details. It really is a pleasure to buy and sell from such an organized company! Thank you and I hope you enjoy checking in and grading this batch!
— Christopher V., Norwalk, CT

Great prices and a great selection. I love all of you.
— Anthony G., Independence, MO

WOOHOO!!! :) Your auctions are very well organized and I'm honored to be a part in them. I can't even look at or go to any other comic sites, I always come to this one instead.
— Jorge T., Romoland, CA

Thank you for making the selling process straightforward and easy!
— Michael N., Stoneham, PA

Thanks, your site is very well laid out and has an amazing selection!
— Joshua C., Brisbane, Australia

Great selection of comics again to choose from during your auction - thanks for providing excellent choices and services.
— Phillip B., Fairfield, CA

I was very pleased with my first order and shipping. So pleased in fact that I have decided to begin completing my collection strictly through your website (and my local comic book shop, of course!). Thank you for the wonderful experience so far.
— Johnathan A., Catonsville, MD

Okay, not my first time, but over time I've begun to more deeply appreciate your going the extra mile to offer people options to buy/sell to/from you or others via store credit, cash, auction, and consignment. Every policy/rule/procedure I've encountered actually makes sense to me as necessary because of quantities, business flow, and fairness. (As a retired litigation attorney who used to represent businesses, my praise in this context is not earned unless fully merited.) Your staff have been unfailingly helpful, too! Keep up the good work. Speaking of which, here's another proposed sale list for y'all to work on. :) Cheers!
— Joan M., Seattle, WA

Your web site is the MOST USER FRIENDLY comic site I ever seen! This is my very first time selling comics to you, but I have been using your site since 2011 to fill in my back issue runs and, especially when prepping for a convention, looking for specific issues for artists or writers to sign, etc. Thanks to you all, I was able to complete my Marvel Shogun Warriors collection as well as the Marvel Godzilla run. Keep up the great job.
— Stephen F., Mesquite, TX

I have a few friends that have had great success using your consignment services. This is just a small batch of some doubles I had. I had heard enough positive things from my associates that I figured I might as well get the ball rolling. Expect more books from me!
— Robert D., Dunwoody, GA

Great site and easy to use. You're the first one that had the whole run.
— John K., Quitman, MS

I love that I can trade my comics for more to read - that's great. That being said, I'm not sure I scored these all correctly. Some may be in better shape than I indicated, and some may not be as in good a shape as I thought. I'm not new to reading comics, but I am new at grading them - please be patient!
— Keith B., Cleveland, TN

You as a company have always been great to me, you have great service and competitive pricing. Thank you.
— Joshua N., Portland, OR

You guys are the best! I always find what I'm looking for on your site.
— Anthony W., Albuquerque, NM

I am the owner of a comic book store and I have a lot of overflow I'd like to sell. Starting with one long box.
— Jason C., Maynard, MA

Great site, and always easy to navigate and find what I'm looking for.
— Joseph L., Weymouth, MA

It's amazing how reasonable the prices are!
— Chessie H., Abingdon, VA

This is my first order from you. The site is very easy to use and has a great selection. Looking forward to future purchases.
— Adam S., Antioch, IL

I love how easy this site is to navigate and find exactly what I need at a great price. I'll be sure to use this site more in the future.
— Tiffany S., Vacaville, CA

I acknowledge that I am not experienced at grading and so I may be off-base on some (or many) of the items. Based upon your high marks given by past customers, I trust you to grade appropriately, and will accept your advice on this. Your website is exceptional and represents considerable effort on your part!
— Marshall D., Belmont, MA

First time doing business with you. You were highly recommended by a friend.
— Andrew M., Bowie, MD

Great job on the packaging! You instill confidence in your shipping.
— Brian L., Lynnwood, WA

You guys are the best, prices are always excellent and comics always come in looking great. Thanks for all you do!
— Jordan F., Denver, CO

You guys pack the books very well. I think you could submerge the box in a lake and it would still be dry!
— Lawrence M., Middle Village, NY

You guys have a wonderful website for searching for and buying comics - the best I've seen. Thank you!
— Geoffrey G., Norristown, PA

Thanks for always doing a great job with my orders/packing. Never a bad experience!
— Kiyoshi N., Los Angeles, CA

Great site, and cool idea about free comic books. Beats standing in line only to not have the ones you want.
— Jason K., Longmont, CO

Man, I wish it was this easy to find back issues when I was younger. Thanks so much!!
— Eric F., Columbus, OH

I live in Australia, where comic book stores are very hard to find and all the ones online all have very expensive shipping. This site has the cheapest shipping and all the comics I want at this point in time, so thank you.
— Shannon S., Woody Point, Australia

My brother told me all about your site and he was so right! You guys are awesome and have every issue of comics I needed on my list. It's unbelievable how many comics you guys have, whether they are obscure or just hard to find. Thank you so much, and I cannot wait to get more from you guys in the future. THANK YOU!
— Mason R., Walpole, MA

I recently purchased 6 comics from you for a total of $330 with my trade credit. I gave these comics as gifts to 6 recent college graduates that I know. They were a HUGE, and unique, hit!!!!! Thank you.
— Brian D., Chalfont, PA

I love your website very much. The selection is fantastic, the pricing is great and hopefully the shippers will complete this first-time shopper experience.
— Johnathan A., Catonsville, MD

This is one of the best sites on all of the internet and I've always had the best service here. Thank you very much for being awesome.
— Kevin T., Arlington, TX

Love your site!
— Will M., Pleasanton, CA

Regarding the comics I am selling to you, thank you for the yellow flagged items that indicate a significant offer price reduction below a given grade. I reviewed them and accept the risk of lower grading. I'm excited to learn what my overall grading accuracy rate is so I can learn and do better next time. I've still got boxes and boxes of comics to go through and submit for sale. Cheers!
— Joan M., Seattle, WA

Thanks SO much! I have been looking for an affordable copy of this book for a long time! Just another example of why your want list is the BEST! And your prices too! Thanks again.
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Not much to say other then I love this site and it's service. I find you guys incredibly reliable, as opposed to other stores.
— Bradley B., Tinley Park, IL

I've only recently started ordering off of this site, but so far I'm highly impressed with the service. My items were shipped quickly and the package was put together very well.
— Caleb K., Washington, PA

You have a great selection and competitive pricing! I look forward to my order and dealing with you in the future! Cheers!
— Erik J., Lindstrom, MN

You guys always save the day when I'm missing an issue. There is almost nothing that you don't have. I am so excited to get caught up on my comics now!
— Joe P., North Canton, OH

You guys are awesome! Been shopping here for a little over a year and I haven't seen a reason to use any other website. Always look forward to seeing my packages come in. Thank you.
— Aaron L., Los Banos, CA

This has been the absolute best place to help me finish up my collections! You guys rock!
— Casey H., Johnson City, TN

I received a very satisfying response from Customer Service after a package got lost in travel. So far, I have nothing but good things to say about the site. Both the search engine and the notice of now-available items seem to work perfectly! Keep up the good work!
— Mauro F., Montevideo, Uruguay

I love your site. You almost always have what I'm looking for and I've never had a problem ordering from you. Thank you for being an outstanding resource for a giant happy nerd like myself.
— Tom M., Spokane, WA

Great selection and prices as always!
— Christopher D., Brookhaven, MS

Thank you so very much for the large selection and decent prices. I love you guys!
— Judy W., Northlake, TX

Thanks, I love doing Business with you!
— Nikki C., Evandale, OH

Thanks again for your fast and fair trade assessment! It's a blast doing business with you guys!
— Brett G., Whitefish Bay, WI

As always, it is truly a pleasure to do business with your shop. Thank you very much.
— Clayton E., Orrville, OH