Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

Thanks for taking my trade-ins and thanks for having such a huge selection. It was really difficult to choose exactly what I wanted because you guys have way too many great books to choose from, thanks again and have a great day!
— John O., Judsonia, AR

Okay, I just have to say it....best collection and variety I've seen in an online shop yet! Outstanding website, and I love the option to sell books and get them graded. Really helped me get a handle on the value of my collection. Thanks for all these Spideys. You guys rock!
— Brad C., Charlotte, NC

Wow guys, great trade credit and wonderful selection, thank you so much. This is the best comic website ever. You have made shopping for comics online easy, affordable and fun!
— Grant T., Abingdon, VA

For years, I bought comics at your Lone Star Comics locations in Dallas, where I lived my whole life until I moved to L.A. in 2003. I'm glad I found you guys online, and glad you are doing well. Now that I know there is a reputable company like you guys to go to, I hope to find more awesome comics in the future.
— James S., North Hollywood, CA

I buy comics from you all the time! I love your shop. This is my first time trading comics. I hope it goes as smoothly as buying them does :)
— Tashera D., Longview, WA

This is the only place to buy and trade your comics.
— William R., Bayside, NY

Have purchased from you before and wanted to compliment you on your service and product.
— Lynn F., Diamond Bar, CA

Thanks! This is a great system, easy to use and fair. I appreciate your honesty in grading and look forward to doing business with you again.
— Jeff W., Greensboro, NC

Another great comic trade! Look for another batch of comics from me soon! Thanks!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

I trade you some comics, then I trade for some comics, then I trade more comics, then trade for more. It never ends and I love it! Thanks a lot!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Here's another small batch of comics for 100% cash. Hope all is well, Buddy. It has been a pleasure doing business with all of you! Have a great week.
— Heath P., Northport, AL

Buddy - Just a note to let you know that I received the check for the Detective Comics collection I sent to you. Thanks for such prompt action!
— Pat D., Leesburg, GA

Your offer for my 1920-30s era newspaper comic strip books sounds fine. Considering the condition the Uncle Wiggly books are in, I imagine the bulk of your offer is for the Skeezix, Smitty, and Bringing Up Father titles.
— Ruth B., Kirkland, WA

Dear Mr. Saunders, Thank you so much for your generous offer. Since I began doing business with you three and one-half years ago, I have been more than satisfied with your offers, the quick turnaround time, and the professionalism. Your offers are always the best ones I've received, and I've yet to meet another dealer more congenial. And you even reimburse for the shipping! Now that's a deal! I enjoy our buyer/seller relationship, and I will definitely continue to do business with you in the years to come. Also, thank you for making each transaction painless.
— Terri S., Pikesville, MD

It's been a pleasure doing business with Mycomicshop. You have dealt with me very fairly. I've found your on line system easy to operate and my comics have been graded accurately. I still have a few more comics to sell, but they are not on your open to-buy list. I'll keep checking, and when you're ready to buy I'll be ready to sell.
— William B., Moundsville, WV

Buddy, thank you for such an excellent offer for my Batman and Detective comics. As always, your offer is more than fair. And thank you for such great service. After Easter, I will ship my Superman collection to you. Looking forward to doing more business with you and your company.
— Pat D., Leesburg, GA

I appreciate the professional manner in which you treated my last trade transaction with your company. This prompted me to look over my collection again, and offer more comics to trade. Again, I appreciate the great manner in which you treat your customers, as well as the fair offer that you make on my trade, and the timely manner in which the transaction was completed. Your company is doing a great job in making a regular customer out of me.
— Shawn B., Norman, OK

Greetings fellow comic lovers, I stumbled across your site entirely by accident while looking for hard to find Predator comics. I am very happy I did! Your prices are amazing, and the selection is larger by far than anything I've seen. I have had a bunch of comics sitting around for a long time now, and I didn't want to simply yard sale them away, or continue letting them lay around in a dark box serving no purpose. So I've had a friend who fancies himself a comic guru take a look at the ones I am submitting via your trading system. I will trust your judgment as to final grade. I hope to hear from you soon, many thanks.
— Randy B., Modcow, PA

Buddy, the revised offer for my comics, TPBs and comic strip reprint editions is fine. Thanks!
— Richard L., Louisville, KY

This is my first time dealing with Mycomicshop. I have heard great things from several friends who sell and trade with you and wanted to see if it was true. So here I am. I am sure I will be presently surprised. Thank you.
— Travis F., Roanoke, VA

Love this site. You make it so easy for people to sell their stuff (at a very fair price). I look forward to more dealings with you.
— Tom S., Stoneham, MA

I was originally going to keep these issues, but I'm having a great time trading and buying. Thanks for a wonderful experience.
— William R., Bayside, NY

Buddy, I want to thank you for the fair offer on my early Spider-Man comics. I was also impressed that, although they were not high grade issues, they sold immediately on your site. I hope they give joy to their new owners.
— Victor G., Novelty, OH

I was very pleased with my first sale to your business. I am now cataloging the rest of my collection for sale. Here is a start of Marvels beginning with the letter "A."
— Mark S., Laurel, MD

This is my first time trading comics with you, but I have heard many great things about you guys.
— Grant S., Graham, NC

This will be my second time selling to you. I have to say that your system is by far the easiest way to sell comics online. Your testimonial page is full of praise for your service, so I'm not going to repeat words that have already been said. But I do want to mention that the thing that impressed me the most was that the check I received was signed in pen. I could see the grooves of the signature. It was not a passionless stamp. More than anything, that showed just what kind of a personal touch this transaction was given. Thank you.
— Tim K., Troy, NY

Thank you all for your constant effort and great customer service!
— Scott T., Bradenton, FL

I'm happy with everything. Thanks for trading with me!
— Ryan C., West Linn, OR

I'm an actor and long time comic reader. Thank you for a great service and giving me an opportunity to trade comics with you. I look forward to using my credit to shop from your site.
— Anthony P., Redondo Beach, CA

Your trade/buy system is most appreciated! Thanks again.
— Bob G., San Francisco, CA

Sold! Thanks guys!
— Bill F., Phildelphia, PA

Sweet. Thanks for a great comic trade!
— Adam N., Palos Heights, IL

Thanks very much for your rapid response to my e-mail of 3/16 and for your generous offer regarding my trade transaction.
— Stephen T., Dallas, TX

Hi Buddy and gang, Happy St. Patty's day and thanks so much again and again for providing this terrific comic buying service!
— Donna L., Albuquerque, NM

Hi Buddy, Here are some more books from my collection. As always nice trading with you.
— Mike W., Auburn, NY

Hi Buddy, I have never fully understood how on earth you can ship books overseas at practically no cost to the customer. You are the best and cheapest. Expect many more orders from me in the future. Thanks for great service, reasonable prices, and the best selection of comics I have found. Best regards. PS: And yeah... it is a d--- shame we are both at the mercy of careless postal workers. :-)
— Michael M., Holstebro, Denmark

I'm a first time trader at your site. Thanks guys for making my comic trade go so smoothly.
— Mikel I., Franklin, IN

Thanks for the smooth transactions. I look forward to trading more with your company.
— Anthony S., Brandon, FL

I accept your offer for my comics; I'm glad they are in better hands and will go to collectors who will appreciate them. Your website was a pleasure to use. And the customer service was excellent.
— Patrick R., Los Angeles, CA

Dear Buddy, I would like to say it's been a pleasure to do business with you, and thank you for very quick service regarding the Fawcett UK comic editions I sold to you.
— Charles B., Camberley, United Kingdom

Many thanks for your great buy/trade service!
— Alan D., Glens Falls, NY

Thank you so much for having your buy/trade service!
— Peter T., Marshfield, MA

Buddy, five boxes of comics went out to you on Tuesday, and three more shipped Saturday. Today, as you'll see, I'm submitting another nice-sized lot. Hope all is well with you. As always, your buy/trade site is great.
— Jack B., Franklinville, NJ

Your trade credit offer for my comic sounds great. Thanks a lot.
— Gene F., Sacramento, CA

Hey Buddy, how are you doing? Thanks for trading with me.
— Mike W., Auburn, NY

As always, thanks for the great sell/trade service.
— Bob G., San Francisco, CA

Here is another batch of comics from my personal collection of Mad magazines and Cracked. I am really enjoying your buy/trade system. I can't wait to do more business with you. Thank you and have a wonderful weekend.
— William B., Miami, FL

Your trade offer sounds great! I've now traded most of my extras to Mycomicshop. I really appreciate your help. And your newest offer is, as usual, very fair.
— Bill M., Shawnee, OK

I have become a recent seller to mycomicshop.com and have been very satisfied with the work you are doing. After four transactions completed, I feel like the process has been very fair. You received my 5th batch yesterday. Once I have that additional credit, I am planning on making a large purchase above and beyond the resulting credit total.
— Samuel F., Indianapolis, IN

The stores I took my comics to showed little interest in what I had. Most (not all) of them were indifferent to downright rude. After that experience, I decided to try your buy/trade system. I found it to be incredibly easy and very convenient. Now I can sell some of my older comics and in the process make room for the new comics I buy! I will do it again and again, and will never again have to face unfriendly comic store owners! Bless you!
— Michael S., Arlington Heights, IL