Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

Thanks for the offer on my comics. I accept.
— Steve P., Alta, IA

Offer accepted. Thank you!
— Stephanie M., Minnetonka, MN

Your offer sounds good. I accept. Thanks again!
— Alex S., East Meadow, NY

It's okay, Buddy. I trust you entirely on that one. Thanks for the trade credit for my Atom Age Superman.
— Michael M., St. Bruno Quebec, Canada

Dear Buddy, I just wanted to thank you for being so easy to chat and work with. Thank you also for meeting me in the middle on our pricing of my collection. I hope you turn it quickly! Best of luck to you and your stores!
— Chris T., Brunswick, ME

Hey guys, Thanks for getting back to me on this. I'll definitely accept your offer. Always a pleasure doing business with you. I look forward to working with you some more in the future.
— Jon D., Westminster, CA

Hi Buddy, Thanks for the quick reply. I'll go with the trade credit for the comics I sent. Thanks so much!
— Jeff M., Brownsville, PA

Dear Buddy, Thanks for the offer for my comics. I accept. I also will be sending another box soon.
— Daniel H., Detroit, MI

Hello once again. Along with comics on your want list, I am sending and additional 57 pre-1981 comics for an offer. Thank you as always for offering this wonderful service!!!!
— Donna L., Albuquerque, NM

Thanks again for your trade option! You've given me the opportunity to try tons of other comics that I otherwise would never have read!
— Roderick B., Davenport, VA

I was very pleased with our recent sale to you. I am submitting another lot under "Option #3," so will be including additional pre-1980 comics along with the comics that were on your want list. Please treat them as a single offer lot. Thanks!
— Diane O., Alexandria, VA

I accept your offer for my comics. Thanks.
— Randall E., Two Rivers, WI

I have checked with my sister and we are happy with your offer for our comics. Can we now send more comics? As I mentioned in a previous conversation with you, we probably have 150 to 200 more. Really appreciate you help.
— Frances S., Easton, MD

Hey, Buddy! The offer looks good to me! Thanks!
— Aaron H., Jefferson, WI

Good afternoon Buddy, Thank you for your offer. I will be mailing out the package this Saturday. I have purchased comics from your company in the past, and I have always been impressed with your customer service and the quality of the product. You speak to a great many people over the phone, so I don't expect you to recall, but we shared a conversation some time back (over two years ago)where you were kind enough to speak for quite some time with me about collecting comics. I always appreciated your kindness. I really do not want to part with my books but circumstances dictate that it is time to do so. Take care of yourself and thanks for listening.
— Eric W., Benicia, CA

Once again, I am happily using cash from trades, to get a new stack of books. You guys are the best.
— Brian I., Plymouth, MN

Please credit my account for the amount of your offer as it is acceptable. Thanks.
— Ron M., Holt, MN

That sounds good. And I'm looking for trade credit, not cash, if that is ok. You guys have been good to me for both buying and selling, so I'd rather keep my business where it's appreciated. I'll make a list of my additional comics and get it to you soon. Thanks!
— Scott B., Mobile, AL

Thanks, your offer for my comics is fine.
— Alex S., East Meadow, NY

I'll be dropping my next comic trade lot off at your Hurst store. Love doing business with you guys.
— Matthew S., Chico, TX

Buddy, Again it is a great offer, better than what I found locally. I accept your offer as is. Thank you.
— Bert S., San Diego, CA

Thank you for the offer for my comics. I accept.
— Cindy D., Dallas, OR

Thanks Buddy and mycomicshop.com!!! You recently bought over 100 comics of mine, and now I'm using the credit to buy from your site. It's incredibly easy and fast. Thanks for taking a number of my comics, so I can condense my collection to focus on quality books not quantity of books.
— Joseph C., Irvine, CA

Hey Buddy, Thanks for getting back to me so quickly. Your offer is great. I look forward to getting the check and doing some more business with you in the future. Take care and I'll talk to you soon. (this was Jon's 6th sale to us)
— Jon D., Westminster, CA

You keep buyin' 'em, and I'll keep sendin' em'!
— Wayne H., Chapel Hill, NC

Thank you. I accept your offer for my 2nd lot comics.
— Raymond v., Piedmont, CA

Are you surprised how many comics I've been sending lately via Want List? Yep, it's that magical time again - i.e., going through all my comics and seeing what's on your Want List. One of my most favorite pastimes! Relaxing...AND PROFITABLE! :) Have a great weekend and God Bless.
— James L., California, MD

Hi Buddy, I accept your offer for my comics Thanks and best regards.
— Lynwood T., Anacortes, WA

Buddy, Thanks so much. I accept your offer for my ninth and last batch of comics. Again, thank you so much for all your help with this process. I truly appreciate it.
— Colette R., Montgomery Village, MD

Everything about mycomicshop.com has been outstanding. Trades and sales of comics have been easier and faster than I ever imagined. Thanks for the great service.
— Brian I., Brooklyn Park, MN

Hi guys, Here's another batch of comics for trade. As always, I appreciate the service. This is truly a great program.
— Graham G., Lawrenceville, GA

Buddy, I accept your on-line trade credit offer. Thanks!
— Mike W., Springfield, VA

Hello and thank you for your prompt service. I'm satisfied with your offer and would like to accept it.
— Robert P., Grand Prairie, TX

With my newest batch, I'll also be sending some non-want list pre-1980s comics. Thank you for the many trades/sales we have already had.
— Matt S., Fairlawn, OH

Dear Buddy, Thank you for the reply. I just cashed your check for my previous group on comics. I agree to the price you offered for my newest group. Please send the check at your earliest convince.
— Margaret C., Clifton, NJ

Hi Buddy, I'm real glad you could use a few of my old Dell Giants. I know you are someone who can really appreciate them. Will be sending you some more in the near future. And before I forget, Yes indeed, I as always certainly do accept your kind offer for my comics. Thank you.
— George T., Montpelier, VA

Your offer sounds fine to me. Thanks for making this real easy! I'll be boxing up and mailing more comics down to you.
— Alex S., East Meadow, NY

Hello Buddy and MCS Gang. Along with my T-transaction, I am including a batch of 31 pre-1980 comics for an offer. As always, it has been a great experience doing the trade thang!
— Donna L., Albuquerque, NM

Thanks you, Buddy. I think we?re in for a long business relation!
— Michel M., St. Bruno Quebec, Canada

Your offer for my collection of Classics Illustrated comics is acceptable. Thank you again.
— Tracy B., Watkins Glen, NY

Hello Mr. Saunders, Thank you for your response and trade offer for my comics! I accept. I would like to have you make my payment in the form of Mycomicshop.com credit so I may move forward with additional purchases. Thank you again for your time.
— Matthew H., Attleboro, MA

I accept your cash offer for my comics. On the second box I shipped to you, I have requested online trade credit.
— Kirk H., Springfield, MO

Hi Buddy, It's been great doing business with you. I think your buy/trade offers have been very acceptable, quick and honest. I have plans to continue using this system.
— Donna L., Albuquerque, NM

Dear Lonestar Comics, Thanks for the smooth trade-in process. You guys are great. This entire experience has been wonderful. I just wanted to thank your staff (Buddy and Erin) for their work and emails. I have a question concerning my recent trade which was just checked in on 3/2/07. The trade/sale # is T020785971. I had requested 80%/20% cash/credit initially, but my comics were valued 30% higher than I'd anticipated. I have 5 issues in particular I'm wanting to use store credit towards, but I'd like to "use up" my web credit with this purchase. Would it be possible to change the trade/sale to 90%cash and 10% credit? Thanks in advance for your reply. I'll be sure to authorize the trade-in as soon as I hear back from you. Thank you again for your excellent customer service! NOTE FROM BUDDY: Changing the cash/credit ratio is easy and we are always happy to make such changes when requested.
— Cliff R., Barstow, CA

Offer accepted. Your offer for my comics sounds good.
— Brian A., Foster, WV

Your offer for my comics is accepted.
— Ruth F., Lake Mary, FL

Buddy, The offer for my comics is perfectly acceptable. I hope to do more business in the future. Thank you.
— Andrew S., Nashua, NH

Hi Buddy, Your trade offer sounds great! I accept!
— James L., California, MD

Dear Buddy, Thanks for the offer and yes that is accepted.
— Margaret C., Clifton, NJ

Dear Buddy, I wanted to let you know that I accept your cash offer for my collection of 210 pre-1980 Amazing Spider-Man comics. Thanks for your consideration.
— Neil M., Charleston, WV