Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

The offer is fine. I accept your offer for my comics.
— Jacob P., Milford, MA

Thanks. Sent lots of comics this time. Hope I can start doing these trades more then once a month, though.
— James R., Tahlequah, OK

Buddy, The higher web credit amount (as opposed to your original cash offer) would be preferable for me since a lot of my comics buying is done through your web site. Accordingly, I give my "go-ahead" for the trade-in amount.
— Jeff K., Bolivar, MO

Your offer of $1,823.60 is accepted. Thank you.
— Jerry M., San Francisco, CA

Buddy, Thank you for going that extra mile to expedite my credit. I REALLY appreciate it. I've already applied it to the Astonish issues I've been looking for and have even submitted another trade offer this evening. I love your system; it allows me to move expendable books from my collection to fill holes off my want list. Very nice! Thank you again.
— Dave H., Palmyra, PA

Just wanted to give you a heads up that I shipped out a box to you today full of pre-70's stuff to be traded. You guys are THE greatest! I hope to visit your stores one day in the future. Many thanks and kudos!
— Danny G., Salt Lake City, UT

I accept the offer of $451.40.
— Jerry P., Pennington Gap, VA

Thanks, Buddy. I accept your offer I look forward to receiving the cheque. Further to our previous emails, I will soon be sending the Amazing Spiderman #129 CGC 7.0 as per your offer price and look forward to hearing from you again.
— Adrian A., Ilkeston Derbys, United Kingdom

Buddy, Just to keep you up to date. I received confirmation, grading and quote for our first transaction with you. I have held off on sending our second shipment until we receive this info on the first, but we are 100% satisfied with the offer and the payment that has been sent so we are ready to package and send out our 2nd trade/sale, #T070761088. Thanks again for all of your help in making this first transaction so quick and easy.
— Sue S., Lakewood, OH

Hi, Sorry for the delay in reply. Took a road trip...spent some of the comic book cash from your previous offers. Your offer for my most recent batch of comics is fine. It's been a pleasure. You don't know anyone who buys Barbie (and Ken and Allen and Skipper and Midge and Ricky...) dolls, do you? That my next project. Need to find a home for these dolls (same era--1960s), their storage boxes, clothes, etc. If you do know of anyone, please let me know. Thanks again.
— Frances S., Easton, MD

Hi Buddy, Thanks for getting back to me so quickly. Yes, I do accept your offer for my comics.
— Larry S., Abiline, KS

Buddy, I accept the offer. Thanks!
— Mark M., Campbell, NY

Buddy, I accept your offer of $109.20 for the comics that I sent you. Thank you and have a great day.
— Philip P., Riverside, CA

Buddy, I accept your offer for my comics. Thanks!
— Kyle O., Murfreesboro, TN

I accept your offer. Thanks.
— John D., Vidor, TX

While downsizing to a smaller home, I found a box of comics in the garage along with a box of vinyl record albums. I thought to myself, "I wonder if anyone would want these comics." I went on the internet and found Buddy Sanders and Lone Star Comics. I read through the website and it gave me a comfortable feeling about them. I sent them by comics and then was pleasantly surprised when I got an email with an attractive offer. It was just so easy. Thanks, Buddy for making this process so easy. Now I have some extra funds to use on the new house we are moving into. Wishing you an outstanding and productive day!
— Philip P., Riverside, CA

Buddy, Thanks for explaining how easy it is to use a Gift Card in your stores. This time around, I was more than happy to go to the Arlington office and bring in my trade comics personally. I was a little curious to see how the operation worked, having worked for a larger comic store myself when I was younger. I had a very pleasant experience yesterday and was glad I made the trip.
— Nick T., Irving, TX

Excellent. Yes, I accept your offer. Your process is very easy to use and your offer is very fair. I have a much larger comic book collection that I will be talking to you about in the near future. Thank you again.
— Robert S., Conroe, TX

Thank you Buddy, I appreciated the note and accept the offer. I'd just like my comics to go somewhere where they will be appreciated and possibly even searched for. Should I run across any more in my 'cleaning,' I will most certainly send them to your organization. Thanks for your fair and thorough explanation, and for the service that you offer. I'll look forward to receiving the check in the mail.
— Donalee K., Copalis Beach, WA

Buddy, I accept your offer of $381.60 in online trade credit. Thanks!
— Michael W., Utica, MS

Buddy, Thanks for the quick processing. This is the first time I've sold anything to Lone Star Comics. I think you've got a great system.
— Scott S., Allen, TX

Hi, I wanted to let you know how pleased I was with the trade we recently worked out. I have another lot ready to trade.
— Mike C., East Haven, CT

Thank you for the fair offer!
— Ray E., Ottawa Ontario, Canada

Buddy, As always, you are prompt, professional, and offer the best price out there. I accept your newest offer and thank you.
— Robert C., Sammamish, WA

Buddy, I gladly accept your cash offer. However, I was wondering if I could pick some issues out of your on-line superstore equal to the cash offer value of $96.55. I never planned on buying more old comics, but your online store has me hooked! If it's not possible, no big deal--I gladly accept the cash. (Buddy replied, telling Tony that the trade value for his lot would be more--$120.70) Tony replied: Thanks, Buddy. Now to get started on my online shopping at MCS! Thanks again for all your help.
— Tony L., Chicago, IL

Buddy, Your offer is fine. It has been a pleasure dealing with you. I have sent another box of comics. It may be my last shipment because, we are down to about 25 comics. Some are Dell and Gold Key related to TV shows of the era; we may want to hang on to them "for the memories." I have one comic from 1980 that was given to me by a friend. It is a Marvel Comic, Frances, Brother of the Universe, about St. Francis of Assisi. I can't believe it sold for 75 cents when it came out. Wow! I have really enjoyed flipping through the comics while preparing the packing lists. Sure hope the folks who ultimately end up with them enjoy them as much as we did.
— Frances S., Easton, MD

Hi guys, Here's my latest batch up for trade! Have a good weekend and 4th of July!
— Graham G., Lawrenceville, GA

Thanks! This is a great service!
— Steve B., Sarasota, FL

Although I've placed 40 orders with Mycomicshop, this is my first try at doing a comic trade with you. I look forward to doing more business in the future. You guys are by far the best!
— Daniel G., Salt Lake City, UT

Hi again, Buddy, Thanks so much for the quick response and thanks for switching the payment for my comics to the higher trade credit amount. Now I'm ready to do some comic shopping on your site! Thanks for all your help.
— Tony L., Chicago, IL

I accept your offer. Another box will be shipped out next week.
— Daniel H., Detroit, MI

Hello Buddy! I whole-heartedly approve the trade amount! Thanks very much! Your biggest fan.
— Larry C., Spring Grove, IL

I accept your offer for my comics.
— John D., Vidor, TX

Buddy, Just want to let you know that I used my online trade credit. Everything arrived promptly and in the condition I ordered. Thanks so much! You guys really have a great operation. Thank goodness for the internet and efficient shipping so that I can do trades with you.
— Sean B., Exton, PA

I have traded with Lone Star Comics several times in the past, and it has always been a pleasure doing business with you.
— John W., Las Vegas, NE

Hi Buddy, I accept your offer so please apply this trade credit to my mycomicshop account. Thanks again for a great trade!
— Jeff C., San Antonio, TX

Buddy, The offer is fine. I'll soon have another box of comics en route to you.
— Frances S., Easton, MD

Buddy, Thank you for your response. I will accept your offer of $1,202.80 even though I was hoping for more in the range of $1,500, since I was offered $750 from a comic book store in my area. Again, thank you.
— Steve P., Harleysville, PA

Hey Guys, Here's another batch of trade comics I'd like to send your way!
— Graham G., Lawrenceville, GA

Hey Buddy, Thank you for the reply and helpful info on how you buy comics from sellers. I will try out your www.webuycomics.com site. You guys are great. I have bought a lot of books from you in the past.
— Mark P., Mt. Sinai, NY

Tomorrow I'm sending you another box of comics for an offer. I've sold you comics a few times in the past and was always happy with the results. Thanks.
— Jordan L., Marietta, OH

I am very happy with my purchase. All my issues came just as described. I'll be pleased to do business again with you again real soon-- you know, read'um once for the story, then trade 'um for more stuff to read. It has been nice doing business with you.
— Ben G., Grandbury, TX

I accept your offer for my third lot of comics.
— Dan B., Littleton, CO

One of my favorite weekend activities is reviewing your want list for comics that I can send in for trade credit. I was wondering how often your want list is updated? Thanks for your time. (Buddy replies: Good question, Joel. We update literally minute-by-minute 24-hours a day every day. However, once we approve your comics to ship, your items can't be bumped off our buy/trade list even if they do go off the online want list.)
— Joel P., Milford, OH

I received the communications from you and your staff regarding my credit and cash. Thank you very much! You guys were great to work with and very flexible. I appreciate doing business with you. Now to search through my comics to see if I have anything else I'm ready to trade thruough your buy/trade system. Enjoy your summer!
— Sean B., Exton, PA

Buddy, Your offer sounds reasonable. I accept.
— Kevin F., Metuchen, NJ

Buddy, The offer looks good. Thanks.
— Aaron H., Jefferson, WI

Your offer sounds good to me. I accept.
— Bert S., San Diego, CA

Buddy, The offer for my comics is fine. I am still sorting comics and should soon have another shipment to send. I will work on getting more comics out to you. Thanks.
— Frances S., Easton, MD

I have sent books to you guys before and was always happy with the fast, friendly service. Thanks for everything!
— Lisa S., Tampa, FL