Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

Thanks for another great trade and buying experience!
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

My collection is fairly restricted to a very few story lines, although I also collect "odd" stuff occasionally. Your store is by far the best online comics store going. I hope to trade you my "odds and ends" for comics that will flesh out my favored stories.
— Elwood C., Doniphan, MO

I love to read comics. And I love to sell them to you, MyComicShop.
— Sherman E., Brooklyn, NY

Thank you, as always, for the quality of your systems and staff.
— David G., New York, NY

Very satisfied with my results in last night's auction! Please accept these comics for in-house grading and prep for auction. Thanks!
— Gene C., Martinsburg, WV

Speaking from 47 years of serious collecting, I can say that no one rivals MyComicShop in the service and professionalism you provide me and other collectors. Speaking for myself, I have never had so much fun in comics working with Buddy as a buying partner, and that is saying a lot. Your amazing team makes Lone Star Comics run better than a starship!
— Phil H., Carona, CA

I trust your judgment and accept any regrading. You are the experts, not me. All of my transactions have been great with you all.
— Stanley S., Sterling, VA

I love comics and really like the idea of being able to trade out/sell some of the issues I'm not into any longer. I appreciate all you do.
— Justin R., New Castle, PA

My local comic shop recommended your site. I am glad that some of my comics can find a new home. Thanks for buying my comics.
— John C., College Park, MD

I've dealt with you guys since 2013. Never dissatisfied. Thanks!
— Michael G., Knoxville, TN

I would like to thank you for the way you handled my request to sell my comics to you. You not only explained how to go about it, but you also gave me the necessary information to document them and how to pack and ship them. The shipping label you sent made it easy for me to get them to you. I never expected to get a check for an amount that exceed my expectations, but I did. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
— Roy Z., Roseville, MN

Repeat customer for both sales and purchases! Your staff does a great job. Thanks!
— Keith C., McDonough, GA

I've both bought and sold comics to your store in the past and have always been satisfied.
— Samuel A., Raleigh, SC

Thank you for keeping the trade alive!
— Michael A., Richmond, VA

First time seller! I'm eager to turn some of the random comics in my collection into store credit so that I can fill out some runs of titles I'm now collecting!
— James H., Atlanta, GA

I remember the fairness with which you treated my questions and comics sent so here I am again. In further downsizing--and celebration of my 80th Birthday--I came across more comics from 50’s through early 70’s (mostly Whitman, Dell, Gold Key and Charlton). I will get them in the mail to you within the week.
— Harlan G., Fairmont, MN

I have a large collection of comics. However, I am running out of space to keep them all. I want them to find good homes with people who will fully appreciate them. I will be posting more soon.
— Liam M., Murphy, TX

I met Buddy at OAFcon in Norman and he recommended I sell via the Mycomicshop Want List instead of at the table. My total here suggests that he was right
— David E., Oklahoma City, OK

Hello, I've been a customer for a few years. Collected on and off for many years, but the majority of the comics I have now are 2014 or later. I decided to pare down my collection significantly for an upcoming move and thought I'd try the mycomicshop sales option for the first time for these few books that I'll part ways with. I've always been very pleased with the buying side of my transactions.
— Joe N., Leander, TX

Loyal customer for many years. I've bought a lot from you and am looking to sell a little bit back. Thanks.
— Steven B., Sherman Oaks, CA

I've done 60 sale and trade lots with you thus far!!! Thank you so much! I just bought another collection, so I'll be adding to my selling pool!
— Tom M., Martins Ferry, OH

First time trading with you. I've been buying comics from you guys regularly for about a year now. Great working with you as always.
— Ryan D., Chesapeake, VA

I was very happy with the prices my Thor comics brought in your auction and I hope my Avengers meet the criteria for auction, too. Thank you.
— Russell A., Fort Worth, TX

Hey gang, just wanted to say thanks for the new guitar. Here’s the story. Back in the 70s I bagged and boxed a bunch of Marvel comics, four long boxes worth, and had them stored ever since. Finally decide to figure out what to do with them. My comics were in good shape, but not high-grade. I had no real idea what to do with them. Your site provided me a way to sort them, price them, decide on a few gems to get slabbed, and sell at good solid prices. I’ve sold about half the collection now, with a couple of the sales to Lone Star and several consignments through Lone Star. The ones sold to you brought the best prices I’ve gotten and the consignments sold quickly, unlike the eBay experience. While some of the books you graded were kicked up or down a grade, I have found your process to be a fair and easy—and more lucrative than selling the collection whole, parts at a shop, or offering otherwise online. Selling my collection is still a work in progress, but I’m playing a new Martin as I trade one hobby for another, and there’s more money coming in. Thanks much.
— Ron P., Seattle, WA

Thank you for making it easy to sell off the comics I no longer want in my collection!
— John B., Santa Barbara, CA

I have purchased items from you for more than 20 years. I have always found your prices fair and your customer service exemplary.
— David P., Staten Island, NY

As always, it’s a pleasure to do business with you. Keep up the good work.
— David G., New York, NY

Just wanted to say I have only gotten into comics the past year or so and I have found your site immensely helpful for learning more about them.
— Matthew K., Chagrin Fall, OH

I have used your services before and you have never been disappointed.
— Chris L., Waterville, ME

I'm currently negotiating for a group of comics being sold by a local resident. Just a quick note to you that the most exciting part is NOT finding and seeing the books. It's not even the check I'll get from you. The excitement comes from knowing that I'm going to get to deal with you (Buddy), your crew, and actually finding out what the books are worth! That's where the "rush" comes in. Thought you'd like to know you're so well thought of, and actually, "revered". Dealing with you is the BEST part of all of my many transactions. Dealing with mycomichop/Lone Star Comics is one of the highlights of my life! PS: I've NEVER been disappointed with a Lone Star deal...EVER!
— Gary M., Huntington, WV

I love your site! I have multiples of many comics from the late 70's up and I am so happy you will purchase them.
— Carlos N., Silver Spring, MD

Love your trade option!
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

My whole experience selling my collection (in two shipments) has been very painless and satisfying. It is a sort of stressful thing to sell such a large collection, but you made it relatively easy and I think you have been very fair. Thank you again, Jon, Ben, Shane and the rest of your staff. I would recommend you heartily to any collector looking to sell their comics.
— Robert S., Davis, CA

I'm so happy I found your site. I cherished every one of my comics and they were one of the few childhood things I held onto. Now it's time for another collector to enjoy them. I will be sure to refer you to others.
— Lyn W., Miami, FL

I have heard only good things about your business and I am looking forward to trade my comics here. I have confidence in your honest grading of my collection and I definitely hope to keep doing business with you (both as a seller and buyer). Thanks!
— Sarah K., Urbandale, IA

This is the first time I've mailed in comics to MyComicShop.com. I have a few friends who have bought and sold comics with you and they highly recommend your service. I'm looking forward to buying and selling comics with all of you for years to come.
— Chris P., Spartanburg, NC

Thanks for such an easy-to-use website! I enjoyed going through all the comics I bought when I was a kid and seeing which ones are in demand today. I hope whoever buys them from you enjoys them!
— Shayne H., Lawrence, KS

First time selling to y'all. I am currently trimming down my collection. I also have a wish list with mycomicshop. Then I saw that I could sell--to you, a Texas-based shop! Yours is a really easy recording system.
— Vanessa N., Harlingen, TX

Always great buying from you and selling to you. Thanks again.
— Johnny S., Stoneham, MA

I'm a long time Mycomicshop buyer and fan since the 1989 Batman movie.
— Dan B., Austin, TX

Here's another batch of comics and magazines for your review. I've decided to go for trade credit this time because you've made me catch the comic bug all over again! There are a few items I definitely want to purchase when I receive store credit. Thank you!
— Ernie R., Orange, CT

Thank you for always being fair on your grading of my books.
— Robert J., Viera, FL

This is my second time selling to you. The first time was super easy.
— Michael A., Fort Worth, TX

Hello, Buddy and crew! I have got to tell you, my experience trading comics with you has been a real treat. I have done enough trades with you that I'm now eligible to use your consolidation trade option, and oh, what a GREAT IDEA! It is, literally, the PERFECT option. I have 20,000+ comics in my selling pool. Without your system, selling would be tedious and time consuming. But using your system, I just make a selling lot for the comics that go on your want list each day, then combine the lists into a single lot when its time to ship. Thanks for having the preeminent site for true comic fans, I'm literally on your site every day and it is a blast!
— David B., Delphos, OH

Thanks again for trade credit! Always a wonderful experience with Lone Star Comics. Buddy and his team are the best!
— David B., Delphos, OH

Hello! This is my first time trying to sell my comic books. Just trying to downsize my collection a little bit and found your website to be extremely useful. Looking forward to working with you!
— Matthew S., Chicago, IL

Thank you so much to your staff for their patience and kindness. I inherited these comic books and was not sure what to do with them. It's been a smooth process thus far!
— Christina V., Mansfield, TX

Thanks for making it so easy to trade and sell comics on your site. I have never been disappointed with you guys!
— David B., Delphos, OH

This I my third time sending my comics to you. Though it is the first time I’m choosing store credit so that’s exciting for me!
— Darcy B., Albright, WV

I'm a first time comic seller! I recently inherited 200+ comics from a family friend who had been collecting since he was a young boy. I'm trying to figure out the best/easiest way to go about selling them and in my research you guys were heavily recommended! Looking forward to doing more business in the future!
— Grace L., Seattle, WA