Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Customers

Hi Buddy, I just wanted express my gratitude. It was great to finally meet you in person. I was pleasantly surprised you were able to offer more cash for my excess Silver Age books than my high end expectation. I was surprised at how quickly you all were able to make that offer, also. There were 22 boxes and less than a week later you had an offer. Superb. I will continue to trade books with you online for issues I am out of stock on and to fill customer want lists. Your web site is so easy to use and so hassle free that I think your programmers deserve a raise!! Once again, it was a pleasure!!!
— Terry S., Houston, TX

Dear Buddy, I just wanted to thank you for working with me on the sale of my Vampirella Magazines. I could not believe it when you said you would meet me at your office ON YOUR DAY OFF to look at my magazines. No other buyer has ever offered to do that for me. When we met, I got a good feeling about you right from the start, and was very comfortable in leaving my magazines with you for review and grading. You were genuinely interested in what I had to say and your grading was very fair. Once I received and accepted your offer, my check arrived within just a few days. Again, something I have never seen. Usually, it takes a couple weeks to get my money from a buyer and I have even had instances where I had to contact them a second time to ?remind them? that I was waiting on payment. This was not the case with Lone Star! I look forward to working with you in the future and wish you the best in your business. We need more folks like you in the industry.
— Tony E., Pfluserville, TX

Just received my latest offer for a trade/sale transaction. It was a very good offer, thanks again! I just realized I've been selling/trading with Lone Star Comics for about 18 months (How time flies when you're having fun!). The reasons that keep me coming back are good offers, courtesy and your professional way of transacting business. An option that you have which is very appealing to me is part % cash / part % trade.  I not only get cash for what I send in, but also receive trade credit that goes into my account that can be used to purchase items whenever I want to. It's a win, win situation!
— Stan B., Oklahoma City, OK

Buddy, Lone Star's superior customer service, promptness and fairness epitomize the very thing which are missing in our world. I was apprehensive to ship my comics to you at first, but now after completing my first sale, I will be shipping more stuff your way. Your offer was about 15% below what I thought I may get (I was a bit off in my grading), but was 3 times more than the locals were offering.  I live in Iowa, I shipped my comics late in the afternoon on Tuesday, and I will have your check in hand Saturday morning. I dare anyone to find a quicker turnaround than that. The ease of your system has made me want to deal with your company for years to come. Thank you. I hope someone enjoys my Tales of Suspense #1.
— Chris C., Tiffin, IO

I was extremely impressed and very satisfied about my recent experience selling about 50 1940's era comic books through your company.  The amount offered, the service, and the detailed explanation of how the condition of my comics were evaluated exceeded my expectations. I live in a rural area, where even finding a nearby comic shop is difficult. I was uncertain about mailing valuable comics to be evaluated, but the next time I am interested in selling some comics, I will go to Lone Star Comics first. 
— Michael C., Worcester, NY

Buddy delivered on everything he promised. He has a terrific web site which outlines the entire selling process and answers all your questions up front. I recommend to anyone wanting to sell their old comic collections to use Buddy's service, Webuycomics.com.
— Jim M., Waukesha, WI

Your offer is more than fair, and I definitely accept. I am *very* pleased; your advertisements did not overstate the fact that your offers are fair and even generous!  The next time I can get to my storage unit, I will pull out more comics to send to your company. One collection I am thinking of selling is the entire run (from the old western issues) of Jonah Hex, most of which are in F/NM. Thanks again for your offer and I accept!
— Vince P., Grand Junction, CO

Buddy, It was great doing business with you. I got a better price than I had hoped for, and in the process I avoided your competitor. Fast, prompt, and friendly. What more is there to ask for?
— Bob B., Long Beach, CA

Thanks for your help in selling my comic book collection. The experience was hassle free. You and your company performed as advertised.
— Ron ., Palm Desert, CA

When I had to liquidate my mother's estate, I knew there were people who would love to have some of the comics she had saved. I also knew I couldn't begin to find and contact them. Then I found the Lone Star Comic web page and I was so pleased that they would do it for me. It is truly a win-win situation.
— Jeri M., Mount Harmon, CA

Lone Star Comics made it easy and fast to sell my comic collection. I had considered selling them a few at a time to your competitor, but with Lone Star I got the convenience of selling them all at once to a reputable dealer for a great price. Would I go to Lone Star again? In a heartbeat!
— Connie N., , CO

Buddy, When I decided to sell my comic collection, my wife and I spent a lot of time browsing the web to find sites that buy comic books. There are a lot of them out there, but we finally decided to go with yours because it looked so professional, and seemed really upfront about everything. We even took your advice and asked around at local comics shops first, to get an idea of what the books were worth. From the ho-hum responses (and of course they wanted to pick them over instead of taking the whole collection), we decided to send them on down to you. Boy are we glad we did! I wasn't home when you called, so when my wife told me just now that you had made an offer for my comics collection, I was prepared for the worst (I'm a real pessimist). You could have knocked me over with a feather when she told me that your offer beat my best guess by about three times! I always loved my comics so, of course, they were valuable to me, but I sure never expected that they would be worth so much money! This has been a great transaction for us! We will definitely be recommending you to our friends! 
— James S., , MO

I wholeheartedly endorse webuycomics.com as the way to go if you are looking for an efficient way to sell your comic collection for a great price. I had about 1000 comics from the 60's which I wanted to sell. I wasted a LOT of time with your competitor trying to do something myself and then saw Buddy's buy/trade cart concept and felt it was the way to go. Just to be sure, I took a stack of comics and ran them through his cart system and approximated what they would be worth to him. I then took the same comics to a dealer in New York which is close to me. After looking through them, he offered me less(and with the attitude that he was doing me a favor). I sent the same comics to Buddy and got three times his offer, the first of several sales I made to mycomicshop.com.  The payments are sent super-fast and it is just a pleasure doing business with this outfit. I have received more than I had even hoped for when I was planning on doing the grunt work! Buddy is definitely the way to go.
— Mike R., , CT

Buddy, Considering how many transactions we have consummated, I think it's about time I gave you some feedback. What you have created with your buy/trade system is unprecedented in the history of comics collecting. You present a comprehensive, constantly updated data base covering a huge (and growing) number of eclectic comic titles, in an easily accessible format. By posting both BUY and SELL prices, including price adjustments to reflect current market supply and demand, you are offering the closest thing to a daily "comic book stock exchange" that has ever existed. Your competitor, lacks the stability, organization, and unified vision necessary to truly provide a comprehensive view of what the overall marketplace is doing, but your pioneering and ever-evolving system has truly secured you a place in the annuals of comic book retailing history.
— Howard M., Somerset, NJ

Thank you!!! I like the site layout, the easy and quick search engine, and the layout of search results which made it easy for me to find what I wanted. I also love the want list idea. This was a positive experience, thanks again!
— Stephanie M., Brandywine, MD

Hey, this site is pretty inexpensive compared to some others I've seen, and there was also a significantly better selection. Keep up the awesome work, and you've got yourself a lifelong customer!
— Sean H., Toms River, NJ

My comics last time were great, with no hassle.
— James B., Boyne City, MI

This is the first time I've ordered from you, and I hope it's the first of many! Great website. Easy to use. I look forward to receiving the comics.
— Ben L., Stafford, United Kingdom

Dear Mr. Saunders, Thanks for your prompt reply. I would like to accept your offer for the lot of comics that I sent to you. I will continue to keep watching your want list.  I've found your system extremely easy to use, and I've been very pleased in my dealings with your company.
— Scott R. M., Muncie, IN

Hey Guys & Ladies, This will be my 6th sale to mycomicshop.com. You have made it very easy to sell my comics and I appreciate it. I am a comic reader, but not a fastidious collector. After inheriting an inventory from a comics store, I really didn't know what to do with the books. Thanx, Lone Star and remember, GO RAMS!!!!!
— Homer B., Union City, GA

Buddy, That sounds great. I accept your offer. I now have two long and two short comics boxes of pre-1980 comics read to ship. 
— Vince P., Grand Junction, CO

Dear Buddy, Your cash offer is acceptable. Thank you for taking the time to talk to me and evaluating the comics. Thank you again. I would like to say it has been a pleasure doing business with you.
— Alan K., Rolla, MO

Dear Buddy, I accept your offer for the batch of Marvel comics. I hope your having a great day. Keep up the good job!
— David E., Washington, DC, WA

Sounds excellent; thank you very much. As usual, I enjoy doing business with you and your company.
— Tim E., Stockton, CA

Thank you for your offer. I will accept it. You have been very easy to deal with and prompt with your follow-up. 
— Sandra D., Mechanicsburg, PA

We accept your offer for our Classics Illustrated comics, and thank you for your time. 
— Kathy F., Brandon, SD

Buddy, Thank you. Your site is great, and it's good to be back trading with you.
— Jack B., Franklinville, NJ

Hi, Thank you for your offer. I accept, and I look forward to doing business with you in the future.
— Mike P., Del Norte, CO

Buddy, As usual; your offer is very fair. Thanks.
— Joel P., Bethesda, MD

Hello Buddy! Your offer sounds good. 
— Felton C., San Angelo, TX

Paying with store credit was incredibly easy! Great process from selling my books for credit to picking out my new treasures from you website! 
— Matthew H., Stow, OH

Mr. Saunders, Thank you for your offer! I accept. Now that I have seen your system work (which is very efficient and user-friendly), I will send more comic lots in the future.  Thank you for your time!
— Jeremy R., Huntsville, AL

Your offer is acceptable. Thank you for the great service.
— Greg L., Auburndale, FL

Placed my first order with my trade money. That was LOADS of fun!!! Ordered 2 nice books.
— James L., Oceanside, NY

Buddy, it sounds like a great offer. I look forward to receiving the check.
— Vince P., Grand Junction, CO

Well, you guys rock! I will ship my comics to you, per your shipping tips, forthwith! Thanks for the quick and positive response. The local comics store guy could use some tips from you.
— Michael R., Augusta, GA

Afternoon, Buddy! Just a brief e-mail to let you know how grateful we are for the purchase of the vintage Golden Age comics I had for sale.  Please thank Brent for all his hard work that day (he said you owed him a lunch!). 
— Larry & Rebecca ., Whittle, TX

Dear Buddy, Its a deal! I accept the offer.
— David E., Washington, DC, WA

Hi Buddy, I will be sending you a full comic box of 10cent comics this week for your consideration. I am needing to thin down my inventory once again. Thanks again for such steadfast service and honorable pricing quotes.
— Terri G., Richardson, TX

Your offer is very satisfactory. Thank you.
— Adolfo A., Brooklyn, NY

Hi Buddy, I accept your offer for my comics, and once again it is a great pleasure doing business with you folks. Thanks again! I still have more to come!
— Ernie B., Morgan Hill, CA

Yes, I will accept the cash offer. Thanx again!
— David B., Brooklyn, NY

Here's my 14th Option #2 trade comics lot. Also going to try one of your other trading options. Will e-mail a list. Boy, I wish I could visit you guys in person! Great service, great system, and great e-mails from Buddy. Thanks for everything!
— James L., Oceanside, NY

Hey Buddy, I will accept your offer. Thanks a lot.
— Jody R., Lexington, SC

Super, good offer. I have lots of other stuff you may be interested in. The comics I sent came from an estate I'm helping to liquidate.
— Tom P., Greeleyville, SC

Simply stated, it's great doing business with you!
— Homer B., Union City, GA

Dear Buddy, Thank you, we accept your offer.
— Duif C., San Rafael, CA

I just mailed you the package with my autographed Simpsons Comics. Thank you for being great people to deal with. I recommend you to everyone.
— Phil D., Livonia, MI

Buddy, I accept your purchase offer. As usual, it is always a pleasure doing business with you. When the weather breaks and I'm able to get out of the house again...if I can find my van through all this snow (lol), I will ship off another package for you to check out. Again thanks for everything and have a nice week.
— Tyra H., Mexico, NY

Thank you for taking these great Hulk issues(#4 and 5 original series) off my hands as I am getting ready to upgrade to a better condition on both books as well as the Ultimate Spider-Man #1. I hope that I make someone else happy who have been waiting for Hulk 4 and 5 and Ultimate Spider-Man #1. Thanks again for having this option to earn some money to purchase a better condition issues. Take care and as always, you have a customer for life.
— Chris C., Virginia Beach, VA