$0.00 0 items

Auction in progress, bid now! Prime Auction ends Monday April 13 to Friday April 17!

Comic books September 1958, graded by CGC

  • Item #63961428
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    Katy Keene (1949-1961 Archie) #42 CGC 8.5
    Published Sep 1958 by Archie Publications.
    Add to cart CGC 8.5 Add to cart
    $350.00
    • Paper: Off white
    • Label #1260221008
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($10.50) will be charged at checkout.
    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    5 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #63961437
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    Katy Keene (1949-1961 Archie) #42 CGC 4.0
    Published Sep 1958 by Archie Publications.
    Add to cart CGC 4.0 Add to cart
    $150.00
    • Paper: Off white
    • Label #4467461022
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($4.50) will be charged at checkout.
    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    5 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #64219830
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    Romance Stories of True Love (1957 Harvey) #51 CGC 9.2
    Published Sep 1958 by Harvey.
    Add to cart CGC 9.2 Add to cart
    $199.95
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Cream to off white
    • Label #4604503009
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($6.00) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    Stories and art by George Tuska, Vince Colletta and Bob Powell. Tear-soaked tales of love, loss and reunion from Harvey. Jo and Ellen discover they have both fallen for handsome artist Jeff. While temporarily blinded, Jeanne falls for a mystery man, in a story with art possibly by legendary good-girl artist Matt Baker. Sandy likes to flirt with the boys, but her games backfire on her, in a story with good-girl art by Bob Powell. Stand-In Heart; I'll Always Love You; Am I Duty Bound to Marry?; His Face Before Me; My Beloved Doctor; My First Sweetheart!; I Don't Want to Be The Most Popular Girl in School! 36 pages, full color. Cover price $0.10.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    2 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #64585865
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    Superboy (1949-1979 1st Series DC) #67 CGC 2.5
    Tags: Superman
    Published Sep 1958 by DC.

    Superboy (1949-1979 1st Series DC) 67 CGC 2.5

    Paper: Cream to off white

    Label #4354692005

    Starts Apr 27

    Cover pencils by Curt Swan, inks by Stan Kaye. The Three Secret Identities of Superboy, script by Otto Binder, art by Al Plastino; Superboy appears as a guest on the TV Show "Unmask the Truth"; Based on the real TV show "To Tell The Truth". Know Your Pet! public service announcement, script by Jack Schiff, art by Lou Cameron. Varsity Vic humor page by Henry Boltinoff. The Execution of Krypto, script by Otto Binder, art by George Papp; Krypto is wanted for the murder of Clark Kent, and Superboy can't save him without revealing his identity. The Man Who Destroyed Krypton, script by Bill Finger, art by George Papp; Klax-Ar claims to be the man who destroyed Krypton. 36 Pages, Full Color. Cover price $0.10.

  • Item #63926596
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    Walt Disney's Comics and Stories (1940 Dell/Gold Key/Gladstone) #216 CGC 9.6
    Tags: Disney Ducks & Mice
    Published Sep 1958 by Dell/Gold Key.
    Add to cart CGC 9.6 Add to cart
    $599.00
    • Paper: Off white
    • Label #1267274010
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($17.97) will be charged at checkout.
      Other items consigned by Poka

    Cover by Carl Barks. Stories and art by Carl Barks, Tony Strobl, Carl Fallberg, Jack Bradbury, Paul Murry, Al Hubbard, Bob Karp, and Al Taliaferro. Sometimes listed as Vol. 18 #12. The long-running vehicle for Disney character comics featured art by Carl Barks, the legendary Good Duck Artist. Mickey and Goofy are shanghai'd into Pete's scheme to swindle a South Seas island out of a fortune in pearls. In a story by Barks, Donald enters a jumping-frog contest. Donald's parade perch is in the wrong spot. Donald Duck; Scamp; Chip 'n' Dale; The Pearl Mystery; Mickey Mouse: The Idol of Moaning Island. 32 pages, Full Color. Cover price $0.10.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    6 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.