Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

Buddy, Thanks for all the great trade-ins and purchases over this past year. Please give my wishes for a Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to all those at Lone Star Comics and especially to yourself and your family.
— David H., Alexandria, VA

I'm also sending additional pre-1980 books that were not on your current want list. Thanks for this great service.
— Phillip Y., Temple, GA

I accept your offer for my comics. Thank you for your service and God bless your holidays and Christmas!
— Michelle L., Florence, KY

Buddy, Thank you for the swift reply. I appreciate it and I accept your offer. Thank you.
— Dennis R., Arlington, TX

Hi Buddy! I accept your offer. Thank you.
— Rick D., Rochester, MN

Buddy, Your offer is fair and I accept it. Thank you for the prompt handling. This is my second transaction with you and I am very satisfied. I have no more comics, but I have and will continue to recommend you when speaking to people looking to buy or sell comics.
— Fred B., Wake Forest, NC

Thanks Buddy, Happy Holidays! Oh, and I have a lot of Spiderman and X-men coming to you next.
— Ray R., Pasadena, MD

Your offer for my comics is accepted. Thank you.
— Tim F., Patterson, NY

Buddy, I accept your offer of $641.80 plus $54.00 shipping reimbursement.
— Bruce M., Manassas, VA

Dear Mr. Saunders, Thank you for sending me your offer on my comics. I accept and I hope this will turn out to be the first of many trades. They were given an average grade of 4.7, which I think is very fair.
— Matthew H., Columbus, OH

Hi Buddy, I have more to offer for trade. I just wanted to let you know I've been very impressed with your pricing and the service that I've been receiving since I started dealing with your site. Thanks for everything!
— Mike C., East Haven, CT

As always, I appreciate the great customer service you provide. Thanks again!
— Kelly B., Flower Mound, TX

Yes, I accept your offer of $1,012.60 for my comic books. Thank You.
— Robert L., Las Vegas, NV

Thank You! You always make me smile!
— Terri S., Pikesville, MD

Hi Buddy! Yes, consider them sold. Thanks again, for the fair offer.
— Ray E., Ottawa Ontario, Canada

Hi Mr. Saunders! I accept your offer. Thanks again for your kindness. I hope you, your family, and your employees all have a safe and happy Thanksgiving!
— Terri S., Pikesville, MD

Per conversation with C.J., I am enclosing four additional comics for an offer. Thanks again for the outstanding service.
— Kevin W., Pierce City, MO

I was packing up my other trades and had some room in the box, so I checked to see if I had anything else on you want list that you were interested in and I did. So, here they are and the box is a little fuller now!
— David H., Alexandria, VA

Thanks Buddy! Always great dealing with you.
— Peter N., Hawthorne, CA

Hi Buddy, I accept the offer....many thanks. Stand by, there's more books coming! Take care.
— Tony L., Chicago, IL

Hi Buddy, Yeah, I'm still collecting and still sorting through things. It always seems to be a few pieces at a time. Your offer for my three items is fine. I appreciate it.
— Robert C., St. Agustine, FL

Awesome trading system! Thank you!
— Nathaniel H., Crosby, TX

This is my second trade with you guys. I am VERY pleased with the first! Quick turnaround and shipment of new orders. Thanks a lot!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Many thanks for the offer for my comics. I accept.
— Tony L., Chicago, IL

Buddy, The offer sounds great. Please credit my MCS account. The credit will sure help fill some holes in my collection. Thank you again.
— Matt G., Glen Allen, VA

I love that I can trade in the excesses of my comic collection for trade credit that I can then use to get other comics as well as superhero related items such as toys and action figures.
— David H., Alexandria, VA

Buddy, Thank you for the follow-up. I accept your offer.
— Brian M., Midland, MI

Thanks guys! I think you offer a great buying and trading service.
— Jim A., Bellevue, WA

Hi Buddy, Your offer for my comics is fine. Many thanks!
— Faina D., San Francisco, CA

Yes, your offer for my comics is acceptable. I will send you the rest of my comics--three boxes--soon.
— Robert L., Las Vegas, NV

Love doing business with you! Keep up the great work!
— Matthew S., Decatur, TX

Thanks for another very fair and satisfactory transaction (20% credit/80%cash). I approve all details of this trade/sale.
— Wes H., Phoenixville, PA

Your trade offer for my T-transaction looks great! Thanks!
— Dan S., Asheville, NC

Hello Buddy, Yes, I will take online trade credit. I will also be happy to send yet another package next week. You have been gracious with trade credit. Thanks! I am happy I have been able to send you salable merchandise which I no longer require.
— Stan W., Buffalo, NY

I didn't attempt to grade my comics, but would say the vast majority fall in the G to VG range in accordance with your grading standards. Thought I'd leave the grading up to your experts. I have had good experiences with your company so I felt I could trust your judgment. I tried a local shop but his offer seemed a bit on the low side. I'm just trying to clear out copies I don't need and trade them for credit towards other issues I'd like to add to my collection. Hope to hear back soon. Thanks for your time.
— Mike K., Paducah, KY

Yes, I accept your offer and yes, I would like $27.00 of your cash offer converted to online credit (I just set up an account with your site).
— Doug C., Madison, WI

Hi Buddy, That offer sounds fine. Thanks for all the help! Much appreciated!
— Gary L., Lauderdale Lakes, FL

Thanks once again for being there. Being able to trade with you to fill the holes in my own sets is a real treat and with oil hitting $90+ a barrel, who wants to drive around from shop to shop looking when you and the mailman are filling the void.
— Jordan N., San Carlos, CA

Thanks Buddy, Your offer sounds good to me. Thanks so much for taking the time to grade my comics and make an offer.
— Susan B., Mabank, TX

Yes, I accept your offer for my fourth lot of comics.
— Dan B., Littleton, CO

The offer is great. I'll take the 100% credit. You guys are simply the best. I have packaged up another box of 130 more comics.
— Matt G., Glenn Allen, VA

Buddy, I'm definitely going to have to take the trade value this time around. Please credit my account.
— Joshua R., Aurora, CO

The MyComicShop trade and sell process is very efficient, convenient and streamlined. Thanks for a great online resource.
— Charlie T., Brookline, MA

I am interesting in selling or possibly trade this new batch. Please let me know what the different totals are for both trade and cash once you finish grading my comics. I really appreciated my first selling experience with you guys and look forward to a continued great selling/trading relationship.
— Joshua R., Aurora, CO

Dear Buddy, Thanks for buying my comics after our talk on the phone. It's a pleasure doing business with you and you will be the first one I talk to when I have more.
— Barbara M., Bayside, NY

Do you know if my trade will be checked in before Wednesday? I was hoping to use the password word sale to buy some things off of your website. Just have to say I love the new website. It is awesome and extremely easier to use.
— Matthew S., Decatur, TX

Hello Buddy, I accept your offer. Nice doing business with you again.
— John T., Edinburgh, IN

Hello Buddy, Your offer for my comics sounds good. I accept.
— Matthew D., Bayonne, NJ

I mailed in a box of comics to you yesterday that I am wishing to sell. I have heard many good things from other customers of yours, so I would like to thank you in advance for your fair and honest practices.
— Karen K., ,

I accept the offer. Appreciate your business and thank you.
— Daniel S., Buffalo, NY