Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

I've done a few trades with you fine folks before. Starting to go through storage and I intend to trade a lot more comics with you for credit over the next few months as I sort through.
— Peter N., Gardena, CA

Thanks so much for your offers on my books. I can't tell you how grateful I am. My Fantastic Four #48 came in at the Fine price, and that my grades for the other books held up. Thanks so much for your excellent service! I was very happy, too, by the way, with the first consignment check. It was definitely a fair price! I am hoping for the best with the rest of the consignment pieces and the auction items. The payments for the books that you have bought will go a long way to relieving some of my stress.
— Vince P., Grand Junction, CO

Thank you for taking the time to look at my early 1950s comic lot, and thank you for your offer which I accept. I'll make sure to send anybody your way if they have any comic books!
— Chris S., Roundrock, TX

I have never sold my comics before. Any mistakes doing so is kind of traumatic for me because my comics have emotional value for me. I have been collecting and loving comics for 50 years. Everybody I have talked to on the phone at your company has been great. Thank you.
— Anne P., Hancock, MI

I just received my check from the previous transaction, Now I'm ready to send my next sales batch of comics! It is my hope that we can keep the pattern going for a while!
— Matthew M., Hattiesburg, MS

I absolutely love the trade option you provide! I finally get to use the stuff I've been saving forever for "someday" to get comics to fill holes in my collection. Thanks!
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

Glad to find your firm. My good friend Mary S. just sold several hundred comics to you all and was very pleased. The comics I am now offering for sale have been in our family forever - they are mostly from the 30's, 40's, and early 50's.
— William H., Dallas, TX

I have had several dealings with you guys and they have always left me more than pleased. :) I love comics - always have - and you all clearly do too. Thanks for making this guy in Montana very happy and very broke! hahaha :)
— Joe S., Bosemanm, MT

Wow! What a great trade, thanks for accepting! I have more super-hero related items that I will be listing and submitting to you. I'll have all the holes in my collection plugged in no time. :)
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

Thanks for the great job you do. Very fast and accurate service every time - buying or selling.
— Patrick L., Mobile, AL

Thanks, you guys! I always love working with you all.
— Margaret L., Hoover, AL

My father started this collection for me when I was a kid. These comics have been sitting untouched for close to 30 years. I selected the "Very Fine" condition for many of these because I could not tell if the comic was perfect, but I genuinely feel like many are near mint or mint condition. I trust your judgment regarding final grades. I was simply planning to inventory the comics when I came across your website. I loved that it had a picture of each comic. It made life so much easier inputting them. It's also great to know that while only about one-fourth of them are on your want list the moment, more go on your want list daily. I look forward to doing more business with you.
— Jose M., Dixon, CA

Trading comics with you by way of your want list trade option is getting to be a habit (within a habit)! Best Wishes!
— Brett G., Milwaukee, WI

It was really nice to speak with you today and I appreciate your call. I'm glad we made a deal as I felt very comfortable with your offer for my Silver Age comics. Thanks again. It was a pleasure doing business with you.
— Steve P., Marietta, GA

A pleasure to do business with you guys, as always.
— Robert J., Viera, FL

Love your site and the ease in using it!
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

Hi Buddy, Got your check today in payment for my 100 DC and Marvel Slurpee cups. Thank you so much for being so patient with me. You have no idea how much this helps me.
— Suzanne S., Bullhea, AZ

I was so excited when I found your site. No longer did I have to search for particular issues for days, if not months. This is my first time trading with you guys, and I know you'll do right by me. I'm planning on getting some trade credit because I've had some comics in my cart for a while now. Anyways, keep up the good work.
— Dominic G., Ozone Park, NY

Received the check today. Nice doing business with you.
— Dawn O., Lemmon, SD

Great service!
— Stephen D., Downy, CA

I recently sold a stack of my most treasured comic books. I am still in shock at the tiny amount I was given for them. I wish I had sent them to you first. Thanks bunches, my fellow comic book enthusiast!
— Lyle S., Salt Lake City, UT

I completed my Ghost Rider volume 2 set and ALL the ancillary secondary story lines with the help of you guys. You are great and very easy to deal with. Thanks!
— David C., Montvale, NJ

Glad I found your site. These are my son's comic books and all the proceeds will go to him. I was uncertain how to grade most of them, so I chose the green grade. Thank you!
— Alain M., San Jose, CA

Time to swap out some comics and grab some credit. I believe this is my second time with your trade service but lots of happy orders in the past!
— Christian M., Colcheste, VT

I had several trade transactions with you guys years ago and everything was handled great. I've decided to start selling off more of my collection, so I knew I would make my way back to you guys sooner or later. Great service, indeed!
— Matthew M., Hattiesburg, MS

Looking forward to another excellent transaction!
— Michael R., Auburn, NY

I sold several thousand comics to you a few years ago. I was treated very fairly and that is why I am back. It is time now to sell my better books to you.
— Rich B., Detroit Lakes, MN

Thank you for your prompt evaluation and payment for our comic book collection. We packaged up our collection and mailed it to your company with our contact information. You called us to explain the offer and handled the whole transaction in a very professional matter. We recommend your company to anyone who is interested in selling a comic book collection.
— Rob and Jean D., Virginia Beach, VA

It's a wonderful service that you guys provide here!
— Mark M., Tempe, AZ

I have made deals with you in the past and I have been happy with your grading, so let's keep it going. Here's another batch of comics.
— Raul R., Tempe, AZ

I've done business with you before, in the long ago past. You are more than fair and great to work with. Expect many more transactions from me.
— Matthew F., Hertford, NC

Your auctions continue to be the highlight of my collecting. Along with the Amazing Spider-Man 74 and Harvey 4, I would like to send Incredible Hulk 194 CGC 7.0 and ASM 359 CGC 9.2. Keep the comics rolling on your auctions. We all still have a lot of holes to fill in our collections.
— Marc T., Fort Walton Beach, FL

These comics will fill another box that's coming to you for buy/trade! By the way, the 7 comics I won in your May auction are slated to arrive tomorrow. I'm really looking forward to them!
— Chuck W., Lake Buena Vista, FL

I love your site!
— Samuel S., Tuscon, AZ

I don't know if you remember, but back in March I had a conversation with you on the phone. I advised I was sending in a bunch of my comics so I could get an Amazing Fantasy 15 at my local comic shop, but it was on the condition that I pay it off in three months. So over the next two months, I sold some of my other comics in your auctions. I ended up with the cash I needed plus some. So thanks to you, I will be the proud owner of an Amazing Fantasy 15 CGC 4.5 in about two weeks!
— Keith O., Pittsburgh, PA

This sales batch starts a new box! By the way, when I got up this AM, I saw that you had posted various lower grade post-WWII comics last night. Some scarce funny animal, etc. So, I ordered about half a dozen! Looking forward to getting them.
— Chuck W., Lake Buena Vista, FL

I'm clearing out closet space, and from past experience, I know that dealing with MCS will be smooth and painless.
— Mike A., Alexandria, VA

I heard so many positive things about your site. That is the reason I want to join in the party and do business with your company. Beyond those I'm listing in my first offer to you, I have thousands more comics. I hope we can be successful doing business together.
— Lam T., Seattle, WA

Buddy, my youngest daughter comes home from the university on Sunday. One of her summer jobs will be to help me reorganize some 25,000 comics that I have picked up to sell or trade to you. I am going to do a deep reorganization including using your bar code scan option for item entry. I want to be able to send you 2,000 books a month.
— Phil H., Corona, CA

I am looking forward to continuing business with mycomicshop. I have purchased quite a few comics from you and you are my absolute favorite. I am looking forward to using my trade money toward the latest Guardians of the Galaxy run.
— Zac C., Brunswick, OH

I've been selling my comic collection through My Comic Shop for the past couple years now, and I wanted to thank you for making the process so easy. You've implemented a great system that takes so much of the guesswork (and just plain work) out of selling comics. Thank for your help.
— Ali L., Puyallup, WA

This is my second shipment of romance comics for sale to you. I was pleased with the outcome of the first sale. Your website and method of buying items from sellers is superb.
— Ben C., Cincinnati, OH

I would like to put all of these comics in the June monthly auction. I just sold similar copies of all of these books in your April auction and was happy with the results, so I hope to continue doing the same most months going forward! Thanks for the great service!
— Adam A., Fairfax Station, VA

More comics for you to buy! Opened another one of my "ancient" boxes, sealed since the 1980s. Had a bunch of UK Captain Britains in it. All are unread file copies with fairly minor storage flaws.
— Chuck W., Lake Buena Vista, FL

Just wanted to say this is my third transaction with you, and it has been great doing business with you!
— Bryan B., Round Lake, IL

I know we just finished one trade deal with you, but as I continue liquidating, your system helps me get boxes moved in a timely manner, and this time, the trade value will help me fill in gaps in the collections of several friends!
— Aaron C., Chandler, AZ

You guys are awesome.
— Charles D., Sanford, FL

When I've got a moment, I'm going to rave about you over on Trustpilot - you're the best! Hippity hoppity!
— Brett G., Miwaukee, WI

Hi, Thanks for making my first transaction super-easy. Here's round TWO!
— Shawn F., Los Angeles, CA

I'm happy to find a home for my magazines. Online recording was very easy! I have no experience in grading comics but will trust your judgment.
— Emily K., Pittsburgh, PA