Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

I've been very happy selling comics to you and "through you" (consignment). Consolidating comics for a credit order is very easy and applying that credit seems easy too (first time I'm trying to order something from you). I continue to be impressed with how easy your website is to use for various things.
— James S., Richfield, MN

Great store - incredible selection, reasonable prices, easy trade-in, prompt and safe shipping. Overall a wonderful experience - far and away the best online comic store.
— Steven A., Webster, NY

I graded my comics to the best of my ability. Your pro graders might be pulling their hair out by the end of my order. (I Hope Not!) I have a lot of comics to sell and I have heard nothing but rave reviews about you guys, so I figured I would give you a try. If some of my comics grade lower, that's alright, it won't cause me a nervous breakdown or anything. Anyway, thanks again.
— Craig N., Newhall, CA

Your response helped me dig a little deeper, plus I just chatted with the actual consignment director. I am well-armed with what I need to make rational choices. Time to dig into the boxes and decide what else to send to y'all. I have been so impressed by every aspect of the website and your business model, but especially my direct interactions with Lone Star Comics staff (Buddy, and now Este). Some communication was in writing and some was verbal. Both avenues have been characterized by amazing promptness, responsiveness to the specific issues, and pleasant supportiveness. We are at the beginnings of a relationship, and a lot more steps must happen before any transaction has been fully concluded. I am filled with optimism that the middle and end will be as good as this beginning.
— Joan M., Seattle, WA

Let's start yet another trade! They all go so smoothly that you will keep me well stocked in new unread material for years to come! Thanks as always, have a great weekend, and rest up for the big.....event?,deal?,catastrophe? of DC's 3D Villains month!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Thanks for the best buy/trade system......ever!
— Aaron C., Chandler, AZ

This is the first time I am dealing with mycomicshop and I am VERY pleased by the site layout! Easy to use!
— Ashley P., Johnston, RI

This is my first time trading in some comics. I'm trying to clear some space in my small apartment. I'm sure you've heard that story before! I'm planning to use the store credit to get some old Milestone comics. I'm pretty new to this whole scene. Thanks for making your site so easy to use.
— Tom L., Silver Spring, MD

I am an avid collector of both comics and art, so I love your service.
— Elton J., Chicago, IL

Thanks for all you do for comics.
— Marc T., Fort Walton Beach, FL

My last experience selling to you was such a pleasant experience that I've decided to sell more of my comics you!
— Randy D., Charles City, IA

Thanks for offering this service. I'm trying to clear out some duplicates and comics that I no longer need or want. I'm going to be using the cash for a trip to Disneyworld for my family in the middle of September. Thank you in advance.
— Michael T., Eastpointe, MI

Y'all are great!
— John B., Sioux Falls, SD

I love your website. I'm trying to parcel out my collection a little bit at a time and use the money to hunt for other items at places such as yard sales and estate sales to keep up the hobby. Thanks! I look forward to being a long time customer, both buyer and seller!
— Edwin M., Chesapeake, VA

We came across these comics and had no idea what they were worth until we went to your site. The site has been a very valuable tool for researching these items and preparing a selling offer to you.
— Billie Joe E., Buffalo, WV

I've had a bunch of these just sitting around for years, but a friend recently got me back into comics. Now I'm getting rid of stuff I don't want and making space for stuff I do want. Thanks for helping me out and making it so easy.
— Phillip F., Dallas, TX

This is my first time dealing with consignment. I would like to list as a set price. Feedback on the appropriate price would be greatly appreciated. I have listed some issues that I am selling as I am cutting back on my collection. I have been ordering from you guys for years and have had a wonderful experience. Thank you.
— Kyle S., Beaumont, CA

I enjoy collecting comics, but I am looking to sell part of my collection. I have a baby on the way. Your website is an excellent source to sell, trade, and buy. I have been telling all my friends about it. Thank you.
— Edward R., Ewa Beach, HI

Hi Buddy - Not sure you'll want all these quantities because some of the numbers are sort of big, but you continue to surprise me! Hope things are going well. Shane and his team really, really exceeded my expectations - again. But this last effort was nothing short of remarkable. No details needed - they just really came through in a big way. Thanks again.
— Mark D., Santa Barbara, CA

More comics on the way to you. I'd love to get these in your next auction. Really happy with the current bids.
— Todd G., Cape Coral, FL

This is the second time I've sold comics to Lone Star Comics. My first transaction went very smoothly.
— Tom A., Patterson, NJ

I came across mycomicshop.com by chance while trying to value a box of comics I obtained for free. That was six months ago. That experience was so good for me that I started to buy comic books from numerous sources, i.e. craigslist, garage sales, and estate sales. Collecting and selling comics has grown from a fluke to a full time hobby which I really enjoy and has grown into a passion. I would definitely recommend mycomicshop to anyone who has comics. Mycomicshop.com is a fair and easy way to obtain values for your collection. I don't think there is a better way to do business in the comic book industry!
— Paul D., Phoenix, AZ

Mycomicshop is a great site for so many reasons, and I plan to continue using it. I am very excited to begin collecting and selling! The comics I'm sending have been graded to the best of my ability. While I anticipate some variance in grading, I hope I was very close. Thanks for your help. Your new fan.
— Matthew H., Cleveland, TN

Am sending a few more boxes of comics down Texas way. Hope you are doing well, Buddy and Conan. By the way, I turned a local store on to your site. He tells me that he uses you guys often and it has really helped him with his business. :)
— Heath P., Newport News, VA

I really liked your website. It was very easy to navigate and the pictures really helped.
— Shelby H., Shelby Township, MI

Thank you, guys! You guys Rock!
— Carl S., Ft. Wayne, IN

This is my second consignment transaction with you as a seller and so far I am enjoying the experience.
— David S., Chicago, IL

You have really helped me enjoy buying collections. I keep what I need for my permanent collection and trade the remaining comics for credit to purchase even more items I need. Thanks for having the absolute best trade-in system I have ever seen!
— Aaron C., Chandler, AZ

Buddy, I am coming across collections right and left this summer. Expect two or three more boxes soon via your online buying option. The San Diego Comic Con is next week and I can’t wait to have fun.
— Phil H., Corona, CA

I am not a comic collector. Given that, I especially appreciate your help with this transaction. I find that everything about your site is amazing and have enjoyed the thorough breakdown of how and why things are done the way they are.
— Raul P., Palm Bay, FL

Bought my first mail order comics from you about 30 years ago - still buying from you and haven't been disappointed yet!
— Bradley J., Jacksonville, FL

Thanks for the cool website and cash sale option.
— Steven M., Santee, CA

First time consigning books with mycomicshop. Really appreciated how helpful Conan was to folks on the CGC boards, which further eased my concerns regarding consignment for auction.
— Howard W., Cerro Gordo, NC

I have about 12,000 comics and need to "cull" those I can sell at this time. I'm retired and have plenty of time to sort and catalog them. Your site was recommended by a friend who has used it many times. I hope to do ongoing business with your company in the coming months, as many of my listed items show they will be on your "want list". Fully 95-99% of my comics have never been read and have been protected in sleeves and backing boards, so they should rate as NM or even higher once you see them. Thank you.
— Mark F., Molalla, OR

I've done business with you several times over the last year and consider you to be my favorite online comic shop. Thanks for doing what you do.
— Scott S., Woodridge, IL

Thank you so much. This completes a collection I recently bought, so afterwards I will go back to being a usual customer. I really do appreciate you taking these overstock comics off my hands!
— Trevor F., La Canada, CA

I can't seem to get my overstocks recorded into your system fast enough to keep your buying needs satisfied, so my trade lots just keep coming your way! In fact, here's my next batch. Thanks so much!
— Michael T., Ft. Worth, TX

I have been collecting comics since the 1960's. Mycomicshop.com has provided me with a viable method for selling portions of my collection.
— Shawn C., Redondo Beach, CA

You folks just get better and better! I can't thank you enough.
— James S., Boxboro, MA

Thank you for allowing me the opportunity to deal with you. I have had nothing but a positive experiences selling comics to you guys.
— Jeffrey R., Marietta, GA

You guys are quick! And the offer for my 80 long boxes of comics sounds great - I accept your very your professional offer! I am very appreciative of the way you have handled buying my entire lot and just not some of them! Thanks for everything!
— Guy P., Wabash, IN

Love the website. Great setup!
— Ryan W., Burbank, CA

I got these comics from a comic shop closing. I have been trying to sell them and hopefully you can take them off my hands. I sold many on eBay, but that takes a lot of time. I have tons more older comics that have 15 to 25 cent covers. I will list them soon as well. Thanks in advance.
— David F., Ellington, CT

Hello, I've been doing business with you guys for a little while now. You guys are awesome. Not only am I an avid comic reader, but I enjoy collecting as well.
— Collin S., Cape Girardeau, MO

I was referred to your site by an online friend I do some trading with. I've collected comics off and on for about 30 years. I need to thin out my collection and convert it to TPBs, and this looks like a good place to start. I've heard nothing but good things about your site, and am looking forward to dealing with you.
— Greg T., West Des Moines, IA

Hi there, first time submitting a sale lot. I went with the green default for each comic, with the understanding that your grades are likely to be different. Thanks for such a great user-friendly website!
— Josh H., Beloit, WI

Gotta earn that trade credit for when the Promethea Immateria edition hits the shelves.
— Danimal P., Abingdon, VA

I have enjoyed purchasing from you before, and have especially enjoyed the delicate care and friendly service you have given me. Thank you for your time considering this trade. Have a super day!
— James D., Idaho Falls, ID

Thanks for all the effort. I really do thank you for the service.
— James S., Boxboro, MA

Love you guys!
— Shawn L., Gainesville, FL