Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

Buddy, Your offer sounds good to me. I plan on sending stuff your way as long as you're buying. Thanks again for the great service. :) Marc
— Marc M., Jackson, MO

I've ordered comics from your site, but this is my first time selling my own comics. I am really interested in getting store credit so I can order more comics for my collection. I really like your web site.
— Matt P., Provo, UT

Thanks for yet another very satisfactory buy/trade transaction. I've said before that you not only provide the best service available, but also provide an opportunity for me to compare and improve on my own grading ability. I'm getting better at grading! In my most recent transaction with you, there was only a 5 cents difference between my grading and yours! Thanks again!
— Wesley H., Phoenixville, PA

This is the second time I've traded comics with you. I love that Mycomicshop makes it possible for me fill holes in my comic collection without having to spend cash.
— James S., Boxboro, MA

Here is my latest trade offering. I appreciate the quality of my previous trades and look forward to trading with you again. Thanks!
— Brian L., Santa Maria, CA

You have a terrifically detailed and complete web site. I've bought from you many times in the past, but never sold until now. Your on-line store credit offer is very fair, and there is tons of stuff I'd like to acquire from your web site. These are just some of the extra comics I've acquired in 44 years of collecting.
— Gene K., Waterloo, IA

Thanks again for your service and your assistance with my on-line trade to you.
— Stephen T., Dallas, TX

Long time comics reader with way too much stuff sitting around and gathering dust. A friend of mine has used your site and has had plenty of good stuff to say about you. Looking forward to completing a successful and mutually beneficial transaction.
— Will M., Kicksville, NY

I'm really enjoying trading with Lone Star Comics. I'm very pleased with the fairness and professionalism I've been treated to. This lot will be shipped in the same packaging with my previous trade in order to save shipping costs.
— Frank C., Harvard, MA

This is my 12th comic trade with you, and I am still satisfied with your service! Fair and industrious. You all have set a standard in customer service for every industry. I used my trade credit to get some older, rarer comics, and I thank you for introducing me to those stories I have not read before.
— Phillip K., Astoria, NY

We received your check. Thank you very much. We hope to find more items of interest to you in the not too distant future.
— Robert S., Old Saybrook, CT

I appreciate the increase in trade value for the CGC comic. After factoring in all the fees and shipping expenses, it costs me about $20 for each book I send to CGC. It's nice to be able to get fair return value in this economy. Thanks.
— Mason C., New Hyde Park, NY

Hi there, I've been using your sub-service and website--really enjoying how comprehensive it is--and now want to trade some recent issues I've been accumulating.
— Alex S., New York, NY

I have been collecting comics since 1968. This time I am weeding out some dupes acquired in a small dealer buyout from 1996. You have a great system. I hope to do more business with you in the future.
— John L., Austin, TX

Hi, Here's more comics. I'm looking more for trade credit, and I love your site--it's the best in the business.
— Steve M., Libertyville, IL

Thanks! I accept your trade offer. As always, it's a pleasure to deal with you all either in buying or trading/selling!
— Wesley H., Phoenixville, PA

Hi Buddy, We received your check for our first lot of comics. We're very satisfied with the grading and results, so we're ready to do a second batch. Many Thanks!
— Don E., Manchester, CT

I always have a great and fair time trading with you. Looking forward to another transaction!
— Aaron C., Bartlett, TN

Glad to be once again using your awesome comic trading service!
— Dennis R., Edwardsville, PA

I am a 42-year-old who is back into collecting after 20+ years...a Bronze Age kid mostly. Just looking to unload some titles for store credit. This will be my first attempt using your trading service. I purchased some comics from you recently and was very happy with them.
— Jay S., Spencerport, NY

My friend got industrious and found more of her comics that were on your want list. This is working out great for her.
— David H., Alexandria, VA

I own a comic shop in Bozeman, Montana. We are a small town (36,000 people). When I don’t sell all of a new issue, I once had a hard time doing anything with the overage, but now I can trade them to you, then use the credit to get items on my customer want lists
— Lincoln E., Bozeman, MT

My friend and I are purging the extraneous books from our collections and will use the credit to trade for comics we enjoy reading and collecting.
— David H., Alexandria, VA

Thanks again guys! Always a pleasure doing business with you!
— Desmond H., Tallahassee, FL

Buddy, Thanks! I don't do business with anyone else. You guys are simply the best.
— Nathan M., Spring Arbor, MI

Hi Buddy, Fabulous! Yes, I accept your generous offer and look forward to receiving your check. In the meantime, I'll use the same method to prepare the list of my sister's remaining titles for you to review.
— Don E., Manchester, CT

WOW! I love this! I'm cleaning out all my old comics, etc. and this site is awesome for that! I tried to grade some of the comics, but that is sorta confusing for me, so I mostly just used your default grading option.
— Nicole B., Brooklyn, MD

I would just like to say that you have been very fair in your grading. I will continue to do business with your company. Thank you.
— Donald C., Erie, PA

Good morning, Buddy. First I want to say how much I like the new consolidation option for submitting trade offers. It is great. I've really been able to pare down the comics I've been sitting on.
— Dan J., Springfield, IL

Here's my second load going to you guys. Thanks for the quick response to the first trade. Thank you for your service. You are by far the most accomodating of any comic book site we have. I really do appreciate it. Take care, friends!
— Jeremy B., Murray, KY

Thanks for your sell/trade consolidation option. It's very helpful for small fries like me.
— Mason C., New Hyde Park, NY

Hey guys, I absolutely love your site. I'm a comic collector who works with databases so I've long imagined a resource such as yours, but only stumbled upon this one a few weeks ago. The comics I'm trading are a blend from my childhood and extra books picked up recently in my efforts to build a full run of Amazing Spider-Man. I've already got my eye on one of your items. Hope to do more business in the future.
— Dennis C., Arlington, VA

I've enjoyed all my comic trades with mycomicshop.com. Thanks!
— Christopher F., Pittsfield, MA

I just want to first say that I started buying comics from you guys a little less than a year ago and I have never had a problem, so thank you very much. I am an amateur collector and I started collecting with my friends Clay S, and Anthony C., who also buy comics from you. Thanks again and you will most definitely be hearing from me again.
— Robert B., Columbiana, OH

Great comics trade experience first time, so here's my second lot.
— Frank C., Harvard, MA

Thank you! You were very timely in getting back to me, and I am quite happy at your grading. I am also totally fine with your offer. So much so, in fact, that I'm putting together another batch of comics that I would also like to trade. You have so many titles that I can't find anywhere else. I am so happy to have found Mycomicshop!
— Arlan S., Eugene, OR

Hi, I have completed many trades with you. More to come. Thank you for your great service.
— Boyd R., Bedford, TX

Just a quick note to say how much I love the easy, utilitarian interface of your website. You guys also have a great selection!
— Ryan G., New York, NY

Thanks guys. You are as fair when you buy as you are when you sell. Merry Christmas!
— Jim M., Arrington, TN

Hi Lone Star Comics, my first buy/trade transaction with you has been a pleasure from start to finish. Thank you!
— Douglas H., Oakland, CA

Thanks to Shane for adding the credit for the Star Wars issue. I am very pleased with this trade transaction and look forward to the next.
— Nathon H., Crosby, TX

I am still digging through around 70 thousand comics and will offer all Marvel and DC from 1981 and earlier that are on the want list. I want to thank you for all the great transactions over the last few years. I sincerely hope that all at Lone Star Comics have a happy, healthy, and safe holiday. Still snowed in!
— William L., Mount Jackson, VA

Hello, A-team! I just wanted to let you know that I dropped off my comics trade at the post office for you yesterday. I am so psyched! You have several titles that I have not been able to find anywhere else, and believe me, I've looked a lot! Thank you for everything!
— Arlan S., Eugene, OR

I’m doing another trade consolidation. Thanks so much for this great new feature!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Thanks guys, always great dealing with you and I hope to get another batch of comics in to you for a cash offer before the end of the year.
— Scott C., Lehi, UT

Buddy, I am slowly getting through my collection and have a couple more boxes of earlier comics to go through. You folks have been great to work with--very professional and honest. Thanks again!
— Jim B., Polson, MT

Each time I do a comics trade, you guys are fair with your grading! It is much appreciated!
— Aaron C., Bartlett, TN

I only just recently discovered your web-site, and have to say, I really like the ease of use. On top of that, you have so many more titles available than most, and at very reasonable prices, and your shipping costs are unbeatable! Having purchased a quantity of comics at your eBay store, I was quite impressed at the speed of delivery, with each and every issue in the quality as described. I will always come here first for my comic shopping needs. Thank you!
— Arlan S., Eugene, OR

Hey, thanks. It was very helpful to get this kind of feedback on my grading. This is an excellent system, very easy to use and a great way to trade up using your shop. Thanks, you guys are great!
— Frank C., Harvard, MA

Buddy, A few months ago I sold my collection of 1950's comics to your company. I wanted to let you know how satisfied I was with the whole transaction. I wish I had known about your company 10 years ago when I made several abortive attempts to sell my collection. That experience was frustratingly unsuccessful. My experience with your company was exactly the opposite. Once I discovered your online system, I knew I wanted to do business with you. Your data base is unbelievable. My compliments to your software and data base people. No one should ever sell their comics without using it. Your customer support was also top notch. I had several conversations (in person and on the phone) with your employee Este. She knows her business and was extremely helpful. Once I had used your software to "estimate my own grade" on my comics and submitted them to you folks for your inspection, I thought your evaluation was very fair. Count me as a very pleased customer (who is $970 richer as a result of the sale) and would recommend your company to anyone who is selling their collection.
— Verne G., Rockwall, TX