Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

Hello Buddy & Co., I would like to take CREDIT for comics please. Thanks for your quick processing.
— Greg M., Haverhill, MA

Yes, I accept your offer for my comics. I hope to do business with you again. Thank you.
— Margaret D., North Quincy, MA

Dear Buddy, I accept your offer for the comics I sent to you (Option #1B). It has been good doing business with you. Once again thank you for your attention.
— Dorothy M., Omaha, NE

Thanks a lot! Another fine trade! I really appreciate it!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Thank You so very much again. You guys and your online sell/trade want list system are awesome.
— Michael V., Boise, ID

I've thus far sent in around 600 comics for credit which has been great. I still have around 1,500 or so that I'd like to sell off or get credit for. These books are not on your want list, but I was wondering if you may be interested in them anyway. Mostly early 80's Marvels in high grade.
— Robert L., Macomb, MI

Buddy, Thank you for, as always, your prompt service in grading/pricing my comics. I ACCEPT your offer and again THANK YOU. It is a pleasure doing business with you.
— Patrick D., Leesburg, GA

Thank you for your cash offer which I gladly accept. I shall try to send another package next week. Once again thank you and I hope to do more business with you.
— Heath C., Williamston, NC

Hi Buddy, Thank you very much for taking the time to evaluate my comics. I appreciate it. As always, it is a pleasure doing business with you.
— George H., Corning, IA

Buddy, Thank you for the prompt reply! I would like to take the trade credit offer this time. Thanks again! Doing business with your company is a pleasure!
— Andrew K., Alliance, OH

More stuff to trade! I'm really looking forward to completing some of my runs! Keep up the awesomeness.
— Greg A., Indian Harbour Beach, FL

My trade transaction looks great. Thank you for taking the extra comics not currently on your want list. Everything was fair, easy, and awesome.
— David P., Corona, CA

Thanks. You are great!
— Matthew S., Bedford, Texas

Hello! This is my second submission (one "trade" and one "cash"). I can drop these off at the Hurst or Arlington stores so there is no shipping requirements. Just a note all the earlier Uncanny X-Men comics are signed by John Byrne as I took advantage of his appearances at Lone Star Comics in the early 80s. Thanks!
— Michael B., Euless, TX

I would just like to say that I'm thrilled with the professionalism and care that you all took to make this transaction possible. Went to the UPS store last night and they assure me that you'll get these four boxes (two long and two short) by Thursday, if not, Friday. This has been a real pleasure that I look forward to doing again.
— John K., Yuma, AZ

Mr. Saunders, Much of my collection will soon be in your hands. I will include the oldest material (pre 1981) and those comics in the best shape. Thanks for the time.
— Ed R., Carolina Beach, NC

Hi, I've been real happy with your sale and trade offers you've provided. Thanks for your time and professionalism.
— Stuart S., Winston Salem, NC

Dear Buddy, Received your payment for my Menomonee Falls Gazette lot. The amount you offered was much higher than I was offered locally, and your follow through was prompt and accurate. It was good doing business with you. Thank you very much.
— Richard L., Lousiville, KY

Hi again, Buddy. Thanks a lot for your understanding. And thanks also for your quick response. It's things like that, that make me keep doing business with you and Lone Star Comics.
— Paul G., Cypress, CA

Your website and interface are truly an admirable achievement in efficiency...simply, the best I've seen! I look forward to future transactions with your wonderful company. Thank you.
— Robbie K., Joliet, IL

I'm getting better with my grading. This next week we get serious. Looking at your large buying list and my large amount of pre-1981 comics, it may be good to drive down--just to say we did it and probably save some money (car gets 30 mpg and I have a brother in Houston down by Clear Lake). In any case, I am happy with all my business with you thus far.
— John B., Crestline, OH

To Buddy and the Lone Star crew, I have to say I am very pleased with your offer. I had hoped to do well with my trade in, and this goes well beyond my expectations! Thank you very much!
— Greg H., Raleigh, NC

Hi Buddy, I wanted to let you know that I received your check. Thanks for another smooth transaction.
— Bill Y., Brooklyn, NY

Dear Buddy, Your offer is accepted. Thank you so much.
— Richsard L., Louisville, KY

Thanks very much for your offer. I accept.
— Richard R., Damascus, MD

Buddy, The total offered will be fine. Thank you again!
— Frank Z., Eastlake, OH

Thanks again! I appreciate the grading you do.
— Jayson D., Ripon, WI

Always a pleasure. Thanks.
— Donald H., Chapel Hill, NC

I accept your offer for my comics. Thank you. Very professional and well done. (sold a large Silver Age collection)
— Greg B., Arcadia, CA

Thanks a lot guys. Your offer and grading is a fair assessment. I'm glad my comics in your hands. Thanks again and have a good one.
— Brian M., Edison, NJ

I've had two very smooth trades with your company and I am very pleased.
— Gary K., Princeton, NJ

Thanks Buddy and company. Always great trading comics with you.
— Wade E., Yakima, WA

Having fun. In this newest batch, almost all comics are prior to 1981. Had to go back and read your online selling procedures. Next time I will not follow my spouses directions blindly.
— John B., Crestline, OH

Thank you so much for taking the time to further assist me with info on how your online buying stems operates. I'm getting pretty excited about this. I'm going to buy a long box today and see how much fills up one of those, and might use smaller ones after that. Thanks again!
— John K., Yuma, AZ

Thanks guys! I trust your grading and appreciate your quick and professional communications. :)
— Joel H., Springfield, IL

I am thrilled with the way you guys have handled my trade-ins. Always a pleasure.
— Brandon B., Sophia, NC

Thanks! Your online selling and trading option is great!
— Sarah L., Davis, CA

This submittal for trade is this time for a batch of my own comics. I love that I can use the excess of my old collections to fill in my new collections!
— David H., Alexandria, VA

Here's another batch of comics from a friend of mine who heard I was going to be sending some of my books in and wanted to piggyback on my shipment. She liked how well she was treated the last time I submitted some books for her. Even though many of her books were re-graded, she was still quite pleased with the overall process.
— David H., Alexandria, VA

Buddy, Thanks for making the sale of my comic books a "PAINLESS" process. Your company makes it so easy to get the comics to you, have the comics graded fairly, and have a fair price given for the books submitted. It is a scary process the first time anyone sends their collection to a company for grading and pricing. You guys make it PAINLESS. It is a pleasure doing business with you and Lone Star Comics. I look forward to doing ALL my future business with Lone Star.
— Patrick D., Leesburg, GA

Great, very easy to use web site and ordering/trading system. Looking forward to buying and selling more comics with you soon. Thanks!
— David B., West Hartford, CT

Thanks again for your generous offers on our comics. This last check basically paid for our hotel room for our upcoming vacation...and with gas prices as they are now...let's just say, had I had to have gone through the eBay process, I wouldn't have nearly been taken care of so quickly, efficiently and generously as we were with you folks at Lone Star Comics. I have my eyes on yet another collection of Batman Annuals. When I get back, I may buy them, knowing in advance what you'll pay me. You're online price system has usurped Overstreet as the "bible" of the industry--if you pay $20 for a book, I know that's what it's worth at wholesale! That's a comforting feeling to have. Thanks for helping us out on our trip...you helped make it possible. I thank you also for being a new friend.
— Gary M., Huntington, WV

Thanks again, Buddy and crew!
— Phil H., Carona, CA

Thanks again! I'm cleaning out and organizing and you guys are wanting what I got. Imagine my pleasure and surprise!
— Greg A., Indian Harbour Beach, FL

Word has gotten around! A co-worker of the flea market gentleman I told you about called today and asked if I were interested in buying his comics. I told him I'd be glad to check out what he has; I'll let you know if he's got anything worthwhile. Take care, and as always, much thanks. The feeling of having someone reputable to sell to at any time is, well, quite nice.
— Gary M., Huntington, WV

Thanks a lot! Your online buying and trading system is really GREAT!
— Margaret T., Anacortes, WA

Buddy, Another excellent offer. Thank you and I accept.
— Joe L., Allen, TX

Dear Mr. Saunders, I am sending you more comics today. I wanted you to know before I sent them out. Look forward to doing business with you again.
— Margaret D., North Quincy, MA

Your trade offer for my comic looks good. Thanks again for your help.
— Adam F., Newhall, CA

Buddy, Thanks to you, I was able to nab this collection. Your onine system made it possible for me to know in advance what you pay for specific issues. Once again, you've proven your value to average Joes like me. I think you'll be happy with the comics I'm sending--I know I was. I sent them out today. Thanks again!
— Gary M., Huntington, WV