Auction in progress, bid now! Weekly Auction ends Monday March 11!

Customer Feedback

You can reach us at

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

First Page Previous Page Current Page: 1 of 64 Next Page Last Page

I've had a consignment account with you folks for a while. I just purchased this collection and and decided to flip it to you guys. I'm one of the Co-Owners of Gold Key Comics with Mike D.. Love you guys!
— Adam B., Phoenix, AZ

Buddy, Conan and Ben, You will find attached a list of the comics I am shipping to you. A agreed, we are splitting the locker collection 50/50. The amount due to me for your half is $1620. I can never say enough about the Saunders family and Lone Star Comics. My operations have grown since becoming a buying partner with you several years ago. Nothing is more fun than working with your crew, everything from W-transactions, buying collections, and consigning with you. I have a lead on a good-sized collection close to me. My hunt for great comic collections never ends, as you saw the finds today in my earlier e-mail.
— Phil H., Corona, CA

Hello Buddy, I'm very thankful that you are doing so well after your stroke. A fighter! I also want to thank you personally for your involvement in the negotiations with Steve to sell my comic collection that I started 55 years ago. If I am going to sell my collection to anyone, I'm glad it was you. My beloved comics will find good homes with people who will really enjoy them appreciate them just as I have. Take care and all the best
— Tim F., Houston, TX

I've bought comics from you before and sold some to you, too. I really enjoy your website, your prices and the way it's laid out (very user friendly). I'm a 73-year-old who, when I look at the comics I'm interested in, I get such a warm and nostalgic feeling of back when I was a kid and was so excited whenever the newest comic books came out. Memories of buying them at my local drugstore, at 12-15 cents—pure joy! Nothing like reading those old comic books and that feeling and memories of those youthful days come rushing back like an old friend.
— Brenda P., Charleston, PA

This my first time selling with you. A friend, Adam P., said you were awesome to work with. It was fun scanning and grading my books so now I am looking forward to doing the rest of my collection and building up more consignment eligible books for a shipment as well.
— Drew E., New Straitsville, OH

I was given my great-grandfather's large collection of Tip Top Weekly's that he collected from a young age. For being over 100 years old, these books are in incredible condition and I look forward to selling them to to you so that they go to others who will enjoy them!
— Rebecca B., Philadelphia, PA

Hello, I've purchased many books from MyComicShop via eBay, and noticed there are auctions on your own site, and the eBay listings are less expensive when buying direct from you. I'm in the process of pruning my collection, and thought this is a good place to sell my books, and use that money towards more select books.
— Chris S., Lake Villa, IL

I sold about a third of my collection to Lone Star Comics about 10 years ago and even had the pleasure of meeting Buddy when I was touring Texas. I'm now 70 and starting to downsize, so I would like to sell more of my collection. Also, forgive me, but I am awful at grading, but I always give it my best shot. I've also got a lot of Man From Uncle Magazines and Perry Rhodan paperbacks if you are interested in them in the future.
— Sylvester M., Poinciana, FL

Hello, I still have two boxes of American comics and a box of manga to go through. I also have a copy of Iron Fist 14 at CGC, though I won't see it till August, probably. I was paid almost $20,000 last year, and I expect to make over $2,000 this year selling to your want list. I never could have done it without your site. Thanks,
— Jondahl D., Lubbock, TX

Buddy, first let me first say that the prices you pay for books for sale is unmatched. By far, the prices are the best on the Net. I've been trading, buying, and selling to you for AT LEAST 20-25 years, and I'll never go anywhere else. I stand by my words. Keep up your great work... you're the best at all you do.
— Gary M., Huntington, WV

The following testimonial is one you’ll want to read, especially if you are thinking of selling or trading comics to us via our online want list, a system used by literally thousands of sellers every year.

I made my first sale to you in 2012, and since it went well, I sporadically worked up orders for the next couple of years. During this time, I kept running into chances to buy lots of comics containing stuff I wanted, often at dirt-cheap prices. There were plenty of comics I didn't want in those lots so I just started adding them to your database.

As my pile of unwanted comics grew, I became more familiar with your system and my sales to you increased.

In 2015, I decided to start keeping copies of every order and record every sale. That year, I thought I had a great year by making $624.31 in trade credit. But in 2016 the amount shot up to $1,800.18, and then $2,763.98 in 2017.

By this point, I was raiding store and convention dollar boxes armed with your printable want list, and looking for uninformed sales anywhere I bought comics. Each year my sales to you have risen (even during Covid 2020) as I've gotten more savvy buying comics to resell to you.

At the start of this year, I have amassed (and spent) $20,656.10 in trade credit with you since 2015.

I'm just a guy who collects comics. I don't buy to sell anywhere else. I don't really even spend much time with my extra comics. It started off as a way to offload stuff I didn't want for some extra money, but it turned out that I have a knack for it.

I rarely have to spend any of my own money when I order, and the 5,000 or so comics I pull from have already been paid for many times over.

Your system works, and I recommend it whenever I can, especially to people who have no clue about comics. Most of them have jackpots in their eyes, though, and disregard my advice. I think my totals show that your system works and I thought that you might get a kick knowing a simple collector had used it to this extent.

— P. T., Pelham, Al

Thank you for the very professional cooperation and the very friendly communication regarding your purchase of my Marvel comic sets! Likewise, thank you very much for your flash-like payment for my most recent title lot, Amazing Spider-Man! Less than 24 hours for an oversea transfer! Sometimes a transfer within Germany takes two to three days. Wow! Such lightning-fast payment is a great compliment to me! Again, thank you very much! Garret F., Dresden, Germany
— Gerrit F., Dresden, Germany

In my profession of buying odd lots of merchandise for over 40 years, I have experienced many different situations, companies, and people, some great, some not so good. In your case, I find your company a delight to do business with. Everyone I spoke with was knowledgeable, organized, friendly and concerned. A real professional organization. I look forward to doing more business with you.
— Dick C., Talmadge, OH

Every step in our deal was very professional with the communication always easy and very friendly! I think, as a second step I will offer to you my German set of Fantastic Four # 1-124. It will take a few weeks, but one thing is absolutely sure: when I will offer it, there is only one shop I will consider - and the name of the shop is: Lone Star Comics. Please let Buddy know I had this feeling when seeing your ad at the back of the Price Guide: I then knew I must write to Buddy and his crew! And my inner voice was right: it was a very, very friendly and professional experience! Thank you very much, and please tell Buddy I have great respect for his and your way of doing business!
— Garret F., Dresden, Germany

I have done a lot of business with your store and I think you are an amazing company, both buying and selling. Thank you so much and I hope you stay in business another hundred years because your store is the very best and you are the only one I trust to do business with.
— Eric W., Washington, NY

Thanks for having such a fair and great trading option. By trading with MyComicShop. I know I'm getting the best deal every time.
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

I've had my collection 20 years. I discovered your site a few months ago and I'm thankful for how easy you've made selling my comics.
— Mark F., Richmond Hill, Ontario, Canada

This is my third time using your online selling option. You are very fair and I still have three more full boxes of comics. Thanks for being honest.
— Shawn D., Gambrills, MD

Wow, that's it? You look at my comics today, make an offer which I accept, and now you will issue a check? I've lived in five countries outside of the US in the past fifteen years and I'm not used to things going smoothly! Thanks.
— Mark H., Arlington, TX

Ben, thank you so much for the offer for my comics, which I accepted. Everyone I have dealt with at Mycomicshop from beginning to end has been straightforward and has answered all my questions. The entire transaction has been seamless and I totally feel that you offered a fair price. I want to thank you for your personal interest and for staying in touch with me.
— Michael S., White Creek, TN

I just saw this morning that our CBCS slabbed Journey Into Mystery #83 sold for $24,700. I want to express my gratitude for your advise, direction and body of knowledge which made the sale of this comic and others possible. My wife and I hold your entire organization in very high regard. We look forward to continuing our working relationship as we sell the remainder of the collection.
— Ralph B., Easton, PA

Hello, Buddy and friends. This is the third time I've traded comic books with your company, and it is just as fun as ever! I've ordered around 100 times from MyComicShop over the years, and I can say MCS is absolutely the number-one, top-notch online site for all things comic book, whether you are buying recent releases or comics published 50 years ago. Thanks again!
— David B., Delphos, OH

Hi Ben, Just wanted you to know you made selling my comics a great experience. Your company, Lone Star Comics, paid me top price. I had approached a number of other big-name comic dealers. Only one came close to you and several tried to low-ball me. In my opinion, any collector who doesn’t offer his comics to Lone Star is out of his mind.

What’s more, I had learned that Lone Star’s grading standards were among the most stringent out there. But even so, you made the process of valuing my comics easy. You made an accurate judgment based on only a strategic sample of my covers. That you were able to do so to both buyer’s and seller’s satisfaction evidenced a great deal of experience and a high degree of professionalism.

You, personally, were very patient with me, answering all my questions promptly and giving me confidence in you and your company. This was my first time selling comics online and, as you appreciated, I had some misgivings about packing up the bulk of my collection and sending it off to who-knows-where. Lone Star’s quick and hassle-free payment came as quite a relief.

To sum up, you and Lone Star gets my highest recommendation. I’d deal with you again in a minute.

— Joe R., Medford, MA

Hi Buddy. Just want to share with you that your staff is part of the reason I continue doing business with Lonestar Comics. Whether it be Este, Sean, or Brian - they always find an answer to any questions I have. Thank you again.
— Rudy R., Miami, FL

Love how easy you make it to sell comics to you!
— Brad B., Dublin, OH

I love how easy the mycomicshop site is to use! Especially given the amount of comics I own. The process of entering them in by data cart and storing them was quite easy! Thank you for making this a fun and enjoyable process! I was excited to see what my comics were actually worth!
— Miles T., White, GA

I have really enjoyed looking through your site. It has made selling my comics, what could have been really tedious work, fun. Thank you for making your site so easy to navigate! I have had these comics in storage for over a decade and looking through them has brought back a lot of memories.
— Linda H., State College, PA

I love your site. I’ve been buying with you for years and will continue to do so. This is my first time selling comics. I trust mycomicshop, and I feel secure that you’ll give me the right price, Thank you!
— Derrick W., Orange, NJ

You guys have been really awesome to me as a customer. Just about everything I've looked for I've found at Mycomicshop, but this is the first I've tried to sell or trade any of my comics. I'm old school when it comes to shopping. I like going to a store and flipping thru the comic stock. So I've placed a trust value in purchasing online thru you. Even when I look on eBay, I only feel comfortable when I find comics with your stores digital watermark.
— Andy S., Saint Louis, MO

Wow! What a great experience working with the team at Lone Star Comics! They were very patient with all of my questions and helping me to find the best option to sell my comic book collection. Thanks to everyone for all of their help!
— Janet G., Pittsburgh, PA

This is my first time dealing with you folks, and I am very impressed. You have a slick operation, well done!
— Dan W., Gatesville, TX

Wanted to drop a quick note to thank you for running such a streamlined and honest auction. This is the second time I've taken advantage of that service, but once again, from grading to delivery and everything in between, it couldn't have be better! And your shipping department did a stellar packing job, as usual! Thanks again for all you do.
— Steve B., Pueblo West, CO

I am a comic collector of 30 years. I have been dealing with your company for many of those years, mostly buying great comics, but I have also done some selling to you. I have really enjoyed the experiences.
— Jeremy J., Santa Paula, CA

My good friend's stepdad hired me to sell his collection of nearly 5,000 Marvel comics from 1967-1991. It's a huge task that had me feeling overwhelmed, that is until I spoke with Trey on the phone. I love the business model you guys have going and I look forward to making this happen with you!
— Alexander W., San Carlos, CA

I love how easy (and fun!) you make it to sell my comics!
— Keith E., Glen Ellyn, IL

Your consignment rates beat everyone. 8% for $300 and up is why I consign with you.
— Shaheed A., Woodhaven, NY

I brought my collection in to you last year. You offered to buy the whole collection, but I decided to sell some myself on eBay. It is way too much trouble, so I have decided to sell them to you as they show up on your want list.
— Mike S., Nacona, TX

Although this is my first effort selling comics to, I've been a frequent customer of your wonderful site for the past 14 months. I order comics from MyComicShop at least once a week and have been consistently happy with the experience. I presently own 2,100+ comics, trades, and omnibuses and am always looking to expand my collection.
— Stephen A., Katy, TX

Just wanted to thank you again for a terrific selling experience. After holding on to my collection for 50 years, it wasn't easy to part with it. But I was in good hands with My Comic Shop and Buddy. I wouldn't want to sell my comics anywhere else. I was treated professionally from start to finish and received a very fair payment in record time. Whether selling or buying comics, it is clear that My Comic Shop is a first class act and one you can feel confident in following.
— John U., Rockford, IL

Hi Buddy, I truly appreciate your making this transaction so very painless (and seamless)! You and your buying partner Phil made it so easy. Near the end, Phil and I were chatting like old buddies although we had just met. We talked mostly about comics. It was a pleasure to meet him. Phil is a real nice guy and a true professional. I'll love to take you up on your invitation (especially the tour of Lone Star Comics if I am ever in Dallas), and we'd like to extend a reciprocal invitation if you are ever in the beautiful south Orange County--as one comic fan to another. Thanks again for making this transaction so easy. In the meantime, I'll continue reading your (and Odinson's) extremely informative weekly blogs/emails. Here's to many more happy years of reading comics! Thanks again.
— Rajiv A., Laguna Hills, CA

Thank you Buddy! You gave us a really fair deal for my 450+ 1940-50s comic collection. I am grateful for opportunity of having to work with you. I've enjoyed learning truly amazing things. I have come to respect and appreciate the history of my comics, along with every aspect of their preservation. I'm glad to have this new found appreciation for them. I also have to thank you, kind sir, for having integrity when it comes to this business. Before talking to you, I was taken aback by the unpleasant experience I had with another would be buyer. Your mild manner, calm, and friendly character was reassuring. And I appreciate your encouraging me to seek other offers to compare to your offer. But in the end, I was blessed with you offer, the top offer by far. I'm glad that our paths crossed, and I really, truly pray for your business to continue thriving for years to come. Mahalo nui loa (deepest Thank You).
— Kristal A., Kaneohe, HI

Buddy, I want to thank you so much for the great experience I had in my transaction with you and your company. I was honored with the personal attention you gave me in all the phone calls leading up to the sale. I was really sorry that you had to be out of town on the day I was there, but everyone at your place made us feel so welcome. I could say "went out of their way" to make us feel welcome, but I'm pretty sure they treat everyone like that all the time. A great group of folks you have assembled. Your wife is such a treasure. She came to the break room to personally greet us, buy us a drink, and then took time from her busy schedule to give us a tour. I was a little wound up from the trip down and the whole experience of selling my stuff, so spending time with her was a perfect way to help me unwind. Please thank her for me for the personal attention she gave to my wife and myself. I was disappointed that you were in Florida the day I arrived, but you certainly left me in extremely capable hands. Este was great. Your crew got those 58 boxes out of that hotbox trailer. I was so impressed with Este. She has the knowledge and skill to quickly evaluate the varied collection that I brought to you. I'm sure she handles every transaction that way, but she made me feel special, and I want to say "Thank You" to her. Also, I want to make mention of your website. When I made the decision to sell my collection, I looked at several sites on the internet. Your site is the absolute best by far. No one else was even close. In talking to your wife, she told us that your son was responsible for your site. I'm sure you're very proud of him, and you have every right. In closing, thank you for everything. Selling a collection that I started as a young boy over 50 years ago was a little tough. So many memories wrapped up in those items. But you and your folks made the process easier than I would have imagined, and I know that my stuff is in very capable hands.
— Tom B., Effingham, IL

All of you have been fantastic! Thank you so much for everything that you do at I've been so in the dark about selling all of these comics until someone told me about you. I'm so thankful!
— Lindsey L., Bushnell, FL

Hello to whoever reads this. This comic collection is mostly from my deceased father-in-law from his decades of collecting. I've entered so many comics into your system over the last few days that my head is spinning. Every phone call I've made with questions for your staff have been answered by such kind people. Thank you so much for everything that you are doing with this company. I really feel confident selling to you. Nobody ever made me feel like my questions were stupid and everyone walked me through everything step-by-step. Thank you all and have an amazing day!
— Lindsey L., Bushnell, FL

I just wanted to write to say thank you to Buddy and the entire Lone Star Comics team for our recent transaction. My father had recently passed away, leaving my brother and me with a large comic collection amassed over 50 years (almost 100 long boxes). The situation left us in a bit of a bind since both of us lived states away. We were needing to clear his house quickly, and neither of us had the time or emotional energy to sell everything (individually or by box), nor did either of us have the physical space to hold onto it. We thought we would end up having to throw a lot of it away, which was a terribly depressing thought. But a call to Buddy turned things around for us. Buddy was very gracious and beyond helpful, offering to buy not only the whole collection of comics, but also the boxes and boxes of trade paperbacks and hardcover collections we had been left with. In the end, Buddy gave us a very fair price for the whole collection (more than we initially expected) and his competent crew flew out to the house in Tennessee and carted everything off in just under two hours. Because of this company's professionalism and expertise, we were able to have some peace of mind about a once-stressful situation, which also allowed us to devote time to wrap up other matters of our father's estate. Having such a great and painless experience with you and your team during this trying time made all the difference, so thank you Buddy!
— Kurt W., Chattanooga, TN

I just wanted to say that I am pretty new to comics. I recently purchased three issues of a title at my local comic store, but they didn't have the rest. They recommended your website so I gave you a try. Not only did I find what I was looking for, but I received an email every time something progressed with my order. The estimated time was 3-10 business days for delivery. My comics were here in two. Thank you for making a new comic reader feel important in the scheme of the universe and, in this simple standard procedure of ordering from you, keeping a new comic reader more enthused to read than ever. Good on ya.
— Matt N., Facebook, Comment

Thanks for a wonderful experience with my comic book sales to you. Not very often you call a business and they connect you to the owner/CEO without hesitation! It was fun talking to you and learning a bit about your love of comics. Thanks for your prompt responses and kindness.
— Bill H., Duluth, GA

Buddy, We are doing well with the Apple Valley Collection. You must have had one heck of a Christmas sale period. I am getting more stuff shipped out to you. The seller had a lot of the treasury editions in great shape. Sending those out to you this morning. After doing a hard count, we bought 30,000 comics in our joint buy. That does not include all the Doctor Who stuff. My daughter is home from her world trip and is helping me pull together some W-transactions as well side. My inventory is growing as I keep picking up small transactions on top of the buying opportunities you send me. A good problem for us both. Hope you saw Rogue One; it was fun to say the least. (Phil is a Mycomicshop Buying Partner)
— Phil H., Corona, CA

Here's a little something I'd like to share with the Lone Star Comics universe. As you know, I'm a true believer when it comes to your online buy/sell/trade system. Over the years I have sold or traded tens of thousands of comics and books to you via that system. Anyway, I currently have approximately 5,000 comics entered into my pool of comics in your system. Here's the cool part. Each morning when I wake up, I have approximately $50 of comics that you are currently ready to take off my hands. These are not huge dollar books individually (I'm mostly talking about dollar books here), but do the math. If I print out a pick list every morning before going to work, I'm looking at an average of approximately $300 a week of extra cash! Not bad for what amounts to a passive investment. If I got my pool up to 10,000 books I could probably double that amount! I urge everybody reading this to take advantage of this EZ Money opportunity. It's a perfect partnership. I input books in my pool at my leisure knowing that your system will fill up my cart every night while I'm asleep. So what are you waiting for? Start entering those books now!
— Howard M., Cranford, NJ

I still have over 1,300 comics to go thru and catalogue on your AWESOME website! I was so excited when I found your site and saw how easy you make it for me to sell my comics to you. Thank you!
— Donna K., Gilbertsville, PA

First Page Previous Page Current Page: 1 of 64 Next Page Last Page