Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

Buddy! It's been a pleasure sending you bundle after bundle of comic books for offers. Your website is extremely easy to work with. The process of selecting comics to sell is quick and actually kinda fun! Thanks for the phone chat last week regarding my 16 long boxes. I'm looking forward to sending them your way as well!
— Fernando O., New York, NY

I have been collecting comics since the mid-80's and have amassed a pretty good collection. The short boxes have overtaken my basement and it was time to "thin the herd." I took some of my long boxes over to my local store, but all they offered was $20 a box. I tried different other selling options including web sites hoping to sell my comics at a reasonable price. No luck until I stumbled across you folks. My wishes came true. Thus far I have loaded a quarter of my comic collection into your database and I am happy with the prices I have been offered. It is a little bit of a learning curve on grading, but I'm getting there. I just sent my second box and there will be more on the way. Thanks for awesome service and fair pricing!
— Matt J., Haverhill, MA

I'm not a dealer, just a reader who wants her garage back, so I suspect my grading is off. I hope your buyers enjoy these as much as I did.
— Eva V., Alameda, CA

I found a few more comics to sell to you. I was very pleased with our previous transactions. Thanks.
— George H., Sevierville, TN

I liked the ordering process and, of course, I liked that I could use my trade credit to pay for the entire thing including the shipping and tax. I am looking forward to getting these comics and to doing more trading! Thanks.
— Rex E., McKinney, TX

You guys are fantastic! Thank you so much for all you do!
— Lindsey L., Bushnell, FL

Thanks for offering such a great service in looking up comic book pricing and being able to list them.
— Matthew W., Doylestown, PA

Thanks so much for having the trade for credit option. I absolutely love it! It's helped me to downsize a lot of miscellaneous stuff I've collected over the years and fill in various spots in my collection. I also always keep my eyes open for items when I'm out and about.
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

Thanks Buddy! You guys are great! I just sent off one last short box. With that I will have sold everything to you. Thanks for being so awesome and easy to work with!
— James L., Columbus, OH

Love your trade option!
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

I appreciate your honesty and I am pleased with the way the sale went regarding your purchase of my comics and Edgar Rice Burroughs book collection.
— Linda W., Duncan, OK

I just discovered your website and am very impressed with your company and prices! So excited to be doing business with you, and hoping you can find some great new homes for my books!
— Tessa S., Anahein, CA

You guys and girls are the best!
— Sarah H., Southington, CT

Mr. Saunders, Just received your check. Was happy about the amount paid for my comics. Once I finish a project I'm doing, I'll put together more boxes.
— Greg K., Saint Louis, MO

I wanted to let you know that I just got the check in the mail. It was a pleasure working with you. You made selling my comic so easy. I really felt like the process was fair to both you and me. I still have 30 CGC graded books and I will be in touch when I am ready to sell those. Thanks for your promptness.
— Mark G., Des Moines, Iowa

Buddy, I received your check and want to thank you again for the purchase and for reimbursing part of the shipping costs.
— Holly K., Murfreesboro, TN

Thanks for your excellent continued service and fair pricing for the comics I have sent in.
— Adam N., Manassas, VA

I love your service!
— Daryl T., Lake Worth, FL

Thank you, Buddy, for making what I considered an extremely fair offer for my Golden Age comics. I was very pleasantly surprised, as you could no doubt tell by my reaction.
— Gary M., King, NC

Hi Buddy, Everything looks good. The total of $644 matches with my numbers based on your earlier per book offer. Thank you for another smooth transaction. It’s truly a pleasure working with you and your fantastic team!
— Zachary A., Dallas, TX

Hi Buddy, Thank you for your time in putting together an offer for my comics, an offer which I accept.
— Art H., Aspen, CO

Your buying partner, Phil, came over last week and went through my collection to see what it was worth. It was pretty much bronze and copper editions, but he checked the boxes pretty thoroughly. Honestly, I was sorry to see everything go, but I'm super happy with your offer. Phil was really nice and a pleasure to do business with. I'm so glad your company exists. You helped remove the stress of wondering what the heck I was going to do with this mess of comics. Tell Phil I said hi and thank you both so much for the quick response.
— Liz K., Los Angeles, CA

I received the payment for my comics. I appreciate the business we are doing. Best wishes and a productive rest of 2017 to you.
— Long N., Everett, WA

I recently sold my childhood comic book collection to Buddy Saunders at My Comic Shop. I dealt directly with Buddy. He patiently explained my options for selling the collection. After providing a listing of the collection, Buddy immediately made an offer. He then requested sample scans of some of the older titles. After receiving the scans, Buddy increased his offer. I shipped my comics on a Monday and by the next Monday I received a check for the agreed upon amount. Throughout the entire process, Buddy was professional and fair. Five stars for My Comic Shop and Buddy Saunders!
— Thomas R., Belleville, IL

Selling to you has been a great experience. You are running a fantastic and professional service. I was glad to send my Dad's 1950's EC collection to you with no worries.
— Lance S., Newman, CA

Thanks Buddy & Co.! Looking forward to putting together another consolidated comic batch to trade to you.
— Brett G., Milwaukee, WI

Your company is very good to work with.
— David D., Mechanicsburg, PA

I have been collecting comics since age seven. Now that my kids are grown, I'm going back and collecting things I wanted when I was a kid. Your service is helping me do that! Thank you SO MUCH!
— John G., Rochester, MN

This is my first time selling to you. Your customer testimonials have convinced me to give it a try.
— Thomas L., Douglasville, GA

Hi Buddy, I accept your offer of $2,556.00 for my early 1940s comics. I do appreciate your being frank with me regarding my initial grading of the first shipment, and feel that you have been very fair with me during this whole process. Your patience with my inexperience, and informing me of the options available to me, meant a lot. Thank you for that. I will always keep that in mind, and remember the courtesy you extended to me. I will also gladly point anyone with comics in your direction.
— Harlan G., Fairmont, NE

Mycomicshop is absolutely amazing! There is no better place to trade comics. Thanks for helping me build my DC collection!
— Joshua W., Broken Arrow, OK

Thank you so much for the quick reply and resolution! This is why your company is at the top of the industry. Again, thank you very much and I will most definitely be placing another order soon.
— Michael H., Tallahassee, TN

I should be able to drop off the comics I'm listing for sale through your online system. Will be n Arlington on Monday. Thanks again for all your help and great service.
— Chris C., Greenville, TX

I am going to deposit the $13,500 check you gave me for my Marvel collection, but I do it with regret that I did not take you up on your consignment option. I did not realize how much I will miss not being part of the comic book world and working with your organization for a little longer. I think it would have been exciting watching some of the books on auction. This is my failure and I wanted to thank you for our meeting and tour of your premises.
— David M., Colorado Springs, CO

This would be a small everyday trade for you, but it is my biggest yet. (Due to my putting things off rather than a great all-at-once strike.) Thanks to all the packers and pickers that make it possible.
— James S., Boxboro, MA

I'm blown away by how comprehensive and easy to use your website is! thanks for that. My Heavy Metal magazines have always been kept in original Heavy Metal binders purchased from the publisher, and the binders were laid flat, not stored upright on shelf.... tried to take good care of them so they may be in better condition than listed. :)
— Madja K., Reading, PA

Your trade option is my favorite! As I'm going through and re-organizing and re-evaluating my collection I can trade with you what I no longer want to fill in gaps elsewhere. I love it! Thanks!
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

Site was easy to use, as always.
— Joseph R., East Greenbush, NY

Hi Buddy, Just spoke to your assistant and accepted your offer for the comics. I wanted to thank you again for all your assistance with this and, especially, for reviewing the comics for additional value once you had them in hand. If you need an endorsement on your website, I will be happy to do one in greater detail.
— Doug P., Fort Myers, FL

You guys are my new favorite place to buy comics. I appreciate the work you put in to your quality services!
— John G., Rochester, MN

Great job, everyone! Ex-sell-see-your!
— Ben K., Benbrook, TX

I super appreciate you guys and what you do.
— John G., Rochester, MN

Thanks for having a store credit option, love it!
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

Sending y'all books is always a pleasure! It's so darn easy. Oh, and one thing that needs mentioning is the beauty of the Mycomicshop website! The way the user can change the header is so underrated and FUN! I adjust it frequently depending upon what I'm reading at the time. Right now I have it set to Green Lantern as I'm on a Green Lantern re-read through. But I love that we can change it, and great choices too! Thanks for everything!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

One of the best shops to buy and sell comics & graphic novels. Thanks a bunch!
— Timothy M., Christiansburg, VA

Thanks again for always expediting my transactions as quickly as you do. Have a blessed day.
— Chris C., Greenville, TX

Hi Buddy, the first Golden Age collection I ever bought was about a hundred books of all types back around 1966. I got some stunning Walt Disney's Comic and Stories from about #12-29. I have loved those WWII era WDC&S ever since. Was therefore thrilled to get three of the WWII era WDC&S from your auction that closed last Monday! They are in transit and should arrive Tuesday or so.
— Chuck W., Lake Buena Vista, FL

Always a pleasure doing business with you.
— Sean T., Canton, MI

I have had good experiences in the past selling to mycomicshop. Now looking forward to another round of selling. This time I would like credit so that I can purchase some comics for my private collection.
— Fredrick C., Yorktown, VA

Thank you so much for being so easy to work with!
— John G., Rochester, MN